Déjà Vu All Over Again

By Nicole Hemsoth

November 16, 2009

Steve Wallach, a supercomputing legend and recipient of the 2008 IEEE Seymour Cray Award, has participated in all 22 supercomputing shows. He is known for his contributions to high performance computing through the design of innovative vector and parallel computing systems. He is co-founder and chief science officer for Convey Computer Corp., a new company with a hybrid-core computer that marries the low cost and simple programming model of a commodity system with the performance of customized hardware architecture.

Never short on opinions, especially when it comes to high performance computing, Steve Wallach talked to HPCwire about the future of HPC and how lessons from the past can point the way for the future.

HPCwire: There’s been a lot of talk about how recent architecture advancements will bring GPU computing into the mainstream for high performance computing with significant speedups and energy savings. You disagree. Why?

Steve Wallach: GPUs are an interesting technology and some applications will probably see significant speed-up, but I don’t see them in the mainstream. Here’s why: programmers will have to put in a lot of effort to get the speed-up. Real-world applications consist of millions of lines of code, and organizations have invested too much money in those programs. If you tell them they have to modify those programs to use your technology, you lose. And it’s not just the software that has to be changed; it is the entire programming eco-structure: debuggers, profilers, and programming memory. Anything that disturbs those underlying realities is destined to become a niche player. This is the biggest difference between an accelerator and a coprocessor. A coprocessor is an extension to the instruction set and is part of the same environment. GPUs are not. A GPU consists of two different programming environments and you have to move the data back and forth between them to get the benefits. The host cannot see the memory of the GPU; there are two separate address spaces.

It’s similar to what we saw with attached array processors in the 80s. What we saw back then that you had to explicitly move and manage the data — which reduced programmer productivity, raised actual cost of ownership and ultimately reduced performance. Like back then, the GPU programming model is different from its host.

GPUs initially did not have ECC correctable memory, now they do. This, however, demonstrates their lack of general purpose computing requirements. You have to work hard to make it work and not every application is amenable. The memory structure of a GPU is meant to be optimal for sequential access, but many programs require non-unity stride which will reduce performance for those applications. Classical supercomputers from Cray, Convex, NEC, and Fujitsu had very high bandwidth, highly interleaved main memory. A GPU is not going to be a general-purpose or a wide-spread solution for technical and software reasons. You can only execute the “hot spot” on the GPU, for example, and still need a classical host like the x86. It is not an integrated system. And, as of now, GPUs do not support virtual memory.

The GPU is really just a contemporary version of an attached array processor. If you look at the last 30 years, the architectures that have succeeded in the long term have been the ones that are easiest to program and that fit into the current environment. New languages take time to be learned and adopted. Organizations can’t hire the right people to program the machines. Each new full-time equivalent programmer who has to be hired can easily add $200,000 to $300,000 to the costs of the new system per year. This is not a new phenomenon; it has been true for the past few decades. The time to reconfigure is really expensive.

HPCwire: You’ve said that “software is the ‘Trojan Horse’ of high-performance computing.” What do you mean by that?

Wallach: As an organization, you accept the hardware — the horse — and then the next day the software warriors pour out and devour your IT department. As technology enthusiasts, we get excited by new technologies based on peak performance micro-architecture and the software questions come later as well as questions about “how do I fit it into my environment?” and “will I be able to achieve this level of performance with my applications?”

This has been true for the last 30 and will be true for the next 30 years. If you go back to the 80s — you had all kinds of interesting technologies like array processors and others, but the ones that had the best software succeeded such as Convex, Cray and Alliant. They succeeded because the programmer could leverage the technology for their FORTRAN and C environments. Integrated solutions like these succeeded and companies like CDC failed because their software was part of an anemic development environment. As another example from the past, the Japanese (Fujitsu and NEC) had exceptional software environments.
 
Fast forward to today. It’s like déjà vu all over again. A lot of new technologies are evolving but are not dealing with the software environment. Previous FPGA vendors had this problem. They were not integrated with the host environment. Vector processors, such as ClearSpeed, have this problem and this is true of all accelerators and GPUs.

The GPUs have some great technologies for visualization, for example, but are not integrated. You have to learn how to program in new languages like CUDA and there aren’t a lot of major applications written in CUDA. Programmers have to re-code or set up source translators that facilitate FORTRAN to CUDA. There are no translators for FORTRAN to assembly code and from a technical perspective it is much more efficient to go from FORTRAN to assembly code. Source to source translators are NOT as efficient as compilation to assembly code.

