Solving Simulation Complexity
Although HPC has helped solve important problems in nuclear physics, earth sciences, meteorology, etc. since the 1960s, HPC has traditionally existed only for specialists. But, with the democratization of x86 servers, large storage systems, and high-end networking technologies, companies and research facilities can now buy clusters at a reasonable ratio (power/cost) with very powerful, complex technologies or get access to remote HPC cloud platforms.
However, even though the resources are available, widespread use has been limited due to the difficulties in accessing and using the resources and/or adapting existing HPC software and hardware that still exist. Back in the nineties, researchers could spend time getting used to those hurdles, but today business ROI drives engineers and researchers to produce results in much less time. As a result, overcoming the HPC access and usability hurdles has become crucial and this has been further exacerbated by the fact that many more users of large-scale platforms are not specialists of HPC use and programming.
This article addresses the need for HPC to become a tool that’s as simple and transparent as possible so that small and medium businesses (SMBs) can easily access the resources of mid-sized clusters and use complex applications on hybrid HPC resources. To achieve this without extensive financial outlay, end users need to execute and control the simulation of applications and data directly from their desktops.
The HPC Challenge for the Smaller Business
While R&D labs and large companies may be accustomed to accessing and exploiting large computing infrastructures, small-to-medium-businesses and smaller business units within large companies that have no dedicated computing resources or HPC experts must now deal with increasing amounts and complexity of data. These smaller groups cannot afford to abandon the advantages HPC provides, but need a way to access the processing power and capabilities that mid-sized clusters offer. This need for readily available “super applications” is first referred to by Dr. Erik Deumens, Director of Research Computing at the University of Florida in his paper “What Drives Investment in the Middle of HPC?” to describe simulations that run on mid-sized computing clusters that are fully accessible on the end-user desktop.
At an international scale, some countries have tried to address this through various resources. In France, INRIA, BPI (the French public investment bank), and GENCI launched “Initiative HPC-PME” (http://www.initiative-hpc-pme.org/), an initiative aiming at providing knowledge, funds, and computing resources to enable simulation software to be powered on HPC resources for SMBs. Free Field Technologies, a French SME, participated in this program and in this testimonial, they present how improved simulation times of HPC helped them win Airbus as a customer.
In Europe, “Fortissimo” was (http://www.fortissimo-project.eu/index.html) launched in October 2013. In this initiative, SMBs needing HPC computation gain access to the resources of a research lab and a computing facility. SMEs like Pipistrel, for example, are using these HPC facilities to improve their simulations of lightweight aircraft designs.
In Silicon Valley, ÜberCloud (http://www.theubercloud.com/hpc-experiment/), launched by Burak Yenier and Wolfgang Gentzsch, was established to show how the SaaS (Software-as-a-Service) model can be used for HPC simulation. A number of large companies, software providers, and computing facilities have now implemented these technologies:
- “High-resolution Computer Simulations of Blow-off in Combustion Systems” involving CSE, a US-based company
- “Drifting Snow Around Arbitrary Structures” where end-users were SMEs like Binkz. Inc, a Canadian Based company
- “Performance Analysis of GROMACS Molecular Dynamics for Simulating Enzyme Substrate” with the Indian SME called Polyclone Bioservices, and the second one has been released last week with use-cases about, or in the field of biology with a use case around.
Moving the Needle Forward
Although these advances have been implemented by some of these initiatives, there’s a need to take the solution further, to provide broad-scale access to many users. To understand what’s needed, let’s first take a look at what these users have in common.
All these different types of users need to upload their data, launch (large-scale) non-interactive simulations, and post-process them. This workflow might be business- or research-centered, but for both communities, there’s a very real need to get better results faster. This need far outweighs knowing if the computation involves using GPUs, fat nodes, or an ultra-fancy middleware designed specially for their purpose.
A preamble of all these tasks is access to the applications. The SaaS (Software-as-a-Service) model does fit with this goal. Through the browser we use every day to check our e-mail or visit websites, we can also work on complex and resource-demanding applications.
What barriers do SMBs need removed from HPC?
The ability to create structures that allow non-technical users to directly access hybrid resources is essential. Here we explore the characteristics of a web portal that would enable SMBs to easily gain access to them.
