Reliable Memory: Coming to a GPU Near You

By Michael Feldman

September 2, 2009

GPUs are becoming more like CPUs. But in the critical area of error corrected memory, graphics hardware still lags. The lack of error correction is probably the single biggest factor that makes users of GPUs for high performance computing nervous. Some HPC applications are resistant to the occasional bad data value, but many are not. The good news is that graphics chip vendors are aware of the problem and it appears to be only a matter of time before GPUs get a memory makeover.

Before AMD and NVIDIA brought GPU computing onto the scene, graphics processors didn’t really need to be concerned with error-prone memory. If a pixel’s color is off by a bit or two, nobody is going to notice as the images go flying by. So it was natural (and cheaper) for GPU devices to be built without support for error corrected memory. In 2006, with the advent of general-purpose computing on graphics processing units, otherwise know as GPGPU, the issue of reliable memory came to the fore.

The problem is that when you’re using the GPU as a math accelerator and a memory bit flips in a data value, you’ve got a potential problem. Obviously in numerical calculations, accuracy matters. That’s why all standard CPU servers today come with memory that supports Error Correcting Codes (ECC) as well as with on-chip intelligence for error checking and correction in cache and local data structures. The reason that general-purpose computing can be done on GPUs at all has to do with the relatively infrequent occurrence of these errors on standard graphics hardware. Algorithms are typically run many times in a typical technical computing application, so anomalous results can be averaged out, or even manually discarded.

The only simple way to circumvent the problem on the current crop of GPUs is to run the code twice (or simultaneously on two separate devices). If the results don’t match, you assume an error occurred and you rerun the offending sequence. It’s relatively bulletproof, but you’ve cut your price-performance in half for the sake of error correction. A less brute-force method was devised by the Tokyo Institute of Technology, who came up with software-based ECC for GPUs (PDF). But the preliminary results showed the performance overhead was acceptable only for compute-intensive applications, not bandwidth-intensive ones.

There are different categories of memory errors. The kind most people focus on are thought to be the result of cosmic rays, alpha particles in packaging material, or possibly as a side-effect of harsh environmental conditions. They are called soft (or transient) errors and most commonly occur in off-chip DRAM, but can also strike the GPU ASIC itself in local memory or data registers.

Hard (or permanent) errors can also be present on memory chips, but these are easy to detect with simple diagnostic tests. Hard errors are usually dealt with by replacing the offending memory module, but theoretically could be handled in software too. The conventional wisdom is that soft errors are much more common than hard errors, although at least one study (PDF) by Google found just the opposite.

Data errors can also occur at the memory bus interface. Here, at least, the graphics world has made some progress. GDDR5 (Graphics Double Data Rate, version 5) memory, which first appeared in 2008, was the first memory specification for graphics platforms that contained an error detection facility. The motivation behind this was the high data rates of GDDR5, which made the odds of producing bad data much more likely. Since GDDR5 contains an error correction protocol, a compatible memory controller is able to take corrective action — basically a retry — to compensate.

That still leaves a lot of data on the GPU board exposed. Adding ECC memory to GPU boards intended for the technical computing market is a relatively straightforward product decision since the extra cost can be passed on to the GPGPU consumer. But changing the GPU core as well as the integrated memory controller to complete the protection requires a tradeoff, since extra transistors are needed for error detection and correction on the ASIC. And because of the expense of designing and testing chips, GPUs are shared across product lines at AMD and NVIDIA.

For example, the latest AMD FireStream products use the Radeon HD 4800 core, while the current NVIDIA Tesla platforms uses (presumably) the GeForce GTX 285. These are the same ASICs used in high-end graphics products. The challenge to the two GPGPU vendors is to figure out how to design processors that offer the data reliability of a CPU server, without impacting their core graphics business unduly.

Patricia Harrell, AMD’s director of Stream Computing, admits that the need for more robust data protection in GPUs already exists. She says error corrected memory is a requirement for a number of customers, especially those looking to deploy GPUs at scale, i.e., high performance computing users with large compute clusters. Although individual memory error rates are low, as you add more GPUs (and thus more graphics memory) to the system, and run applications for longer periods of time, the chances of hitting a flipped memory bit increases proportionally.

The AMD FireStream 9270 board already incorporates GDDR5 memory, so data protection is already in place at the memory interface in this product. In this case, whenever the memory controller sends and receives data to and from the DRAM, it buffers the data locally while the DRAM calculates the integrity of the value and returns a status code. If the code indicates an error, the memory controller does the retry automatically.

Overall though, AMD seems to be taking a cautious approach to error correcting GPUs. “It’s really important to put in the required features intelligently, and make sure you do the research and engineering to protect the data structures that are going to return the most value,” notes Harrell. If not, she says, you end up with devices that are too big and too hot, in which case you lose the performance advantages GPGPU was originally intended for.