HPCwire: You talk about Convey’s hybrid-core computer as being an application specific, low power node. What is the significance of this description to the market?

Wallach: In the past decade, every generation has added new, specific instructions to general purpose computers to speed performance. For example, the current x86 system enhances image processing and new instructions have been developed to enhance vector processing. Since clock cycles are basically flat, you will see the trend toward specific instructions built into the microprocessors increasing. If one instruction can replace 10 instructions, you will have reduced power for that application. Our view is that it is now time to step up and increase the functionality of this approach. We advocate having one instruction to replace 100 instructions. Now you don’t have to rely on clock cycles to increase performance. You are relying instead on data and control paths. This approach is extremely useful for Convey and allows us to significantly increase performance while reducing power requirements, footprint and overall facility costs for a data center.

HPCwire: In order to be successful, do you think new computing paradigms need to leverage existing eco-structures like Linux and Windows?

Wallach: Absolutely. As I said before, new languages mean higher costs and lower productivity. In VC deals, whenever I hear that you have to program in a new language to make it work, I turn it down.

With new computing paradigms, you get several benefits when they leverage existing eco-structures like Linux and Windows. First off, they are more easily acceptable in the marketplace. If I’m the data center manager, I don’t have to hire anyone new or have training for a new eco-structure. No need to program in OCCAM, for example. I call programs that don’t take into consideration legacy systems and that are obscenely difficult to integrate, “pornographic” programs — you can’t always describe them exactly, but you know them when you see them. In 1984, I converted a FORTRAN program from CDC to ANSI FORTRAN to see what they were doing and it was awful. In the contemporary world, CUDA is the new pornographic programming language.

In addition, Windows and Linux allow for adoption of related technologies from other industries without changing the programming environment. Industry innovators such as the researchers at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory believe, for example, that future supercomputers will use the processors found in cell phones and other hand-held devices. Why? Because they use so little energy and have proven that they can handle sophisticated tasks (October 2009, IEEE Spectrum: “Low-Power Supercomputers” ). It is easy for the manufacturers to build chips designed for specific HPC applications just like they build different chips for each Smartphone brand. Chip manufacturers will also provide the software — compilers, debuggers, profiling tools, even complete Linux operating systems — tailored to each specific chip they sell which will make the new systems easy to integrate into a current environment.

HPCwire: Last year in HPCwire you said the future of HPC involves improved software, in particular more widespread use of PGAS languages and optical interconnects. Is this still the case?

Wallach: Yes. I believe the need for optical interconnects increases as we build large systems. The efficiency of scaling in parallel processing has to do with bandwidth and latency. Optical interconnects are much more efficient in terms of speed and power as compared to copper. PGAS (partitioned global address space) languages allow programmers a global view of their dataset and are much more efficient. PGAS languages also make it much easier to program highly parallel systems — they are much better than MPI.

HPCwire: Speaking of software, where is Convey on its development of different software personalities?

Wallach: We are on track with our development of personalities. Convey’s personalities are application architectures and instruction sets that support a wide array of application-specific solutions. Rather than develop hundreds of unique applications, we a creating a manageable number of personalities that can be leveraged in hundreds of different ways. We’ve shipped a range of different personalities for different customers, and we’ve got several others in development.

In the end, we anticipate developing around a dozen different core personalities. This is consistent with what leading researchers have determined, also. For example, in the study published by the University of California at Berkeley, “The Landscape of Parallel Computing Research: A View from Berkeley,” researchers define what they call MOTIFs or computer application structures for HPC. They describe 13 computer application structures on the Y access with the X access representing a particular application and how it uses that structure. Berkeley’s view is consistent with ours that there are approximately a dozen different personalities that cover the full spectrum of computing. In our development, we add a third element to the equation — the memory system — and see this as a three-dimensional grid. For this case, a unity stride (access sequential elements — dense data); or a highly interleaved (access non-sequential elements — multiple independently accessible memory banks — sparse data); or a “smart” memory (PIM – perform specific operations in the memory system — thread based) system is required for optimal performance.

We are on track to have personalities with memory structure and instruction sets with these MOTIFs, which is where we believe computing is going. For the HC-1, we ultimately anticipate 13 MOTIFs — but some will use the same personality.

HPCwire: Convey has just started shipping production units, can you tell us about the company’s early customers and how they’re using the HC-1?

