Berkeley Releases Cloud Computing Study

By Nicole Hemsoth

February 12, 2009

Researchers at the Reliable Adaptive Distributed Systems Laboratory (RAD Lab) at UC Berkeley have released a 23-page white paper, Above the Clouds [PDF], that provides an in-depth analysis of the emerging cloud computing model. The paper is one of the first academic treatises on the subject to offer a critical profile of the cloud computing landscape today.

We asked two of the paper’s authors, David Patterson, Professor in Computer Science at UC Berkeley, and Armando Fox, Adjunct Associate Professor at UC Berkeley’s RAD Lab, to elaborate on the findings and offer their perspective on how the cloud will impact high performance computing.

HPCwire: Cloud computing has come to mean a variety of things. For the purpose of our discussion here, how would you define it?

David Patterson: Cloud computing refers to both the applications delivered as services over the Internet and the hardware and systems software in the datacenters that provide those services. The services themselves have long been referred to as Software as a Service (SaaS). The datacenter hardware and software is what we will call a cloud. When a cloud is made available in a pay-as-you-go manner to the general public, we call it a “public cloud”; the service being sold is utility computing. We use the term “private cloud” to refer to internal datacenters of a business or other organization, not made available to the general public. Thus, cloud computing is the sum of SaaS and utility computing, but does not include private clouds.

We don’t use terms such as “X as a service” (XaaS); values of X we have seen include infrastructure, hardware, and platform, but we were unable to agree, even among ourselves, what the precise differences among them might be.

Armando Fox: The key ingredient is having tremendous computing resources instantly available on-tap with no advance arrangements needed and pay-as-you-go billing. Especially relevant is the fact that once you release unused resources, you don’t have to pay for them anymore. This property of “elasticity” shifts many risks from the users of that equipment to the provider of the equipment, creating new economic models that can change the way that startups, researchers, and even established enterprises think about IT spending.

HPCwire: Cloud computing is arguably the biggest paradigm shift in IT since the PC. Although similar concepts like utility computing and grid computing have been around for some time, they never attained widespread commercial success. What pieces of technology have come together to make cloud computing viable today?

Fox: While there are many technical factors, we believe the most important is the existence of extremely large datacenters built from tens of thousands of commodity computers. It turns out also that there are cost advantages of a factor of five to seven in capitalizing a datacenter at this scale compared to, say, a medium-sized enterprise datacenter of hundreds of computers. And the huge growth of the Internet drove companies such as Google, Amazon, eBay, and others to build such datacenters, to develop infrastructure software for them, such as Google File System or Amazon Dynamo, and to develop the operational expertise to armor them against the hostile environment of the public Internet.

Patterson: These technical advances were matched by a business model that offers three key features: 1) The illusion of infinite computing resources available on demand; 2) The elimination of an up-front commitment by cloud users, thereby allowing companies to start small; and 3) The ability to pay for use of computing resources on a short-term basis as needed and to release them when unneeded. Past efforts at utility computing failed because one or two of these three critical characteristics were missing. For example, Intel Computing Services in 2000-2001 required negotiating a contract and longer-term use than per hour.

Alas, grid computing created protocols that offered shared computation and storage over long distances and did not lead to a software environment that grew beyond the HPC community.

HPCwire: There are some prominent people in the industry like Richard Stallman — quoted in the paper — who portray cloud services as marketing hype and who are wary of becoming dependent on cloud and service providers. Is this just resistance to new paradigms or do people like Stallman have a valid point?

Fox: While we believe that cloud computing is definitely more than just “marketing hype,” we agree that the uncertainty of having one’s data and applications “locked in the cloud” may be a potential obstacle to cloud adoption. As we describe in the paper, cloud offerings may differ in the level of management and functionality offered in the cloud. For example, Amazon’s offering relies heavily on the appeal of a robust open-source software ecosystem and provides relatively little in the way of “built-in” functionality; whereas, Microsoft Azure allows deployed applications to run in a managed .NET environment and make use of the .NET framework and libraries, making those applications (and potentially, the data they manage) more difficult to move to another cloud provider that might not offer .NET.

Patterson: We think there is a potential danger to business continuity if you are dependent on a single cloud computing provider. We argue that such concerns can be addressed by standardizing APIs so that multiple providers can offer the same service, so that cloud computing users can move their application if a provider offers poor service or goes out of business.

