HPCwire: Ethernet, InfiniBand Musings

The Leading Source for Global News and Information Covering the Ecosystem of High Productivity Computing

Leading HPC
Solution Providers

HPCwire >> Blogs

Blog: From the Editor

From the Editor | Main Blog Index

March 07, 2008

Ethernet, InfiniBand Musings

There seems to be a general consensus that the datacenter needs to settle on a unified network fabric. The question is, which one? Today, storage and cluster connectivity use some combination of Ethernet, InfiniBand and Fibre Channel, which creates a hodgepodge of cables, switches and host channel adapters. As readers of this publication are aware, both Ethernet and InfiniBand vendors have staked claim to unifying the datacenter on their blessed fabric. With the introduction of 10 GbE products and the upcoming Fibre Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) standards, Ethernet proponents claim cluster and storage unification is at hand. Meanwhile, the InfiniBand crowd is pushing their technology as the technically superior solution and the one that is available today.

Sun Microsystems seems to be getting impatient waiting for high performance Ethernet gear and FCoE standards, and has openly talked about going the InfiniBand route. In a recent EETimes article by Rick Merritt, Sun's John Fowler (executive VP of the Systems Division) said the company would be introducing a set of products this year unified on InfiniBand. While Fowler admitted they're continuing their involvement in the FCoE effort, he notes that Fibre Channel over InfiniBand should be available in 2008.

The strength of Ethernet -- its ubiquity -- is also it weakness. Changing or adding standards involves dragging the whole vendor community along. Look at how long the IEEE study group took just to decide to move forward on the 40GbE/100GbE standards. That process began in 2006 and standards aren't expected to be completed until mid-2010. And while vendors may come up with proprietary versions of FCoE relatively soon, the standard is still being hashed out by the vendor and user communities. Not only does the process suffer from a "too many cooks in the kitchen" problem, but the cooks themselves are competing with one another.

Meanwhile, the more nimble InfiniBand community has been able to establish its high bandwidth, low-latency fabric as the standard for high performance interconnects. Mellanox has used its position as the only InfiniBand switch silicon vendor to set the pace. With DDR (20 Gbps) products now mainstream and QDR (40 Gbps) products due out at the end of this year, InfiniBand has left 10GbE behind from the standpoint of raw performance.

Increasingly, the InfiniBand vendors that have traditionally focused on the HPC market are looking at the broader enterprise marker. A couple of weeks ago at VMworld Europe, Mellanox announced that it is seeing demand for unified InfiniBand I/O in VMware environments. The company is reporting interest from sectors such as banking, managed hosting services, Web 2.0, insurance services and health care.

In the above mentioned EETimes piece, Sun Chief Architect Andy Bechtolsheim also points to the performance advantages of InfiniBand and, like Fowler, thinks InfiniBand may be the fabric that first swallows up Fibre Channel for storage connectivity. It's a bit ironic that Bechtolsheim would be so enthusiastic about InfiniBand. A co-founder of Sun, he left the company in 1995 to start Granite Systems, a gigabit Ethernet switch vendor. A year later Cisco bought the company for $220 million. Now back at Sun, Bechtolsheim doesn't seem to retain any nostalgia for his Ethernet roots. His most recent InfiniBand project, the 3,456 double data rate (DDR) Magnum switch, which powers the Sun Constellation "Ranger" supercomputer at TACC, is an example of Bechtolsheim's enthusiasm for the technology.

The fact that he's now bullish on InfiniBand should give unified fabric Ethernet enthusiasts something to think about. A shrewd investor, Bechtolsheim always seems to know which way the tech wind is blowing. As one of the original backers of Google, he turned a $100,000 investment into $1.5 billion. But like any accomplished investor, Bechtolsheim knows when to hedge his bets. He recently turned up as a backer for Arastra Inc., a vendor that has recently announced a high density, low-latency 10GbE switch for the datacenter.

In fact, almost everyone is expecting Ethernet to become the standard datacenter fabric ... eventually. Even InfiniBand-loving Mellanox is hedging. The company's recently announced ConnectX EN 10GigE NIC adapters are a nod to the ubiquity of Ethernet-based applications. And the ConnectX architecture is explicitly designed to support both InfiniBand and Ethernet connectivity on the same adapter. Essentially, the Mellanox approach is about unifying data traffic on a single I/O pipe rather than on a single protocol.

