The Leading Source for Global News and Information Covering the Ecosystem of High Productivity Computing
Blog: From the Editor
From the Editor | Main Blog Index
August 24, 2007
Beyond Multicore
If you thought computing was just getting interesting with four cores, what happens when the chipmakers start delivering 100-core chips with multiple types of processing units? In this week's issue, the High End Crusader (HEC) returns, delivering the first of a three part series about the future of parallel computing and heterogeneous processing. For those of you not familiar with HEC, he's an HPC insider who has been a regular contributor to HPCwire. He remains anonymous so he can speak freely in this public forum. Anonymous or not, HEC always has an interesting take on which way the cutting-edge of computing is slicing.
In part one, HEC describes the current state of affairs of high-end computing and gives us a glimpse of the road ahead. In parts two and three he will argue that the community needs to reconceptualize both parallel computing and heterogeneous processing as we move toward what he refers to as "nanocore" -- that is, the point at which processors exceed 64 cores. This is the level at which HEC believes "wholly innovative microarchitectural strategies are required to scale further." The 64-core inflection point he's referring to applies to general-purpose processor architecture, not simpler GPU or DSP architectures, which already have core counts at this scale and above.
While increased core count will make systems much more powerful, heterogeneity will make them more intelligent. In truth, heterogeneous computing has come to mean many things. Traditionally it refers to matching different types of processor architectures -- scalar, vector, multithreaded, etc. -- to the types of workloads that are most suited to them. So, for example, an application that needs to do matrix multiplication along with some non-arithmetic control logic might best be served with a system that encompassed both GPUs and CPUs. Other forms of heterogeneity involve the architecture of the memory hierarchy and the programming mechanisms that tie the various hardware models together.
On the multicore front, we're already starting to see some early attempts at nanocore. This week Tilera announced TILE64, a 64-core chip aimed at the high performance embedded computing market. With an architecture that is reminiscent of Intel's 80-core terascale processor prototype, TILE64 has an 8x8 grid of general-purpose processing cores (tiles) connected via an on-chip network, called iMesh. Tilera's press release claims that it has achieved a scalable architecture significantly beyond current multicore processors:
Because the aggregate bandwidth is orders of magnitude greater than a bus and the distance between cores is shorter, the iMesh technology can be leveraged to create grids as large or small as an application requires, creating a "computing-by-the-yard" scalability...
By including a communication switch on each core, the processor is able to achieve 27 terabits per second of aggregate on-chip bandwidth. At 1 GHz and just 300 milliwatts per core, the whole (32-bit) processor can reach 192 gigaops. This is just a fraction of Intel's one-plus teraflop of performance for their 80-core terascale prototype, but to some extent that's comparing apples to oranges. However, both vendors do take advantage of a tiled arrangement of relatively simple processing cores connected by a 2D mesh to achieve much higher levels of performance than the current crop of commodity processors.
As core count gets into the triple digit range, the on-chip network performance becomes relatively more important than the performance of the individual computational units. The result will be that more silicon logic and power consumption will be devoted to the internal interconnect and off-chip memory access. HEC, in particular, points out that we we're going to have to start paying a lot more attention to power consumption associated with the communication elements as these components start to dominate the system architecture.
For its part, Intel has stated its plans to bring the x86 ISA into HEC's nanocore world, not just with high core counts, but with some elements of heterogeneous computing thrown in as well. Nehalem, the company's next-generation microarchitecture will have a heterogeneous-friendly architecture that will be able to put GPU cores or perhaps other types of acceleration units on-chip. But Nehalem will probably top out at 8 cores.
Intel's terascale effort, which should be commercially viable in the 2010 timeframe, represents the company's intention to place hundreds of cores on the same processor die. At least some of these cores will be x86 compatible. But Intel has also talked about incorporating "special-purpose" computational engines for workloads like signal processing, graphics or network security. It's likely that Intel's contribution to the PSC/Carnegie Mellon NSF petascale Track 1 bid involved some form of this terascale chip.