The obvious fear is that this would lead to a “race-to-the-bottom” and would flatten the profits of cloud computing providers. We offer two arguments to allay this fear. First, the quality of a service matters as well as the price, so customers will not necessarily jump to the lowest cost service. Some Internet service providers today cost a factor of ten more than others because they are more dependable and offer extra services to improve usability. Second, standardization of APIs enables a new usage model in which the same software infrastructure can be used in a local datacenter and in a public cloud. Such an option could enable “surge computing,” in which the public cloud is used to capture the extra tasks that cannot be easily run in the datacenter (or private cloud) due to temporarily heavy workloads. We think surge computing could significantly expand the size of the cloud computing market.

HPCwire: The paper lists ten obstacles to cloud computing. Can you point to one or two that seem the most important overall, and also for high performance computing in particular?

Fox: It was really hard to rank-order these, and even the order in the paper is only a partial order. But we all agreed that cloud computing needs standardized APIs that would work across cloud vendors. This would help address TWO obstacles, namely maintaining high availability and preventing data lock-in. As far as technical obstacles, we observed that just as in the past, the cost of long-haul network bandwidth is falling more slowly than all other hardware costs, so we would like to see novel ways that cloud providers could address this high cost of data transfer, such as allowing customers to FedEx a box of disks directly to the cloud datacenter.

For HPC, we think some basic software infrastructure, such as gang scheduling for clouds, would help a lot; but in general, the HPC community has not had to go through the process of re-architecting software that the Web community went through in the 90s. We think there are plenty of opportunities for innovation if HPC steps up to the plate, and an early demonstration would go a long way toward jump starting that area. We’re discussing some possibilities at the Berkeley Par Lab, just upstairs from the RAD Lab.

HPCwire: The paper also describes some new application opportunities. Can you outline these and talk about why they are particularly suitable for cloud computing?

Fox: A major new area is allowing desktop apps to extend seamlessly into the cloud; for example, the popular analysis software MATLAB and Mathematica both support this now. Also, because of the “cost associativity” of the cloud — using 1,000 computers for an hour is the same price as one computer for 1,000 hours — it is great for apps that parallelize well, like document conversion, photo or video rendering, and so on. Of course, because of the relatively high cost of data transfer, the key is applications for which a lot of computing can be done on each byte transferred into the cloud — an observation made by Jim Gray in 2003 — and for which the latency to transfer that data is small compared to the time during which the data will remain “useful” in the cloud.

We also see the cloud supporting surge computing, where a private datacenter can temporarily overflow into a public cloud to support unexpected surges in workload.

HPCwire: Where do you think cloud computing will fit into the HPC application space?

Patterson: If technical issues like gang scheduling of VMs and higher network bandwidth within the datacenter are addressed, we think many users of HPC applications would love to take advantage of the cloud’s new cost associativity: no extra charge for using 20 times as many computers to get your results back in 1/20th the time. We’re conditioned to buying a set of computers and then trying to keep them uniformly busy. This elasticity of resources, without paying a premium for large scale, is unprecedented, so it will take a while for clever people to exploit this opportunity.

When HPC users don’t have to pay the costs of operating their computers — someone else pays for the building space, electricity, air conditioning, and so — they may conclude that on average they can get their work done for less than commercial cloud computing, but that seems more like bad accounting than good science.

HPCwire: How does future hardware and software need to be built to take advantage of the cloud model?

Fox: For software, one key approach is focusing on horizontal scalability — the ability to accommodate more users by adding more servers. At the level of storage systems and databases, this remains elusive, as evidenced by the various offerings such as Google AppEngine’s MegaStore, Amazon’s S3 and SimpleDB, and other scalable storage services. Also, to take advantage of elasticity means that software must automatically be able to adapt to unexpected workload changes, machine failures, and eventually, even whole-datacenter outages. Looking at the spectrum of clouds today, Amazon doesn’t provide any built-in service like this (though third parties such as RightScale are stepping in to fill that gap) but allows the developer to architect anything he wants; whereas, Google AppEngine severely constrains the software architecture of your app, but in return you get a lot of that automatic management for free.

