GPU Computing Gets Ready for Act II

By Michael Feldman

October 26, 2007

The idea of general-purpose computing on graphics processing units (GPGPU) continues to capture the imagination of the HPC community. But the three big players — Intel, NVIDIA and AMD — all have their ideas on how this new technology should play out.

When Intel rejected the whole notion of general-purpose computing on graphics processing units (GPGPU) at the spring 2007 IDF meeting with its announcement of its upcoming Larrabee product line, the digerati began to buzz about what the future might hold for the GPU. For those who might not have heard about it, Larrabee is Intel’s answer to the programmable GPU, the technology that is bringing GPGPU to the masses.

The Larrabee architecture could be characterized as the anti-GPU entry. The overall approach is an attempt to evolve the CPU into a terascale data parallel engine. According to Intel, Larrabee will be a manycore (i.e., more than 8 cores) device and will be based on a subset of the IA instruction set with some extra GPU-like instructions thrown in. Intel has not elaborated on how it intends to do this, but one could imagine super-sized SSE units with just enough x86 CPU silicon to enable general-purpose flow control and data access. The first product release will probably come in 2009, but Intel says it may have something to demo as early as next year.

The idea behind Larrabee is to bring both traditional graphics processing and data parallel computing under the IA umbrella. I’m not going to talk about the traditional graphics side of the story here (I’ll let the game weenies argue about the advantages of ray-tracing over rasterization.) What’s interesting about Larrabee and its GPU brethren is the extent to which a graphics engine can become a general-purpose computing engine without compromising its performance.

The combination of a data parallel engine with more of the general-purpose flexibility of a traditional CPU could offer a powerful model for scientific computing applications, which usually consist of an irregular mix of matrix math and other logic. One of the drawbacks of traditional GPUs is that they depend upon an accompanying CPU for virtually all of the non-vector logic. That’s fine if the application divides neatly between a vector computing kernel and the rest of the application logic in such a way as to keep both types of processing engines busy. But if it doesn’t, the software developer has to find a way to tease out enough parallelism for the GPU to make sending the vector data on a round trip from the CPU worthwhile. This will only get worse in the future, since chip-to-chip bus performance is not expected to keep pace with either CPU or GPU performance.

The division of labor problem is at the heart of the GPGPU critique elaborated by Anwar Ghuloum, an engineer at Intel’s Microprocessor Technology Lab. In a blog entry last week, The Problem(s) with GPGPU, he writes about some of the ramifications of the current CPU-GPU dichotomy:

[B]ecause of the underlying constraints of GPU architecture, oftentimes the program relies heavily on the CPU to manage the difficult parts of the control and data flow, as well as all the other (necessary) stuff like I/O, etc. Here’s the problem with this, the CPU-GPU link is relatively lower performance, engendering relatively high latencies for CPU-GPU interactions (like using a CPU to handle an outer level loop that the GPU can’t handle). This can have a devastating effect on performance.

Ghuloum is not explicitly making a pitch for Larrabee here. He’s really questioning the validity of the GPGPU programming approach, which he believes is too narrowly defined to exploit all avenues of data parallelism. In a previous blog post, Ghuloum makes a case for Ct, a language Intel is developing that supports a more general-purpose, deterministic parallel programming model. While Ct assumes no specific architecture, the underlying model he’s describing seems to point to a more generalized parallel processing architecture, like Larrabee.

NVIDIA offers a more traditional approach to GPGPU. Its Tesla product line and CUDA C-programming environment were specifically developed to deliver GPU computing to the HPC market. The current Tesla products, released in June 2007, are based on the G80 architecture but packaged in form factors that are geared toward high performance computing setups, both workstations and servers. Host communication is done via PCI Express (PCIe).

There’s plenty of low-hanging fruit to be had with Tesla. Seismic analysis, medical diagnostics, molecular modeling and other such applications can realize performance increases of one or two orders of magnitude from this type of GPU acceleration. The next generation of Tesla offerings are expected to support double precision floating point. This will expand the GPGPU application domain even more, since 64-bit floating point is the de facto standard for scientific computing.