Cray, as the extreme example of the high performance system vendor, is fully committed to move beyond multicore in both core count and heterogeneity. So far, it has only proposed loosely coupled heterogeneous systems that encompass scalar, vector, multithreading and FGPA processors. It is also actively working on the all-important system software that makes heterogeneous processing accessible to the application developer.
But unless the economic model for processor manufacturing gets turned on its head, system vendors will need to rely on the big chipmakers (e.g., Intel, IBM, AMD, NVIDIA, Sun Microsystems) to supply heterogeneity at the chip level. The expense of microprocessor R&D and the cost of fabs has created a rather exclusive club of chip manufacturers. Of the big chip vendors, only Intel and AMD have shown an inclination to pursue the heterogeneous path -- not counting IBM and its Cell processor, which wasn't really intended to be used for hosting disparate workloads.
While it's unlikely that processor manufacturing will get turned on its head anytime soon, it's possible that nanocore will turn it on its side. Imagine a semiconductor manufacturing technology that allowed system vendors to order customized processors from chip manufacturers. So, for example, an OEM who had a contract with an oil & gas company to provide systems for seismic simulations could specify a chip with, say, 80 GPUs and 20 CPUs. Maybe even user-designed cores could be included. While a customized processor is likely to be more expensive than a standard one, the value proposition seems pretty compelling when you're talking about a 100-core chip.
That's just one example of how the next wave of parallel processing and heterogeneous computing could radically alter the IT ecosystem. Certainly both software vendors and hardware manufacturers will be in for some big changes in the years ahead. Get ready for an interesting ride.
-----
As always, comments about HPCwire are welcomed and encouraged. Write to me, Michael Feldman, at editor@hpcwire.com.
Posted by Michael Feldman - August 24 @ 12:00AM
(Digg, Technorati, more)
Sponsored Links
New Paper: Parallel Computing Without Parallel Programming
Learn how domain experts can run VHLL programs like MATLAB® on a variety of high-performance platforms without low-level reprogramming and how to work with the largest datasets and complex algorithms without sacrificing ease of use or reducing productivity.
Michael Feldman
Michael Feldman is the editor of HPCwire.
More Michael Feldman
Recent Comments
still innovative by PhoenixW
Rediculous notion! by jimmymac
The benchmark is completely wrong. by Patrick LEE
SiCortex / Betamax by KevinButerbaugh
Good Luck to Silicon Graphics by Rick_Mandahl
It's About Realism not Speed by cyberdyne
SGI, Not Alone by EricS
Re: Obama Pushes Science Agenda by lwalker701
The battleground... by rgreen1
How it went wrong for SGi by atzanov
Harder than chess by addisonsnell
Debt consolidation by EliasV
Re: Recession Takes a Bite Out of Supercomputing by CooperO
How it went wrong for SGi by shawnu
How it all went wrong for SGI by jmh900
Torn between IRIX and Linux by Merblich
Sun Microsystems by IsaacU
New Search Engine Duck Duck Go by yegg
GlobalFoundries and IBM ? by gutiea
GlobalFoundries and IBM ? by gutiea
HPC Market by Flamingo
Fusion Cloud Rendering by gary@amd
Fusion Cloud Rendering by gary@amd
Not cores, but memory! by dmpase
Are you on Intel's payroll? by jimmymac
anchos by addisonsnell
anchos? by in_the_crease
Here's to Cray accuracy over HPCwire's. by taylors
Tech community prefers Pepsi to Coke by cogsci
Feature Articles
Spider Up and Spinning Connections to All Computing Platforms at ORNL
Spider, the world's biggest Lustre-based, centerwide file system, has been fully tested to support Oak Ridge National Laboratory's new petascale Cray XT4/XT5 Jaguar supercomputer and is now offering early access to scientists.
Read More...
Wolfram Alpha: A Web-Based Application That Embraced Supercomputers
Wolfram Alpha, the Web-based computational engine introduced in May, is not a traditional supercomputing application, but relies on supercomputers to satisfy its unique requirements.
Read More...
