Visit additional Tabor Communication Publications
May 22, 2008
On Tuesday, I wrote about the difficulties that Japan and the UK are having in finding engineers for their local industries. For the flip side of that discussion, today I'm going to talk about how the H-1B visa program continues to agitate the tech community in the US. H-1Bs, of course, are the visas that allow foreign workers with technology skills to be employed in the United States.
There's actually a good report about the ongoing H-1B debate over at TechNewsWorld. In Part 1 of the series, Andrew Burger outlines the system as it exists today; in Part 2 he talks about some possible solutions. In a nutshell, the US tech industry has taken the stance that the current H-1B program doesn't allocate enough visa slots for workers to fill local demands and this is hurting their ability to do business, not to mention national competitiveness. Tech labor advocates argue there are plenty of native workers, but visas are being used by companies to get access to cheaper foreign labor. Burger does an excellent job of illuminating each perspective, so I'd encourage everyone to read the two-part article in full.
One aspect of the controversy seems pretty clear to me. IT companies are using the H-1B program to control labor costs. That in itself is no crime, since all businesses strive to keep labor costs under control. The problem is the program was never intended to be an affirmative action scheme for foreign workers. It was only meant to make up for shortfalls in the local tech labor pool.
This is where it gets murky. Big IT companies like Intel, Google and Microsoft that hire a lot of new workers each year claim there aren't enough tech workers to go around. The conventional wisdom is that the US is perennially short of qualified engineers and scientists to fill the job openings. The qualified adjective is the key, since it becomes a way for an employer to become a discriminating shopper in the labor marketplace. The attitude is expressed when company execs say that they must hire "the best and the brightest" to keep their competitive edge.
The reality though is a bit different, at least according to Norman Matloff, a computer science professor at University of California, Davis. He says the argument that the H-1B program spurs innovation and keeps us competitive is unfounded. In a recent report he wrote on the topic, Matloff concludes that most H-1B visas are issued for "people of just ordinary talent, doing ordinary work." According to the data, the majority of workers hired under the program are at the lower expertise levels. And even though H-1B workers are supposed to be paid at the "prevailing wage," that turns out to be a rather slippery term to define.
In Matloff's opinion, the industry is preferentially hiring foreign workers so they don't have to pay more expensive native-born employees. Nor do they have to be bothered with retraining older tech workers, something US companies are particularly loathe to do. (And by the way, in the fast-moving tech world, "older" may just mean someone in their 30s.) The data suggests that there are generally enough US-born scientists and engineers in overall numbers to meet local demands, even if the skill sets don't always exactly match the job openings. But in the absence of a more regulated H-1B program, that kind of environment sets the table for discrimination.
What's a government to do? Public policy always has to find the right balance between business and labor. But in the current tech-driven society, where companies like Google, Microsoft and Intel are treated as gods, it's hard to argue against their interests. There are a few H-1B reformers in Congress, like Senators Dick Grubin (D-Ill.) and Charles Grassley (R-Iowa), who would like to close the loopholes and create a more level playing field. But the feds are heavily lobbied to expand the H-1B program. Microsoft's Bill Gates rarely misses an opportunity to lecture Congress on the dire employment needs of the industry. In fact, some tech worker immigration proponents want to essentially implement the labor equivalent of free trade: get rid of the H-1B quotas (currently capped at 65,000) altogether. Others are proposing a points system, like the kind used by Canada, Australia, and the UK, that rate potential foreign workers against national employment needs.
The inexorable march of globalization will likely force some tough decisions. Whatever path is taken though, it's certain that history will not be kind to those that fail to adapt.
Posted by Michael Feldman - May 21, 2008 @ 9:00 PM, Pacific Daylight Time
Michael Feldman is the editor of HPCwire.
No Recent Blog Comments
Contributing commentator, Andrew Jones, offers a break in the news cycle with an assessment of what the national "size matters" contest means for the U.S. and other nations...
Today at the International Supercomputing Conference in Leipzing, Germany, Jack Dongarra presented on a proposed benchmark that could carry a bit more weight than its older Linpack companion. The high performance conjugate gradient (HPCG) concept takes into account new architectures for new applications, while shedding the floating point....
Not content to let the Tianhe-2 announcement ride alone, Intel rolled out a series of announcements around its Knights Corner and Xeon Phi products--all of which are aimed at adding some options and variety for a wider base of potential users across the HPC spectrum. Today at the International Supercomputing Conference, the company's Raj....
Jun 18, 2013 |
The world's largest supercomputers, like Tianhe-2, are great at traditional, compute-intensive HPC workloads, such as simulating atomic decay or modeling tornados. But data-intensive applications--such as mining big data sets for connections--is a different sort of workload, and runs best on a different sort of computer.
Jun 18, 2013 |
Researchers are finding innovative uses for Gordon, the 285 teraflop supercomputer housed at the San Diego Supercomputer Center (SDSC) that has a unique Flash-based storage system. Since going online, researchers have put the incredibly fast I/O to use on a wide variety of workloads, ranging from chemistry to political science.
Jun 17, 2013 |
The advent of low-power mobile processors and cloud delivery models is changing the economics of computing. But just as an economy car is good at different things than a full size truck, an HPC workload still has certain computing demands that neither the fastest smartphone nor the most elastic cloud cluster can fulfill.
Jun 14, 2013 |
For all the progress we've made in IT over the last 50 years, there's one area of life that has steadfastly eluded the grasp of computers: understanding human language. Now, researchers at the Texas Advanced Computing Center (TACC) are utilizing a Hadoop cluster on its Longhorn supercomputer to move the state of the art of language processing a little bit further.
Jun 13, 2013 |
Titan, the Cray XK7 at the Oak Ridge National Lab that debuted last fall as the fastest supercomputer in the world with 17.59 petaflops of sustained computing power, will rely on its previous LINPACK test for the upcoming edition of the Top 500 list.
05/10/2013 | Cleversafe, Cray, DDN, NetApp, & Panasas | From Wall Street to Hollywood, drug discovery to homeland security, companies and organizations of all sizes and stripes are coming face to face with the challenges – and opportunities – afforded by Big Data. Before anyone can utilize these extraordinary data repositories, however, they must first harness and manage their data stores, and do so utilizing technologies that underscore affordability, security, and scalability.
04/15/2013 | Bull | “50% of HPC users say their largest jobs scale to 120 cores or less.” How about yours? Are your codes ready to take advantage of today’s and tomorrow’s ultra-parallel HPC systems? Download this White Paper by Analysts Intersect360 Research to see what Bull and Intel’s Center for Excellence in Parallel Programming can do for your codes.
Join HPCwire Editor Nicole Hemsoth and Dr. David Bader from Georgia Tech as they take center stage on opening night at Atlanta's first Big Data Kick Off Week, filmed in front of a live audience. Nicole and David look at the evolution of HPC, today's big data challenges, discuss real world solutions, and reveal their predictions. Exactly what does the future holds for HPC?
Join our webinar to learn how IT managers can migrate to a more resilient, flexible and scalable solution that grows with the data center. Mellanox VMS is future-proof, efficient and brings significant CAPEX and OPEX savings. The VMS is available today.