NVIDIA may eventually move its high performance computing Tesla line, or its descendents, in the same direction as Larrabee. But unlike Intel, NVIDIA starting point is the GPU, and it has no in-house CPU to draw from, so the path is bound to be different. For now, NVIDIA is content to exploit its lead in the GPGPU arena, especially since its nearest competitor, AMD, is still in the process of putting its GPU computing strategy together.

At one time, AMD seemed to be ready to take advantage of the renewed interest in GPGPU. Soon after the company acquired ATI in July 2006, it launched its “Stream Computing” strategy, with the idea of leveraging ATI’s GPUs and AMD’s HyperTransport interconnect technology. The company’s first GPGPU platform consisted of a PCIe-connected ATI R580 GPU bundled with their “Close to the Metal” software development kit. But it’s not clear how many of these platforms have been sold, and AMD hasn’t talked much about stream computing since 2006.

Over the past year, the company has struggled against Intel’s onslaught of new x86 technology and aggressive chip pricing. If that wasn’t enough of a distraction, NVIDIA’s foray into the GPGPU arena seemed to catch AMD off-guard. Even if the company’s initial GPU plans have slipped, AMD’s long-term commitment to marry its two architectures remains. But with Intel and NVIDIA forging ahead, time is no longer on AMD’s side.

The first instance of AMD’s upcoming Fusion processor, which integrates a CPU and GPU on the same die, is at least a year away and is intended for the consumer market (notebooks). If successful, later generations of Fusion will almost certainly target HPC, and are likely to resemble a Cell processor architecture, with multiple CPU and GPU cores. Chip level CPU-GPU integration offers a number of advantages over discrete components, namely increased energy efficiency and better communication bandwidth and latency (HyperTransport versus PCIe). It’s not the Larrabee model, but it offers the same advantage of using an x86 base to create a platform with much greater capabilities for data parallelism. AMD is also likely to offer discrete GPU products for high-end computing, but no roadmap has been publicized.

Like Intel, AMD has hinted at adding GPU-type instructions to the x86 ISA to allow software to work seamlessly with the graphics engines via a standard compiler/runtime. If AMD and Intel were on speaking terms, they could forge a common GPU ISA, which would be much appreciated by the GPGPU ecosystem. It could also serve to blunt NVIDIA’s lead, and probably force the company to adopt what would be an industry-standard GPU interface. In the short term, standards are unlikely. Everyone involved has their own vision of how the GPU should evolve into its new role.

This is one reason why high-level software environments for parallel programming are needed. While the Ct language looks promising, it’s still in the research stage. (I’m guessing we’ll soon be hearing more about this Intel.) Today, RapidMind offers a high-level software platform that allows developers to exploit data parallelism on a variety of hardware architectures, including NVIDIA and AMD GPUs, the Cell BE, and soon, x86 CPUs. The RapidMind platform has been generally available for less than a year, but has already managed to attract over 1,000 developers.

Given the asymmetric capabilities of the different chip vendors and the immaturity of the GPGPU software ecosystem, it’s too early to make predictions on the future of GPUs for general-purpose computing. What seems more certain is that proprietary vector processor-based supercomputers, like the one just announced by NEC this week, will soon be edged out by commodity-based systems that contain the equivalent vector smarts. Whether these machines turn out to be based on double precision GPUs, GPU-CPU hybrids, SIMD-enhanced CPUs, Cell BE processors, FPGAs, or SIMD ASICs, remains to be seen.


As always, comments about HPCwire are welcomed and encouraged. Write to me, Michael Feldman, at [email protected].

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

Supercomputer Research Reveals Star Cluster Born Outside Our Galaxy

July 11, 2020

The Milky Way is our galactic home, containing our solar system and continuing into a giant band of densely packed stars that stretches across clear night skies around the world – but, it turns out, not all of those st Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Max Planck Society Begins Installation of Liquid-Cooled Supercomputer from Lenovo

July 9, 2020

Lenovo announced today that it is supplying a new high performance computer to the Max Planck Society, one of Germany's premier research organizations. Comprised of Intel Xeon processors and Nvidia A100 GPUs, and featuri Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Xilinx Announces First Adaptive Computing Challenge