TeraGrid '09: Student Participation Soars
There was a new energy at this year's TeraGrid '09 conference thanks to an outstanding turnout for the student program. Thanks to support from the National Science Foundation, more than 100 high school, undergraduate and graduate students were able to participate in the conference.
Read More...
Top Headlines
3D Seismic Data: Taking a Smarter Approach to Interpretation
Jul 09 | Engineer Live | The demand for computational tools to underpin the 3D seismic interpretation process has never been more apparent. Read more...
Engineering Unemployment Soared in 2Q to 8.6%
Jul 08 | EE Times | Unemployment for U.S. engineers has reached record levels, according to government figures. Read more...
Gartner Adjusts 2009 IT Spend Downward Again
Jul 08 | Network World | Global spending for 2009 projected to drop 6 percent, for a total of $3.2 trillion. Read more...
Concurrent and Parallel Are Not The Same
Jul 08 | Linux Magazine | Portability or efficiency? Neither is guaranteed when writing explicit parallel code. Read more...
800 TFLOP Real-Time Ray Tracing GPU Unveiled, Not for Gamers
Jul 07 | Ars Technica | Japanese company builds custom ASIC to accelerate real-time ray traced rendering for the auto industry. Read more...
Featured Whitepapers
Parallel Computing Without Parallel Programming
Jul 10 | | Engineers, scientists, and other domain experts depend on the productivity enabled by very high-level language (VHLL) tools like MATLAB® and Python. However, as datasets grow larger and programs get more sophisticated, ordinary desktop computers can no longer keep up. The paper explores how to run VHLL programs on high-performance platforms without low-level reprogramming. Work with large datasets and complex algorithms without sacrificing ease of use or reducing productivity.
Building High Performance Computing in a Green and Modular Solution Building Block
Apr 14 | | Many HPC IT departments are feeling the rising pressure to deliver more capacity computing and performance while trying to reduce the total cost of ownership. This white paper discusses how an environmentally-friendly and open-standards HPC building block based computing system using flexible interconnect options helps address capacity computing needs.
Multimedia
Webcast: Dell Expands HPC Access and Adoption with Intel Cluster Ready Program
Source: Addison Snell, GM/VP, Tabor Research; sponsored by Dell
Many organizations that could benefit from the use of HPC clusters find that it is complicated to get the systems up and running because of limited IT resources or the complexities of the clusters themselves. Learn how the Intel Cluster Ready program, for which Dell was an original partner, seeks to address this challenge for entry level and mid-range HPC users.
Video White Paper: Architecting a Better Network Storage Solution
BlueArc's Titan architecture represents an evolutionary step in file servers by creating a hardware-based file system that can scale bandwidth, IOPS, and overall data capacity well beyond conventional software-based devices. With its ability to virtualize a massive storage pool of up to four usable petabytes of tiered storage, Titan can scale with growing data requirements, offering a competitive advantage for businesses, researchers, or other enterprises seeking to better manage data growth while still ensuring optimal performance.
Webcast: HPC Development Solutions: Sun Studio & Sun HPC ClusterTools
Sun Studio Compilers and Tools and Sun HPC ClusterTools allow you to create high performance parallel applications for OpenSolaris, Solaris and Linux. Sun Studio Express 11/08 includes MPI performance analysis capabilities and full OpenMP 3.0 compiler support. Learn about all this and the latest in Sun HPC ClusterTools 8.1.
Blogs by Topics
Blogs by Author
- John Towns
- John Shandor
- Dennis Barker
- Michael Feldman
- Debra Goldfarb
- Diane Lieberman
- Isaac Lopez
- Addison Snell
- Deb Walsh
- Chris Willard
HPC Blogroll
- Computing Research Policy Blog
- InsideHPC
- Interconnects
- Reed's Ruminations
- Scalability.org
- StorageMojo
- Sun HPC Watercooler
Featured Events
-
July 13-16, 2009
WORLDCOMP'09
Las Vegas , NV
USA
-
August 24-28, 2009
Data Mining: Levels I, II, & III
Denver , CO
USA