So is the fix in for Ethernet? Maybe not. As virtualization takes hold in the datacenter, the demand for ever more bandwidth and ever less latency is growing and some users can't wait for 10GbE to get their act together. As John Lennon once said: "Life is what happens when you're busy making plans" (or writing standards). Even mainstream technologies can collapse under their own weight (e.g., mainframes) or split up into a confusing array of variations (e.g., Unix). And let's face it, if Ethernet gets pushed to the edge of the datacenter, civilization would manage to survive. But still, that scenario seems unlikely.

As I reported at the end of 2007, the Ethernet crowd thinks this year will be the one when 10GbE gets traction in the datacenter and even starts cutting away at InfiniBand's dominance in supercomputing. But they've made that claim before. Sometimes, when I observe how the InfiniBand vendors are courting the OEMs, I'm reminded of the 2005 movie "Wedding Crashers." Near the end of the story, lovestruck Owen Wilson pleads with Rachel McAdams: "I'm not standing here asking you to marry me. I'm just asking you not to marry him," referring to McAdams' obnoxious fiance. But while InfiniBand may be the HPC sentimental favorite, it might not be as fortunate as Wilson in getting that Hollywood ending.

---

As always, comments about HPCwire are welcomed and encouraged. Write to me, Michael Feldman, at editor@hpcwire.com.

Posted by Michael Feldman - March 7 @ 12:00AM

Discussion

There are 0 discussion items posted.

Join the Discussion

You must be a registered user in order to comment on HPCWire stories.

Members enjoy:

	Access to Special Content, including Podcasts, Webcasts, and Whitepapers and more!
	Ability to take an active role in the discussions that are shaping the HPC technology discipline!
	Special offers available only to HPCWire members!

Become a Registered User Today!

Registered Users Log in Here to Comment

Email Address:	Password (case sensitive)

Remember me	Forgot Password?

Michael Feldman

Michael Feldman is the editor of HPCwire.

More Michael Feldman

Feature Articles

The Linux HPC Empire Strikes Back

While the Microsoft juggernaut has been touting the joys of its new Windows HPC Server 2008, the Linux HPC contingent has been somewhat less vocal of late. But now Red Hat has come up with its version of an integrated cluster solution.
Read More...

Nexsan Looks to Scare Up HPC Customers With Storage Beast

Even though the cost of servers still dominates the datacenter budget, storage is actually on a steeper growth curve. HPC storage, in particular, is being singled out as high-growth opportunity. Vendors are scrambling to keep up.
Read More...

The Week in Review

Google datacenters most energy efficient; Cluster Resources to demo Moab Hybrid Cluster; Red Hat Linux releases HPC distro. John West recaps those stories and more in our weekly wrap-up.
Read More...

Read more HPCwire features...

Top Headlines

Lustre to Battle Corruption

Oct 07 | GCN.com | Sun Microsystems has been busy building a lot more intelligence into Lustre, a file system used for large-scale cluster computing. Read more...

Oracle and HP's Database Machine Predicated on Voltaire

Oct 06 | The Register | Does the HP Oracle Database Machine represent InfiniBand's big chance to break out its HPC niche? Read more...

3D Imaging Spreads to Fashion and Beyond

Oct 06 | BusinessWeek | A body scan can save a lot of time in the fitting room, and fields from medicine to architecture are adopting 3D computing applications. Read more...

Structural Engineers and Computer Scientists Hope to Integrate Disciplines to 'Revolutionize Building Construction'

Oct 03 | UCSD News | Despite the evolution of computer science over the past 30 years, structural engineering -- hindered by a reluctance to adapt to digital innovations -- has remained relatively unchanged as a discipline. Read more...

Credit Crisis Spreads a Pall Over Silicon Valley

Oct 02 | New York Times | Silcon Valley is starting to feel the effects of the credit crunch. Read more...

Read more headlines...

Featured Whitepapers

Panasas® Tiered Parity™ Architecture

Sep 04 | | Disk drives are approximately 250 times denser today than a decade ago. This is good news for users who are creating, manipulating and storing more data than ever before. It gives them an opportunity to derive more value from their stored data and lowers the capital acquisition and operating expense associated with that data.

View the White Paper Library

Multimedia

Video White Paper: Architecting a Better Network Storage Solution

BlueArc's Titan architecture represents an evolutionary step in file servers by creating a hardware-based file system that can scale bandwidth, IOPS, and overall data capacity well beyond conventional software-based devices. With its ability to virtualize a massive storage pool of up to four usable petabytes of tiered storage, Titan can scale with growing data requirements, offering a competitive advantage for businesses, researchers, or other enterprises seeking to better manage data growth while still ensuring optimal performance.