July 9, 2020

A new contest is challenging the computing world. Xilinx has announced the first Xilinx Adaptive Computing Challenge, a competition that will task developers and startups with finding creative workload acceleration solutions. Xilinx is running the Adaptive Computing Challenge in partnership with, a developing community... Read more…

By Staff report

Reviving Moore’s Law? LBNL Researchers See Promise in Heterostructure Oxides

July 9, 2020

The reality of Moore’s law’s decline is no longer doubted for good empirical reasons. That said, never say never. Recent work by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory researchers suggests heterostructure oxides may b Read more…

By John Russell

President’s Council Targets AI, Quantum, STEM; Recommends Spending Growth

July 9, 2020

Last week the President Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) met (webinar) to review policy recommendations around three sub-committee reports: 1) Industries of the Future (IotF), chaired be Dario Gil (d Read more…

By John Russell

AWS Solution Channel

Best Practices for Running Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) Workloads on AWS

The scalable nature and variable demand of CFD workloads makes them well-suited for a cloud computing environment. Many of the AWS instance types, such as the compute family instance types, are designed to include support for this type of workload.  Read more…

Intel® HPC + AI Pavilion

Supercomputing the Pandemic: Scientific Community Tackles COVID-19 from Multiple Perspectives

Since their inception, supercomputers have taken on the biggest, most complex, and most data-intensive computing challenges—from confirming Einstein’s theories about gravitational waves to predicting the impacts of climate change. Read more…

Penguin Computing Brings Cascade Lake-AP to OCP Form Factor

July 7, 2020

Penguin Computing, a subsidiary of SMART Global Holdings, Inc., announced yesterday (July 6) a new Tundra server, Tundra AP, that is the first to implement the Intel Xeon Scalable 9200 series processors (codenamed Cascad Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Max Planck Society Begins Installation of Liquid-Cooled Supercomputer from Lenovo

July 9, 2020

Lenovo announced today that it is supplying a new high performance computer to the Max Planck Society, one of Germany's premier research organizations. Comprise Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

President’s Council Targets AI, Quantum, STEM; Recommends Spending Growth

July 9, 2020

Last week the President Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) met (webinar) to review policy recommendations around three sub-committee reports: Read more…

By John Russell

Google Cloud Debuts 16-GPU Ampere A100 Instances

July 7, 2020

On the heels of the Nvidia’s Ampere A100 GPU launch in May, Google Cloud is announcing alpha availability of the A100 “Accelerator Optimized” VM A2 instance family on Google Compute Engine. The instances are powered by the HGX A100 16-GPU platform, which combines two HGX A100 8-GPU baseboards using... Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Q&A: HLRS’s Bastian Koller Tackles HPC and Industry in Germany and Europe

July 6, 2020

In this exclusive interview for HPCwire – sadly not face to face – Steve Conway, senior advisor for Hyperion Research, talks with Dr.-Ing Bastian Koller about the state of HPC and its collaboration with Industry in Europe. Koller is a familiar figure in HPC. He is the managing director at High Performance Computing Center Stuttgart (HLRS) and also serves... Read more…

By Steve Conway, Hyperion

OpenPOWER Reboot – New Director, New Silicon Partners, Leveraging Linux Foundation Connections

July 2, 2020

Earlier this week the OpenPOWER Foundation announced the contribution of IBM’s A21 Power processor core design to the open source community. Roughly this time Read more…

By John Russell

Hyperion Forecast – Headwinds in 2020 Won’t Stifle Cloud HPC Adoption or Arm’s Rise

June 30, 2020

The semiannual taking of HPC’s pulse by Hyperion Research – late fall at SC and early summer at ISC – is a much-watched indicator of things come. This yea Read more…

By John Russell

Racism and HPC: a Special Podcast

June 29, 2020

Promoting greater diversity in HPC is a much-discussed goal and ostensibly a long-sought goal in HPC. Yet it seems clear HPC is far from achieving this goal. Re Read more…

Top500 Trends: Movement on Top, but Record Low Turnover

June 25, 2020

The 55th installment of the Top500 list saw strong activity in the leadership segment with four new systems in the top ten and a crowning achievement from the f Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Supercomputer Modeling Tests How COVID-19 Spreads in Grocery Stores

