The Leading Source for Global News and Information Covering the Ecosystem of High Productivity Computing
Blog: From the Editor
From the Editor | Main Blog Index
July 22, 2008
Can Big Blue Make Power7 Green?
In the past couple weeks, there has been a lot of buzz about the IBM's upcoming Power7 processors, which are slated to be used in NCSA's multi-petaflop "Blue Waters" supercomputer and Big Blue's HPCS PERCS system. Most of the recent speculation was stirred up by an article in The Register penned by Ashlee Vance, who supposedly got a hold of some internal IBM docs. According to Vance:
The IBM documents have the eight-core Power7 being arranged in dual-chip modules. So, that's 16-cores per module. As IBM tells it, each core will show 32 gigaflops of performance, bringing each chip to 256 gigaflops. Just on the gigaflop basis, that makes Power7 twice as fast per core as today's dual-core Power6 chips, although the actual clock rate on the Power7 chips should be well below the 5.0GHz Power6 speed demon.
In fact, according to Vance, the IBM literature says the chips will be shipped at 4.0 GHz, although I think that the CPUs headed for Blue Waters will most likely come in at between 3 and 4 GHz. This is quite a bit slower than the 4.7 GHz seen in IBM's current Power6-based 575 systems. The reason is obvious. To achieve the 10 petaflop peak performance (and one to two petaflops of sustained performance) that IBM is aiming for, the company will need to populate the machine with nearly 40,000 8-core Power7 processors. Even at the 45nm process technology node, the processor guys will be forced to ease up on the CPU clock to keep the chips from throwing off too much heat.
The bigger problem is that the IBM Power (not PowerPC) family is not known to be particularly energy efficient by today's standards. The architecture was originally designed for high levels of single thread performance, which is great for enterprise workloads, like database apps, but in the supercomputing arena, relying on single threaded performance is considered bad form. Building a practical petascale machine on the Power architecture is going to be a challenge.
Consider the latest Green500 stats. The top Power6-based 575 machines all come in at less than 100 megaflops/watt, which is only 1/4 as efficient as the Blue Gene/P supers and about 1/5 as efficient as Cell processor blade-based systems. A more sobering data point is that the IBM Power6-based 575 supercomputer at the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts uses 1.3 megawatts to run the Linpack benchmark and achieves a modest 80 teraflops. Scaling this system up to a one Linpack petaflop would require over 16 megawatts. Keep in mind that's not peak power consumption, nor does it include cooling or storage.
If IBM maintains the roughly 100 watt TDP for the Power7 to match the current Power6 (and older Power5), then you're talking 4 megawatts just for the CPU hardware in Blue Waters. You can easily double that to figure the power consumption of the whole machine, which, according to The Register piece, will also include 620 TB of memory and 5 PB/sec of memory bandwidth. If you add in storage and cooling, you might have to double the power once again. Since Blue Waters will be water cooled, some extra energy efficiency will gained there, but I think NSCA will need something like 10 megawatts to feed their multi-petaflop beast.
If IBM could cut the Power7 TDP to, say, 50 watts, they and NCSA would be in much better shape. One option the chip designers may use to squeeze more energy efficiency from the silicon is to add some sort of floating point hardware acceleration. As Timothy Prickett Morgan of IT Jungle pointed out last week, the Power7 design does allow for such features:
...IBM's [Power7] roadmap and its top techies have been talking about an "advanced hybrid core design." I have been led to believe that by hybrid core, IBM means bringing special functions that used to be done on the motherboard our elsewhere in computer networks back onto the chip, but not necessarily inside the processor core. (Think of the VMX AltiVec vector math units or the decimal math units on the Power6 chip and you get the right idea.) This hybrid approach lets the Power core do the work it is designed to do--run applications--while these adjunct chips assist with specific functions.
Maybe a souped-up version of AltiVec/VMX (vector multimedia extension), which was introduced in the Power6, would help things along. IBM could also make use of the Cell SPE cores to get more parallelism on-chip. But this type of hardware would be considered quite exotic in the traditional enterprise space, where most of the Power7s will be sold.
Blue Waters is scheduled for boot up in 2010, so IBM still has a couple of years to figure out how to keep the lights from dimming at NCSA. And fortunately, the company has plenty of experience with low-power supercomputing; the PowerPC-based Blue Gene and the Cell-based Roadrunner are both tops in energy efficiency. It should be interesting to see what IBM finally comes up with.
Posted by Michael Feldman - July 22 @ 6:31PM
(Digg, Technorati, more)
Sponsored Links
Michael Feldman
Michael Feldman is the editor of HPCwire.