Wallach: Early applications for the HC-1 follow the classic profile of HPC applications: signal-image processing, computer simulations, bioinformatics, and other applications we can’t discuss at this time. We have HC-1s going into the world’s leading research labs, all of which we will talk about during SC09 at our booth.

You can catch up with Steve Wallach during SC09, where he is participating in a talk on “HPC Architectures: Future Technologies and Systems” from 1:30-2:00 p.m. on Thursday (Rm. E143-144); or at Convey’s booth (#2589).

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industry updates delivered to you every week!

High-Performance Storage for AI and Analytics Panel

October 31, 2024

When storage is mentioned in an AI or Big Data analytics context, it is assumed to be a high-performance system. In practice, it may not be, and the user eventually learns about scaleable storage as the amounts of data g Read more…

White House Mulls Expanding AI Chip Export Bans Beyond China

October 31, 2024

The Biden administration is reportedly considering capping sales of advanced artificial intelligence (AI) chips from US-based manufacturers like AMD and Nvidia to certain countries, including those in the Middle East. � Read more…

Lottery to Determine Major AI Conference Attendees Amid Registration Boom

October 31, 2024

A boom in AI has created a problem for the organizers of the NeurIPS conference, which is considered an essential machine-learning research conference. The sheer number of registrations has overwhelmed organizers, who Read more…

Role Reversal: Google Teases Nvidia’s Blackwell as It Softens TPU Rivalry

October 30, 2024

Customers now have access to Google's homegrown hardware -- its Axion CPU and latest Trillium TPU -- in its Cloud service.  At the same time, Google gave customers a teaser on Nvidia's Blackwell coming to Google Cloud, Read more…

AI Has a Data Problem, Appen Report Says

October 30, 2024

AI may be a priority at American companies, but the difficulty in managing data and obtaining high quality data to train AI models is becoming a bigger hurdle to achieving AI aspirations, according to Appen’s State of Read more…

Microsoft Azure & AMD Solution Channel

Join Microsoft Azure and AMD at SC24

Atlanta, Georgia is the place to be this fall as the high-performance computing (HPC) community convenes for Supercomputing 2024. SC24 will bring together an unparalleled mix of scientists, engineers, researchers, educators, programmers, and developers for a week of learning and sharing. Read more…

Report from HALO Details Issues Facing HPC-AI Industry

October 28, 2024

Intersect360 Research has released a comprehensive new report concerning the challenges facing the combined fields of high-performance computing (HPC) and artificial intelligence (AI). Titled “Issues Facing the HPC-AI Read more…

High-Performance Storage for AI and Analytics Panel

October 31, 2024

When storage is mentioned in an AI or Big Data analytics context, it is assumed to be a high-performance system. In practice, it may not be, and the user eventu Read more…

Shutterstock_556401859

Role Reversal: Google Teases Nvidia’s Blackwell as It Softens TPU Rivalry

October 30, 2024

Customers now have access to Google's homegrown hardware -- its Axion CPU and latest Trillium TPU -- in its Cloud service.  At the same time, Google gave custo Read more…

AI Has a Data Problem, Appen Report Says

October 30, 2024

AI may be a priority at American companies, but the difficulty in managing data and obtaining high quality data to train AI models is becoming a bigger hurdle t Read more…

Report from HALO Details Issues Facing HPC-AI Industry

October 28, 2024

Intersect360 Research has released a comprehensive new report concerning the challenges facing the combined fields of high-performance computing (HPC) and artif Read more…

Archetype AI’s Newton Model Masters Physics From Raw Data

October 28, 2024

Physicists have developed a deep understanding of the fundamental laws of nature through careful observations, experiments, and precise measurements. However, w Read more…

PNNL-Microsoft Collaborate on Cloud Computing for Chemistry, More to Come

October 25, 2024

RICHLAND, Wash.—Some computing challenges are so big that it’s necessary to go all in. That’s the approach a diverse team of scientists and computing expe Read more…

Xeon 6 vs. Zen-5 HPC Benchmark Showdown

October 24, 2024

In this GPU age, CPUs are often considered second citizens because most of the performance comes from the GPU. In most systems, GPUs are separate PCIe devices u Read more…

Nvidia’s Newest Foundation Model Can Actually Spell ‘Strawberry’

October 23, 2024

A new AI model from Nvidia knows just how many R’s are in the word strawberry, a feat that OpenAI’s GPT-4o model has yet to achieve. In what is known as the Read more…

Leading Solution Providers

Contributors

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
HPCwire