Harrell says that they are continuing to look at the memory protection issue, but couldn’t offer more specific guidance on AMD’s roadmap. “I think it isn’t clear if that [error correction] is going to be required for the broad market yet,” she adds.

Unlike AMD’s more wait-and-see attitude, NVIDIA appears to be fully committed to bringing error protection to GPU computing. According to Andy Keane, general manager of the GPU computing business unit at NVIDIA, it is not a matter of if, but when. From his point of view, ECC memory is a hard requirement in datacenters. “We have to respond to that by building that kind of support into our roadmap,” Keane said unequivocally. “It will be in a future GPU.”

As far as when ECC-capable Tesla products will show up, Keane wouldn’t say. It’s likely that NVIDIA’s OEM partners and GPU computing developers already have a pretty good idea of the timeline (under NDA of course), so systems and software based on high-integrity GPUs may already be in the works. In a Real World Technologies article that spells out the major costs and benefits of error corrected memory in GPUs, analyst David Kanter predicts that NVIDIA’s next GPGPU product release will include ECC.

Presumably Intel is also mulling over its options, since Larrabee, the company’s first high-end graphics processor, is scheduled to be released into the wild next year. But Intel insists the first version of Larrabee will target the traditional graphics space, making it unlikely that they would introduce ECC into the mix. Of course, the company could reverse itself and release a true HPC processor variant with ECC bells and whistles.

My sense is that ECC will come to GPU computing products sooner (1-2 years) rather that later (3-5 years). Being able to ensure data integrity in these devices will widen the aperture for HPC applications and help push GPGPU into true supercomputers. Just like double precision performance and on-board memory capacity, error correction is destined to become an important differentiator in high-end GPU computing.

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

Microsoft Wants to Speed Quantum Development

December 12, 2017

Quantum computing continues to make headlines in what remains of 2017 as tech giants jockey to establish a pole position in the race toward commercialization of quantum. This week, Microsoft took the next step in advanci Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

ESnet Now Moving More Than 1 Petabyte/wk

December 12, 2017

Optimizing ESnet (Energy Sciences Network), the world's fastest network for science, is an ongoing process. Recently a two-year collaboration by ESnet users – the Petascale DTN Project – achieved its ambitious goal t Read more…

HPC-as-a-Service Finds Toehold in Iceland

December 11, 2017

While high-demand workloads (e.g., bitcoin mining) can overheat data center cooling capabilities, at least one data center infrastructure provider has announced an HPC-as-a-service offering that features 100 percent fre Read more…

By Doug Black

HPE Extreme Performance Solutions

Explore the Origins of Space with COSMOS and Memory-Driven Computing

From the formation of black holes to the origins of space, data is the key to unlocking the secrets of the early universe. Read more…

HPC Iron, Soft, Data, People – It Takes an Ecosystem!

December 11, 2017

Cutting edge advanced computing hardware (aka big iron) does not stand by itself. These computers are the pinnacle of a myriad of technologies that must be carefully woven together by people to create the computational c Read more…

By Alex R. Larzelere

Microsoft Wants to Speed Quantum Development

December 12, 2017

Quantum computing continues to make headlines in what remains of 2017 as tech giants jockey to establish a pole position in the race toward commercialization of Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

HPC Iron, Soft, Data, People – It Takes an Ecosystem!

December 11, 2017

Cutting edge advanced computing hardware (aka big iron) does not stand by itself. These computers are the pinnacle of a myriad of technologies that must be care Read more…

By Alex R. Larzelere

IBM Begins Power9 Rollout with Backing from DOE, Google

December 6, 2017

After over a year of buildup, IBM is unveiling its first Power9 system based on the same architecture as the Department of Energy CORAL supercomputers, Summit a Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Microsoft Spins Cycle Computing into Core Azure Product

December 5, 2017

Last August, cloud giant Microsoft acquired HPC cloud orchestration pioneer Cycle Computing. Since then the focus has been on integrating Cycle’s organization Read more…

By John Russell

GlobalFoundries, Ayar Labs Team Up to Commercialize Optical I/O

December 4, 2017

GlobalFoundries (GF) and Ayar Labs, a startup focused on using light, instead of electricity, to transfer data between chips, today announced they've entered in Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

HPE In-Memory Platform Comes to COSMOS

November 30, 2017

Hewlett Packard Enterprise is on a mission to accelerate space research. In August, it sent the first commercial-off-the-shelf HPC system into space for testing Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

SC17 Cluster Competition: Who Won and Why? Results Analyzed and Over-Analyzed

November 28, 2017

Everyone by now knows that Nanyang Technological University of Singapore (NTU) took home the highest LINPACK Award and the Overall Championship from the recently concluded SC17 Student Cluster Competition. We also already know how the teams did in the Highest LINPACK and Highest HPCG competitions, with Nanyang grabbing bragging rights for both benchmarks. Read more…

By Dan Olds

Perspective: What Really Happened at SC17?