Simplified universal access—To accommodate bandwidth, the interface must be as light as possible: no browser plugins, no java applets, no flash support, or port opening required. By stripping out all of these dependencies, the interface becomes “vanilla”—able to interface with the researcher’s smart phone, desktop, or tablet regardless of its operating system.
Fig. 1 Example of interface providing access to user’s projects and his previous works
Secured access—Small businesses also need secure access. There’s been a lot of discussion about what should be used—X.509 certificates, login and passwords, SSH public and private keys. In fact, there is no standard way of achieving security. It depends heavily on the policies you want to set-up.
Inside the clusters, you could use any of these methods. But from the user’s point of view, the processes must be unified with at least a login and password that then manages every security system underneath. By doing this, the interface reduces the barrier for the end-user.
And, transfers must be, of course, encrypted to ensure no disseminations to competitors for example.
Familiar file structure—When uploading data or dealing with the HPC computing facilities, users need something that’s familiar, that doesn’t change their habits, such as classical files managers of Windows or FTP clients. This ensures that users can process vast amounts of data without having to take an excessive amount of time to prepare the files and to post process the results afterwards.
Remote Visualization—Today, computing facilities provide both computing and graphical resources. To be able to run non-interactive computations and to then do graphical post-processing on the same site is a great improvement for end-users. If the workflow interface runs fluently from computation into post-processing, then users no longer have to go onsite and disturb administrators to transfer video streams. Instead they can use remote desktop technologies from the same interface to bridge from simulation to graphical post-processing without any additional requirements.
Link with the previous capability, e.g. simplified data transfers, the traditional workflow consisting of input simulation data staging, processind and post-processing can be run in a drastically reduced timeframe.
Fig. 2 File management interface allowing users to transfer to and from the computing resources
Simplified graphical interface—While there are many ways to access applications—home-made scripts, proprietary code, web portals—the interface needs to offer users a way to define specific parameters or modify scripts depending on the outputs they seek. This management of applications has to be as simple as possible and take the least amount of time.
The idea of using XML files to define any kind of interfaces was vogue for a while, but such interfaces were quickly recognized as just hype since they were not productive. Instead, what’s needed is a graphical tool that provides a way to design the interface that the end-users will use to interact with the scripts that execute their applications.
In designing graphical interface access, it’s easy to go overboard and provide full access to scripts and the underlying plumbing, which adds to system complexity. Well-defined and flexible right management must be provided. Only users developing scripts should be allowed to add, update, and modify applications, and only managers should be able to access usage reporting, user management, etc.
Streamlined—As shown in Figure 3, integrating an application should be no more complex than defining a script to execute, some documentation, and the input parameters the user must provide. A specific form directing the application use can then launch for the end-user. This efficiency helps the user concentrate on the most important part of their task—running the simulation with good input data.
Fig. 3 Web interface providing an easy way to design submission forms for non-interactive applications
Billing the user—Once a framework provides access to data and the applications and links these to a global, simple-to-use workflow, the resources need to be monitored and time spent needs to be easily allocated to cost centers. Whether computing hours are divided between certain computing facilities or allocated to business units in companies, clear and precise accounting must detail who had access to the applications and resources.
Usage reporting also needs to be available in a digital format that interfaces to accounting packages for invoice creation or be integrated into existing quota systems. Figure 4 shows an interface presenting accounting and monitoring of resources and applications usage that are the basis of billing and invoicing.
Fig. 4 Usage statistics showing the consumption of a project on different clusters
It is through these types of improvements and simplifications that SMB employees will gain access to HPC simulation. With such a simplified interface to powerful complex resources, businesses will boost productivity and be able to efficiently do their high-end computational work in much less time.
Removing HPC complexity from the game, streamlines data analysis and simulation for the SMBs, ensuring maximum productivity and increasing competitiveness.
About the Author
David Loureiro is the CEO and co-founder of SysFera, a software innovator that simplifies management and accessibility of high performance computing (HPC) environments. David holds a Master of Science in Applied Mathematics and started his career at INRIA working on distributed grid and cloud middleware in the INRIA research team called Avalon. His research interests are focused on cloud technologies, HPC resource management, distributed computing and scientific visualization web portals.