Why Pretend?

By Christopher C. Aycock, MS

October 6, 2006

InfiniBand and iWARP have industry heavyweights behind them, to be sure. But this kind of smug satisfaction has only led to a case of the Emperor's New Clothes in which no one is willing to admit to the inadequacy of RDMA in general and VIA in particular.

Kernel Bypass, Zero Copy, and Asynchronous Communication

Networks are a shared resource. Traditional networks such as Ethernet require that the resource be protected by the kernel, which presents a tremendous performance bottleneck when latency is an issue. Furthermore, data is copied to and from pre-allocated buffers, which can hurt bandwidth for large messages.

Many of today's high-performance networks from vendors such as Myricom and Quadrics handle the protection across process boundaries directly through the network interface card (NIC). This setup bypasses the kernel and lets communication occur at the user level, thereby removing the bottleneck of mode switching.

Most modern high-performance networks also have direct memory access (DMA) in which the NIC accesses main memory directly while the CPU is free to perform other tasks. DMA not only eliminates copying, but also permits communication to overlap with computation. This facet is similar to prefetching in the cache as it reduces the effective latency. Taking advantage of this feature in an application only requires asynchronous communication, which is represented as multithreaded designs in Sockets or as nonblocking primitives in MPI — MPI_Isend() and MPI_Irecv().

Send/Receive and RDMA

Most of the above capabilities are available through the widely-used two-sided semantics of Send/Receive communication. That is, the communication runs entirely at the user level, allows the local (sending) node to act without copying, and frees the CPU to perform other tasks. Send/Receive does have a drawback though: the remote (receiving) node must copy the message to its final destination; the benefit of zero-copy only exists for the sending node.

With one-sided semantics in remote direct memory access (RDMA), the receiving NIC uses DMA to place the data into a buffer that has been specified by the sending node. RDMA extends zero-copy benefits to the remote node.

For the NIC to access the data through RDMA, the user's page must actually be in memory and not on the disk. Pinning the page to physical memory requires a memory registration, which invokes the operating system. This is actually an expensive procedure as it requires the kernel and is exactly what high-performance networks are supposed to avoid!

Furthermore, the sending node must know the destination memory address on the receiving node. Most applications, such as those written in Sockets or MPI, will require that this information be exchanged prior to communication. The synchronization here is performed through the Send/Receive semantics in a rendezvous protocol, which adds even more overhead.

Workarounds for RDMA

It is possible to overcome RDMA's shortcomings and still realize the benefit of zero-copy communication on the remote node. Certain supercomputers such as the Blue Gene rely on a custom lightweight kernel that only runs one process; because there is no paging, there is no requirement for memory registration.

Alternatively, QsNet works by patching the kernel so that the NIC may access the appropriate data once the page has been loaded into memory. Patches are developed for very specific versions of the kernel based on assumptions regarding the Linux API. Given this level of required specificity, administering a cluster that involves kernel patches can be quite tedious.

As for InfiniBand, it is possible to rely on caching techniques. That is, if a certain memory region will be remotely accessed multiple times, then the software — an implementation of MPI, for example — may build a table of memory registrations on the receiving node.

In any case, synchronization remains unavoidable in most programs. The sending node must know the destination memory address on the remote node to perform RDMA. There are some special cases where the address will be known ahead of time, as in MPI-2's remote memory access functions — MPI_Put() and MPI_Get(). But these routines are not widely used and represent a niche application.

Specific Issues with the Virtual Interface Architecture (VIA)

MVAPICH is a port of MPICH to InfiniBand maintained by D. K. Panda's team at Ohio State University. This implementation provides a reference for other communication layers on VIA-based networks, such as InfiniBand and iWARP. Of particular interest is that OSU's collection of related research papers contain a series of design patterns for software on RDMA networks.

Design patterns are best-practice architecture that permit reuse of a solution to a common programming problem. Some language researchers, such as Paul Graham and Peter Norvig, believe that design patterns are really a sign that the underlying language is incomplete. After all, a pattern implies automation, and automation implies a machine.

By extension, the design patterns from OSU demonstrate that InfiniBand lacks the foundations that would best serve most of its users. Now some designers, such as John Hennessy and David Patterson, believe that an architecture should provide primitives and not solutions. But given that the (committee-defined) InfiniBand standard is over a thousand pages long, it should be fairly obvious which view the IB Trade Association holds.

In contrast, both the Elan and MX libraries (for QsNet and Myrinet, respectively) have been specifically built to present the common functionality required in most applications. The solution-oriented VIA community should have done the same with their libraries, such DAPL and the OpenFabrics verbs API.