April 8, 2020

In the COVID-19 era, many people are treating simple activities like getting gas or groceries with caution as they try to heed social distancing mandates and protect their own health. Still, significant uncertainty surrounds the relative risk of different activities, and conflicting information is prevalent. A team of Finnish researchers set out to address some of these uncertainties by... Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

[email protected] Turns Its Massive Crowdsourced Computer Network Against COVID-19

March 16, 2020

For gamers, fighting against a global crisis is usually pure fantasy – but now, it’s looking more like a reality. As supercomputers around the world spin up Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

[email protected] Rallies a Legion of Computers Against the Coronavirus

March 24, 2020

Last week, we highlighted [email protected], a massive, crowdsourced computer network that has turned its resources against the coronavirus pandemic sweeping the globe – but [email protected] isn’t the only game in town. The internet is buzzing with crowdsourced computing... Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Supercomputer Simulations Reveal the Fate of the Neanderthals

May 25, 2020

For hundreds of thousands of years, neanderthals roamed the planet, eventually (almost 50,000 years ago) giving way to homo sapiens, which quickly became the do Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

DoE Expands on Role of COVID-19 Supercomputing Consortium

March 25, 2020

After announcing the launch of the COVID-19 High Performance Computing Consortium on Sunday, the Department of Energy yesterday provided more details on its sco Read more…

By John Russell

Honeywell’s Big Bet on Trapped Ion Quantum Computing

April 7, 2020

Honeywell doesn’t spring to mind when thinking of quantum computing pioneers, but a decade ago the high-tech conglomerate better known for its control systems waded deliberately into the then calmer quantum computing (QC) waters. Fast forward to March when Honeywell announced plans to introduce an ion trap-based quantum computer whose ‘performance’ would... Read more…

By John Russell

Neocortex Will Be First-of-Its-Kind 800,000-Core AI Supercomputer

June 9, 2020

Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center (PSC - a joint research organization of Carnegie Mellon University and the University of Pittsburgh) has won a $5 million award Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Global Supercomputing Is Mobilizing Against COVID-19

March 12, 2020

Tech has been taking some heavy losses from the coronavirus pandemic. Global supply chains have been disrupted, virtually every major tech conference taking place over the next few months has been canceled... Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Leading Solution Providers


10nm, 7nm, 5nm…. Should the Chip Nanometer Metric Be Replaced?

June 1, 2020

The biggest cool factor in server chips is the nanometer. AMD beating Intel to a CPU built on a 7nm process node* – with 5nm and 3nm on the way – has been i Read more…

By Doug Black

Nvidia’s Ampere A100 GPU: Up to 2.5X the HPC, 20X the AI

May 14, 2020

Nvidia's first Ampere-based graphics card, the A100 GPU, packs a whopping 54 billion transistors on 826mm2 of silicon, making it the world's largest seven-nanom Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

‘Billion Molecules Against COVID-19’ Challenge to Launch with Massive Supercomputing Support

April 22, 2020

Around the world, supercomputing centers have spun up and opened their doors for COVID-19 research in what may be the most unified supercomputing effort in hist Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Australian Researchers Break All-Time Internet Speed Record

May 26, 2020

If you’ve been stuck at home for the last few months, you’ve probably become more attuned to the quality (or lack thereof) of your internet connection. Even Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

15 Slides on Programming Aurora and Exascale Systems

May 7, 2020

Sometime in 2021, Aurora, the first planned U.S. exascale system, is scheduled to be fired up at Argonne National Laboratory. Cray (now HPE) and Intel are the k Read more…

By John Russell

Summit Supercomputer is Already Making its Mark on Science

September 20, 2018

Summit, now the fastest supercomputer in the world, is quickly making its mark in science – five of the six finalists just announced for the prestigious 2018 Read more…

By John Russell

TACC Supercomputers Run Simulations Illuminating COVID-19, DNA Replication

March 19, 2020

As supercomputers around the world spin up to combat the coronavirus, the Texas Advanced Computing Center (TACC) is announcing results that may help to illumina Read more…

By Staff report

$100B Plan Submitted for Massive Remake and Expansion of NSF

May 27, 2020

Legislation to reshape, expand - and rename - the National Science Foundation has been submitted in both the U.S. House and Senate. The proposal, which seems to Read more…

By John Russell

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
Share This