November 22, 2017

SC is over. Now comes the myriad of follow-ups. Inboxes are filled with templated emails from vendors and other exhibitors hoping to win a place in the post-SC thinking of booth visitors. Attendees of tutorials, workshops and other technical sessions will be inundated with requests for feedback. Read more…

By Andrew Jones

US Coalesces Plans for First Exascale Supercomputer: Aurora in 2021

September 27, 2017

At the Advanced Scientific Computing Advisory Committee (ASCAC) meeting, in Arlington, Va., yesterday (Sept. 26), it was revealed that the "Aurora" supercompute Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

NERSC Scales Scientific Deep Learning to 15 Petaflops

August 28, 2017

A collaborative effort between Intel, NERSC and Stanford has delivered the first 15-petaflops deep learning software running on HPC platforms and is, according Read more…

By Rob Farber

Oracle Layoffs Reportedly Hit SPARC and Solaris Hard

September 7, 2017

Oracle’s latest layoffs have many wondering if this is the end of the line for the SPARC processor and Solaris OS development. As reported by multiple sources Read more…

By John Russell

AMD Showcases Growing Portfolio of EPYC and Radeon-based Systems at SC17

November 13, 2017

AMD’s charge back into HPC and the datacenter is on full display at SC17. Having launched the EPYC processor line in June along with its MI25 GPU the focus he Read more…

By John Russell

Nvidia Responds to Google TPU Benchmarking

April 10, 2017

Nvidia highlights strengths of its newest GPU silicon in response to Google's report on the performance and energy advantages of its custom tensor processor. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Japan Unveils Quantum Neural Network

November 22, 2017

The U.S. and China are leading the race toward productive quantum computing, but it's early enough that ultimate leadership is still something of an open questi Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

GlobalFoundries Puts Wind in AMD’s Sails with 12nm FinFET

September 24, 2017

From its annual tech conference last week (Sept. 20), where GlobalFoundries welcomed more than 600 semiconductor professionals (reaching the Santa Clara venue Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Google Releases Deeplearn.js to Further Democratize Machine Learning

August 17, 2017

Spreading the use of machine learning tools is one of the goals of Google’s PAIR (People + AI Research) initiative, which was introduced in early July. Last w Read more…

By John Russell

Leading Solution Providers

Amazon Debuts New AMD-based GPU Instances for Graphics Acceleration

September 12, 2017

Last week Amazon Web Services (AWS) streaming service, AppStream 2.0, introduced a new GPU instance called Graphics Design intended to accelerate graphics. The Read more…

By John Russell

Perspective: What Really Happened at SC17?

November 22, 2017

SC is over. Now comes the myriad of follow-ups. Inboxes are filled with templated emails from vendors and other exhibitors hoping to win a place in the post-SC thinking of booth visitors. Attendees of tutorials, workshops and other technical sessions will be inundated with requests for feedback. Read more…

By Andrew Jones

EU Funds 20 Million Euro ARM+FPGA Exascale Project

September 7, 2017

At the Barcelona Supercomputer Centre on Wednesday (Sept. 6), 16 partners gathered to launch the EuroEXA project, which invests €20 million over three-and-a-half years into exascale-focused research and development. Led by the Horizon 2020 program, EuroEXA picks up the banner of a triad of partner projects — ExaNeSt, EcoScale and ExaNoDe — building on their work... Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Delays, Smoke, Records & Markets – A Candid Conversation with Cray CEO Peter Ungaro

October 5, 2017

Earlier this month, Tom Tabor, publisher of HPCwire and I had a very personal conversation with Cray CEO Peter Ungaro. Cray has been on something of a Cinderell Read more…

By Tiffany Trader & Tom Tabor

Tensors Come of Age: Why the AI Revolution Will Help HPC

November 13, 2017

Thirty years ago, parallel computing was coming of age. A bitter battle began between stalwart vector computing supporters and advocates of various approaches to parallel computing. IBM skeptic Alan Karp, reacting to announcements of nCUBE’s 1024-microprocessor system and Thinking Machines’ 65,536-element array, made a public $100 wager that no one could get a parallel speedup of over 200 on real HPC workloads. Read more…

By John Gustafson & Lenore Mullin

Flipping the Flops and Reading the Top500 Tea Leaves

November 13, 2017

The 50th edition of the Top500 list, the biannual publication of the world’s fastest supercomputers based on public Linpack benchmarking results, was released Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

IBM Begins Power9 Rollout with Backing from DOE, Google

December 6, 2017

After over a year of buildup, IBM is unveiling its first Power9 system based on the same architecture as the Department of Energy CORAL supercomputers, Summit a Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Intel Launches Software Tools to Ease FPGA Programming

September 5, 2017

Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGAs) have a reputation for being difficult to program, requiring expertise in specialty languages, like Verilog or VHDL. Easin Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
Share This