Personal Notes

I was motivated to write this article after reading “A Tutorial of the RDMA Model” from IBM's Renato Recio, which in turn was a response to “A Critique of RDMA” from Myricom's Patrick Geoffray. I got the impression that Recio was writing to protect the image of VIA rather than provide a sound rebuttal to Geoffray's technical arguments about RDMA. For example, Geoffray's criticism that RDMA is not adequate for Sockets is met with the response that the user can rely on Extended Sockets or the Sockets Direct Protocol (SDP). Extended Sockets is a different library from Sockets, albeit somewhat similar; SDP is a protocol used above and beyond the RDMA paradigm. Geoffray essentially said that RDMA is handicapped and Recio responded that RDMA has a choice of crutches.

What is particularly telling is that Recio fell back on the old technique of using sales volume to justify technical soundness. He states, “it is interesting to note that almost twice as many new machines in the top100 are using InfiniBand than Myrinet.” This is like saying that Titanic was the best movie ever produced since it sold the most tickets. If IBM really did believe the sales-volume pitch, it would stop making POWER chips and simply bundle x86 with its servers.

I wrote this article as a knowledgeable end user; I will leave the marketing brochures to the vendors. At Oxford we used to believe that RDMA was a godsend for the BSP-style programming found in MPI-2 or Cray's SHMEM. Indeed, Geoffray's article states that RDMA networks “can be leveraged successfully for one-sided programming paradigms.” After having studied both the paradigms and the networks, I have come to the conclusion that models such as the partitioned global address space languages are really best suited for ccNUMA machines. And indeed, that is what RDMA is: a crude approximation of a non-commodity machine useful only for niche applications.

Sockets work just fine on vanilla Ethernet. MPI works on Ethernet. Google's MapReduce works on Ethernet. Maybe this is the architecture we should be building on.

The author would like to thank Richard Brent and Peter Strazdins for their comments on an earlier draft of this article.

—–

Christopher C. Aycock is wrapping up his PhD from Oxford University, where his thesis topic is in communications programming paradigms for high-performance networks. He is currently a visiting fellow at the Australian National University and can be reached via chris@hpcanswers.com.

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

UCSD, AIST Forge Tighter Alliance with AI-Focused MOU

January 18, 2018

The rich history of collaboration between UC San Diego and AIST in Japan is getting richer. The organizations entered into a five-year memorandum of understanding on January 10. The MOU represents the continuation of a 1 Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

New Blueprint for Converging HPC, Big Data

January 18, 2018

After five annual workshops on Big Data and Extreme-Scale Computing (BDEC), a group of international HPC heavyweights including Jack Dongarra (University of Tennessee), Satoshi Matsuoka (Tokyo Institute of Technology), Read more…

By John Russell

Researchers Measure Impact of ‘Meltdown’ and ‘Spectre’ Patches on HPC Workloads

January 17, 2018

Computer scientists from the Center for Computational Research, State University of New York (SUNY), University at Buffalo have examined the effect of Meltdown and Spectre security updates on the performance of popular H Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

HPE Extreme Performance Solutions

HPE and NREL Take Steps to Create a Sustainable, Energy-Efficient Data Center with an H2 Fuel Cell

As enterprises attempt to manage rising volumes of data, unplanned data center outages are becoming more common and more expensive. As the cost of downtime rises, enterprises lose out on productivity and valuable competitive advantage without access to their critical data. Read more…

Fostering Lustre Advancement Through Development and Contributions

January 17, 2018

Six months after organizational changes at Intel's High Performance Data (HPDD) division, most in the Lustre community have shed any initial apprehension around the potential changes that could affect or disrupt Lustre Read more…

By Carlos Aoki Thomaz

UCSD, AIST Forge Tighter Alliance with AI-Focused MOU

January 18, 2018

The rich history of collaboration between UC San Diego and AIST in Japan is getting richer. The organizations entered into a five-year memorandum of understandi Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

New Blueprint for Converging HPC, Big Data

January 18, 2018

After five annual workshops on Big Data and Extreme-Scale Computing (BDEC), a group of international HPC heavyweights including Jack Dongarra (University of Te Read more…

By John Russell

Researchers Measure Impact of ‘Meltdown’ and ‘Spectre’ Patches on HPC Workloads

January 17, 2018

Computer scientists from the Center for Computational Research, State University of New York (SUNY), University at Buffalo have examined the effect of Meltdown Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Fostering Lustre Advancement Through Development and Contributions

January 17, 2018

Six months after organizational changes at Intel's High Performance Data (HPDD) division, most in the Lustre community have shed any initial apprehension aroun Read more…

By Carlos Aoki Thomaz

When the Chips Are Down

January 11, 2018

In the last article, "The High Stakes Semiconductor Game that Drives HPC Diversity," I alluded to the challenges facing the semiconductor industry and how that may impact the evolution of HPC systems over the next few years. I thought I’d lift the covers a little and look at some of the commercial challenges that impact the component technology we use in HPC. Read more…

By Dairsie Latimer

How Meltdown and Spectre Patches Will Affect HPC Workloads

January 10, 2018

There have been claims that the fixes for the Meltdown and Spectre security vulnerabilities, named the KPTI (aka KAISER) patches, are going to affect applicatio Read more…