More Michael Feldman
Recent Comments
still innovative by PhoenixW
Rediculous notion! by jimmymac
The benchmark is completely wrong. by Patrick LEE
SiCortex / Betamax by KevinButerbaugh
Good Luck to Silicon Graphics by Rick_Mandahl
It's About Realism not Speed by cyberdyne
SGI, Not Alone by EricS
Re: Obama Pushes Science Agenda by lwalker701
The battleground... by rgreen1
How it went wrong for SGi by atzanov
Harder than chess by addisonsnell
Debt consolidation by EliasV
Re: Recession Takes a Bite Out of Supercomputing by CooperO
How it went wrong for SGi by shawnu
How it all went wrong for SGI by jmh900
Torn between IRIX and Linux by Merblich
Sun Microsystems by IsaacU
New Search Engine Duck Duck Go by yegg
GlobalFoundries and IBM ? by gutiea
GlobalFoundries and IBM ? by gutiea
HPC Market by Flamingo
Fusion Cloud Rendering by gary@amd
Fusion Cloud Rendering by gary@amd
Not cores, but memory! by dmpase
Are you on Intel's payroll? by jimmymac
anchos by addisonsnell
anchos? by in_the_crease
Here's to Cray accuracy over HPCwire's. by taylors
Tech community prefers Pepsi to Coke by cogsci
Feature Articles
TeraGrid '09: Student Participation Soars
There was a new energy at this year's TeraGrid '09 conference thanks to an outstanding turnout for the student program. Thanks to support from the National Science Foundation, more than 100 high school, undergraduate and graduate students were able to participate in the conference.
Read More...
TeraGrid '09: OSG and TeraGrid Collaboration
Paul Avery, a recognized leader in advanced grid and networking for science, delivered the first keynote address at the recent TeraGrid '09 conference in Arlington, Virginia. A professor of physics at the University of Florida, Avery is co-principal investigator and founding member of the Open Science Grid (OSG). Avery talked about the history of OSG, some of the projects that leverage its resources, and OSG's relationship with TeraGrid.
Read More...
TeraGrid '09: Thriving in an Exponentially Changing World
Before he even took the podium, Ed Seidel was one of the buzz makers at the TeraGrid '09 conference. The day before his keynote, it was announced that he was stepping in as acting assistant director of the National Science Foundation's math and physical sciences directorate. For his talk at the conference, however, Seidel focused on the issues and efforts within his home at NSF, the Office of Cyberinfrastructure.
Read More...
Top Headlines
3D Seismic Data: Taking a Smarter Approach to Interpretation
Jul 09 | Engineer Live | The demand for computational tools to underpin the 3D seismic interpretation process has never been more apparent. Read more...
Engineering Unemployment Soared in 2Q to 8.6%
Jul 08 | EE Times | Unemployment for U.S. engineers has reached record levels, according to government figures. Read more...
Gartner Adjusts 2009 IT Spend Downward Again
Jul 08 | Network World | Global spending for 2009 projected to drop 6 percent, for a total of $3.2 trillion. Read more...
Concurrent and Parallel Are Not The Same
Jul 08 | Linux Magazine | Portability or efficiency? Neither is guaranteed when writing explicit parallel code. Read more...
800 TFLOP Real-Time Ray Tracing GPU Unveiled, Not for Gamers
Jul 07 | Ars Technica | Japanese company builds custom ASIC to accelerate real-time ray traced rendering for the auto industry. Read more...
Featured Whitepapers
Building High Performance Computing in a Green and Modular Solution Building Block
Apr 14 | | Many HPC IT departments are feeling the rising pressure to deliver more capacity computing and performance while trying to reduce the total cost of ownership. This white paper discusses how an environmentally-friendly and open-standards HPC building block based computing system using flexible interconnect options helps address capacity computing needs.
Multimedia
Webcast: Dell Expands HPC Access and Adoption with Intel Cluster Ready Program
Source: Addison Snell, GM/VP, Tabor Research; sponsored by Dell
Many organizations that could benefit from the use of HPC clusters find that it is complicated to get the systems up and running because of limited IT resources or the complexities of the clusters themselves. Learn how the Intel Cluster Ready program, for which Dell was an original partner, seeks to address this challenge for entry level and mid-range HPC users.
Video White Paper: Architecting a Better Network Storage Solution
BlueArc's Titan architecture represents an evolutionary step in file servers by creating a hardware-based file system that can scale bandwidth, IOPS, and overall data capacity well beyond conventional software-based devices. With its ability to virtualize a massive storage pool of up to four usable petabytes of tiered storage, Titan can scale with growing data requirements, offering a competitive advantage for businesses, researchers, or other enterprises seeking to better manage data growth while still ensuring optimal performance.
Webcast: HPC Development Solutions: Sun Studio & Sun HPC ClusterTools
Sun Studio Compilers and Tools and Sun HPC ClusterTools allow you to create high performance parallel applications for OpenSolaris, Solaris and Linux. Sun Studio Express 11/08 includes MPI performance analysis capabilities and full OpenMP 3.0 compiler support. Learn about all this and the latest in Sun HPC ClusterTools 8.1.
Blogs by Topics
Blogs by Author
- John Towns
- John Shandor
- Dennis Barker
- Michael Feldman
- Debra Goldfarb
- Diane Lieberman
- Isaac Lopez
- Addison Snell
- Deb Walsh
- Chris Willard
HPC Blogroll
- Computing Research Policy Blog
- InsideHPC
- Interconnects
- Reed's Ruminations
- Scalability.org
- StorageMojo
- Sun HPC Watercooler
Featured Events
-
July 13-16, 2009
WORLDCOMP'09
Las Vegas , NV
USA
-
August 24-28, 2009
Data Mining: Levels I, II, & III
Denver , CO
USA