Patterson: Hardware systems should be designed at the scale of a container (at least a dozen racks), which will be the minimum purchase size. Cost of operation will match performance and cost of purchase in importance, rewarding energy proportionality, which puts idle portions of the memory, disk and network into low power mode. Processors should work well with VMs; flash memory should be added to the memory hierarchy; and LAN switches and WAN routers must improve in bandwidth and cost.

—–

For more discussion of Berkeley’s cloud computing research, go to the Above the Clouds Web site.

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

Long Flights to Cluster Fights: Meet the Asian Student Cluster Teams

November 22, 2017

Five teams from Asia traveled thousands of miles to compete at the SC17 Student Cluster Competition in Denver. Our cameras were there to meet ‘em, greet ‘em, and grill ‘em about their clusters and how they’re doi Read more…

By Dan Olds

Japan Unveils Quantum Neural Network

November 22, 2017

The U.S. and China are leading the race toward productive quantum computing, but it's early enough that ultimate leadership is still something of an open question. The latest geo-region to throw its hat in the quantum co Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Perspective: What Really Happened at SC17?

November 22, 2017

SC is over. Now comes the myriad of follow-ups. Inboxes are filled with templated emails from vendors and other exhibitors hoping to win a place in the post-SC thinking of booth visitors. Attendees of tutorials, workshop Read more…

By Andrew Jones

HPE Extreme Performance Solutions

HPE Wins “Best HPC Server” for the Apollo 6000 Gen10 System

Hewlett Packard Enterprise (HPE) was nominated for 14 HPCwire Readers’ and Editors’ Choice Awards—including “Best High Performance Computing (HPC) Server Product or Technology” and “Top Supercomputing Achievement.” The HPE Apollo 6000 Gen10 was named “Best HPC Server” of 2017. Read more…

Turnaround Complete, HPE’s Whitman Departs

November 22, 2017

Having turned around the aircraft carrier the Silicon Valley icon had become, Meg Whitman is leaving the helm of a restructured Hewlett Packard. Her successor, technologist Antonio Neri will now guide what Whitman assert Read more…

By George Leopold

Long Flights to Cluster Fights: Meet the Asian Student Cluster Teams

November 22, 2017

Five teams from Asia traveled thousands of miles to compete at the SC17 Student Cluster Competition in Denver. Our cameras were there to meet ‘em, greet ‘em Read more…

By Dan Olds

Perspective: What Really Happened at SC17?

November 22, 2017

SC is over. Now comes the myriad of follow-ups. Inboxes are filled with templated emails from vendors and other exhibitors hoping to win a place in the post-SC Read more…

By Andrew Jones

SC Bids Farewell to Denver, Heads to Dallas for 30th Anniversary

November 17, 2017

After a jam-packed four-day expo and intensive six-day technical program, SC17 has wrapped up another successful event that brought together nearly 13,000 visit Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

SC17 Keynote – HPC Powers SKA Efforts to Peer Deep into the Cosmos

November 17, 2017

This week’s SC17 keynote – Life, the Universe and Computing: The Story of the SKA Telescope – was a powerful pitch for the potential of Big Science projects that also showcased the foundational role of high performance computing in modern science. It was also visually stunning. Read more…

By John Russell

How Cities Use HPC at the Edge to Get Smarter

November 17, 2017

Cities are sensoring up, collecting vast troves of data that they’re running through predictive models and using the insights to solve problems that, in some Read more…

By Doug Black

Student Cluster LINPACK Record Shattered! More LINs Packed Than Ever before!

November 16, 2017

Nanyang Technological University, the pride of Singapore, utterly destroyed the Student Cluster Competition LINPACK record by posting a score of 51.77 TFlop/s a Read more…

By Dan Olds

Hyperion Market Update: ‘Decent’ Growth Led by HPE; AI Transparency a Risk Issue

November 15, 2017

The HPC market update from Hyperion Research (formerly IDC) at the annual SC conference is a business and social “must,” and this year’s presentation at S Read more…

By Doug Black

Nvidia Focuses Its Cloud Containers on HPC Applications

November 14, 2017

Having migrated its top-of-the-line datacenter GPU to the largest cloud vendors, Nvidia is touting its Volta architecture for a range of scientific computing ta Read more…

By George Leopold

US Coalesces Plans for First Exascale Supercomputer: Aurora in 2021

September 27, 2017

At the Advanced Scientific Computing Advisory Committee (ASCAC) meeting, in Arlington, Va., yesterday (Sept. 26), it was revealed that the "Aurora" supercompute Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