By Rosemary Francis

Momentum Builds for US Exascale

January 9, 2018

2018 looks to be a great year for the U.S. exascale program. The last several months of 2017 revealed a number of important developments that help put the U.S. Read more…

By Alex R. Larzelere

ANL’s Rick Stevens on CANDLE, ARM, Quantum, and More

January 8, 2018

Late last year HPCwire caught up with Rick Stevens, associate laboratory director for computing, environment and life Sciences at Argonne National Laboratory, f Read more…

By John Russell

Inventor Claims to Have Solved Floating Point Error Problem

January 17, 2018

"The decades-old floating point error problem has been solved," proclaims a press release from inventor Alan Jorgensen. The computer scientist has filed for and Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

US Coalesces Plans for First Exascale Supercomputer: Aurora in 2021

September 27, 2017

At the Advanced Scientific Computing Advisory Committee (ASCAC) meeting, in Arlington, Va., yesterday (Sept. 26), it was revealed that the "Aurora" supercompute Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Japan Unveils Quantum Neural Network

November 22, 2017

The U.S. and China are leading the race toward productive quantum computing, but it's early enough that ultimate leadership is still something of an open questi Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

AMD Showcases Growing Portfolio of EPYC and Radeon-based Systems at SC17

November 13, 2017

AMD’s charge back into HPC and the datacenter is on full display at SC17. Having launched the EPYC processor line in June along with its MI25 GPU the focus he Read more…

By John Russell

Nvidia Responds to Google TPU Benchmarking

April 10, 2017

Nvidia highlights strengths of its newest GPU silicon in response to Google's report on the performance and energy advantages of its custom tensor processor. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

IBM Begins Power9 Rollout with Backing from DOE, Google

December 6, 2017

After over a year of buildup, IBM is unveiling its first Power9 system based on the same architecture as the Department of Energy CORAL supercomputers, Summit a Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Fast Forward: Five HPC Predictions for 2018

December 21, 2017

What’s on your list of high (and low) lights for 2017? Volta 100’s arrival on the heels of the P100? Appearance, albeit late in the year, of IBM’s Power9? Read more…

By John Russell

Chip Flaws ‘Meltdown’ and ‘Spectre’ Loom Large

January 4, 2018

The HPC and wider tech community have been abuzz this week over the discovery of critical design flaws that impact virtually all contemporary microprocessors. T Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Leading Solution Providers

Perspective: What Really Happened at SC17?

November 22, 2017

SC is over. Now comes the myriad of follow-ups. Inboxes are filled with templated emails from vendors and other exhibitors hoping to win a place in the post-SC thinking of booth visitors. Attendees of tutorials, workshops and other technical sessions will be inundated with requests for feedback. Read more…

By Andrew Jones

Tensors Come of Age: Why the AI Revolution Will Help HPC

November 13, 2017

Thirty years ago, parallel computing was coming of age. A bitter battle began between stalwart vector computing supporters and advocates of various approaches to parallel computing. IBM skeptic Alan Karp, reacting to announcements of nCUBE’s 1024-microprocessor system and Thinking Machines’ 65,536-element array, made a public $100 wager that no one could get a parallel speedup of over 200 on real HPC workloads. Read more…

By John Gustafson & Lenore Mullin

Delays, Smoke, Records & Markets – A Candid Conversation with Cray CEO Peter Ungaro

October 5, 2017

Earlier this month, Tom Tabor, publisher of HPCwire and I had a very personal conversation with Cray CEO Peter Ungaro. Cray has been on something of a Cinderell Read more…

By Tiffany Trader & Tom Tabor

Flipping the Flops and Reading the Top500 Tea Leaves

November 13, 2017

The 50th edition of the Top500 list, the biannual publication of the world’s fastest supercomputers based on public Linpack benchmarking results, was released Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

GlobalFoundries, Ayar Labs Team Up to Commercialize Optical I/O

December 4, 2017

GlobalFoundries (GF) and Ayar Labs, a startup focused on using light, instead of electricity, to transfer data between chips, today announced they've entered in Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

How Meltdown and Spectre Patches Will Affect HPC Workloads

January 10, 2018

There have been claims that the fixes for the Meltdown and Spectre security vulnerabilities, named the KPTI (aka KAISER) patches, are going to affect applicatio Read more…

By Rosemary Francis

HPC Chips – A Veritable Smorgasbord?

October 10, 2017

For the first time since AMD's ill-fated launch of Bulldozer the answer to the question, 'Which CPU will be in my next HPC system?' doesn't have to be 'Whichever variety of Intel Xeon E5 they are selling when we procure'. Read more…

By Dairsie Latimer

Nvidia, Partners Announce Several V100 Servers

September 27, 2017

Here come the Volta 100-based servers. Nvidia today announced an impressive line-up of servers from major partners – Dell EMC, Hewlett Packard Enterprise, IBM Read more…

By John Russell

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
Share This