NERSC Scales Scientific Deep Learning to 15 Petaflops

August 28, 2017

A collaborative effort between Intel, NERSC and Stanford has delivered the first 15-petaflops deep learning software running on HPC platforms and is, according Read more…

By Rob Farber

Oracle Layoffs Reportedly Hit SPARC and Solaris Hard

September 7, 2017

Oracle’s latest layoffs have many wondering if this is the end of the line for the SPARC processor and Solaris OS development. As reported by multiple sources Read more…

By John Russell

AMD Showcases Growing Portfolio of EPYC and Radeon-based Systems at SC17

November 13, 2017

AMD’s charge back into HPC and the datacenter is on full display at SC17. Having launched the EPYC processor line in June along with its MI25 GPU the focus he Read more…

By John Russell

Nvidia Responds to Google TPU Benchmarking

April 10, 2017

Nvidia highlights strengths of its newest GPU silicon in response to Google's report on the performance and energy advantages of its custom tensor processor. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Google Releases Deeplearn.js to Further Democratize Machine Learning

August 17, 2017

Spreading the use of machine learning tools is one of the goals of Google’s PAIR (People + AI Research) initiative, which was introduced in early July. Last w Read more…

By John Russell

GlobalFoundries Puts Wind in AMD’s Sails with 12nm FinFET

September 24, 2017

From its annual tech conference last week (Sept. 20), where GlobalFoundries welcomed more than 600 semiconductor professionals (reaching the Santa Clara venue Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Amazon Debuts New AMD-based GPU Instances for Graphics Acceleration

September 12, 2017

Last week Amazon Web Services (AWS) streaming service, AppStream 2.0, introduced a new GPU instance called Graphics Design intended to accelerate graphics. The Read more…

By John Russell

Leading Solution Providers

SC17 Booth Video Tours

EU Funds 20 Million Euro ARM+FPGA Exascale Project

September 7, 2017

At the Barcelona Supercomputer Centre on Wednesday (Sept. 6), 16 partners gathered to launch the EuroEXA project, which invests €20 million over three-and-a-half years into exascale-focused research and development. Led by the Horizon 2020 program, EuroEXA picks up the banner of a triad of partner projects — ExaNeSt, EcoScale and ExaNoDe — building on their work... Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Delays, Smoke, Records & Markets – A Candid Conversation with Cray CEO Peter Ungaro

October 5, 2017

Earlier this month, Tom Tabor, publisher of HPCwire and I had a very personal conversation with Cray CEO Peter Ungaro. Cray has been on something of a Cinderell Read more…

By Tiffany Trader & Tom Tabor

Cray Moves to Acquire the Seagate ClusterStor Line

July 28, 2017

This week Cray announced that it is picking up Seagate's ClusterStor HPC storage array business for an undisclosed sum. "In short we're effectively transitioning the bulk of the ClusterStor product line to Cray," said CEO Peter Ungaro. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Reinders: “AVX-512 May Be a Hidden Gem” in Intel Xeon Scalable Processors

June 29, 2017

Imagine if we could use vector processing on something other than just floating point problems.  Today, GPUs and CPUs work tirelessly to accelerate algorithms Read more…

By James Reinders

Intel Launches Software Tools to Ease FPGA Programming

September 5, 2017

Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) have a reputation for being difficult to program, requiring expertise in specialty languages, like Verilog or VHDL. Easin Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

HPC Chips – A Veritable Smorgasbord?

October 10, 2017

For the first time since AMD's ill-fated launch of Bulldozer the answer to the question, 'Which CPU will be in my next HPC system?' doesn't have to be 'Whichever variety of Intel Xeon E5 they are selling when we procure'. Read more…

By Dairsie Latimer

Flipping the Flops and Reading the Top500 Tea Leaves

November 13, 2017

The 50th edition of the Top500 list, the biannual publication of the world’s fastest supercomputers based on public Linpack benchmarking results, was released Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

IBM Advances Web-based Quantum Programming

September 5, 2017

IBM Research is pairing its Jupyter-based Data Science Experience notebook environment with its cloud-based quantum computer, IBM Q, in hopes of encouraging a new class of entrepreneurial user to solve intractable problems that even exceed the capabilities of the best AI systems. Read more…

By Alex Woodie

Share This