Remote Direct Memory Access Networking for HPC: Comparative Review of 10GbE iWARP and InfiniBand

By Saqib Jang

February 24, 2010

The Rise of HPC Cluster Computing

While the HPC market is expected to experience a revenue dip in 2009, growth is expected to resume in 2010 and remain a bright spot in the overall IT market. The most important feature of the HPC growth trend is that it will continue to be fueled primarily by purchases of Linux cluster systems priced under $250,000. Cluster computing systems, separate compute nodes built from standard component technologies have caused disruptive changes in the HPC market.

As the component technologies of cluster systems have improved and buyers have become more confident running cluster systems, they have inevitably redirected capital once earmarked for large custom systems to larger cluster systems. These much larger clusters, often with thousands of processors, present opportunities for huge performance gains through improved parallel performance resulting in an overall higher order of magnitude return-on-investment (ROI). While algorithm and application tuning is often required to obtain these benefits, so often are cost, bandwidth, message rate, and latency of cluster interconnects.

One consequence of the range of requirements for cluster networking is that the leading interconnects in HPC are Gigabit Ethernet (which is based on Ethernet networking standard) and InfiniBand (delivering upwards of 10X performance vs. GbE). Both show significant deployment in HPC. The latest TOP500 list of HPC systems has 259 Gigabit Ethernet-based deployments compared to 181 InfiniBand-connected systems. The deployment of 10 Gigabit Ethernet (10GbE) cluster networking is emerging at this point. The price of this interconnect has been falling as the volume of its shipments grow. This growth is based on a combination of its 10X performance over GbE along with the ease of deployment due to its Ethernet heritage positions it for a bright future as a cluster interconnect.

As cluster systems have grown, so has the total amount of data in play in the average parallel HPC application. This has significant implications for HPC storage systems. Storage systems need to have the best possible bandwidth and latency characteristics. HPC storage systems have themselves become increasingly clustered and parallel as well as network-attached and accessible from all nodes on the cluster through the interconnect. In this context, the demand for interconnect solutions that supports a converged storage and cluster interconnect fabric is expected to grow significantly.

10GbE iWARP Overview and Value Proposition

For years, Ethernet has been the de facto standard LAN for connecting users to each other and to network resources. Ethernet sales volumes make it unquestionably the most cost-effective datacenter fabric to deploy and maintain. The latest generation of Ethernet, 10 Gigabit Ethernet (10GbE), offers a 10 Gbps data rate, which simplifies growth for existing data networking applications while removing the bandwidth barriers to deployment for highest-performance HPC clustering and storage networking.

  • 10GbE end-to-end performance now compares very favorably with that of more specialized datacenter interconnects, which eliminates performance as a drawback to the adoption of an Ethernet unified data center fabric.
     
  • Off-loading cluster and storage protocol processing from the central CPU to intelligent 10GbE NIC can also improve the power efficiency of end stations because off-load ASIC processors are generally considerably more power-efficient in executing protocol workloads.
     
  • The value of implementing TCP/IP protocol processing in silicon at 10 Gbps data rates is clear. Effectively, such approaches have the potential of reducing the relative bandwidth and latency overhead effect of TCP/IP protocol processing to zero.

Achieving 10GbE performance for latency-sensitive HPC communications has required solving Ethernet’s long-standing overhead problems; problems that, in slower Ethernet generations, were adequately overcome by steadily increasing CPU clock speeds.

Enter 10GbE iWARP

The iWARP extensions to TCP/IP focus on eliminating the three major sources of networking overhead — transport (TCP/IP) processing, intermediate buffer copies, and application context switches — that collectively account for nearly 100 percent of CPU overhead related to networking. Specifically, iWARP implements a number of mechanisms to provide a low-latency means of passing RDMA over Ethernet.

The iWARP extensions utilize advanced techniques to reduce CPU overhead, memory bandwidth utilization, and latency by a combination of offloading TCP/IP processing from the CPU, eliminating unnecessary buffering, and dramatically reducing expensive operating system calls and context switches — moving data management and network protocol processing to an accelerated RDMA over TCP/IP NIC (or R-NIC) 10 Gigabit Ethernet adapter.

R-NICs can reduce CPU utilization for 10 Gbps transfers to less than 10 percent and can reduce the host component of end-to-end latency to as little as 5–10 microseconds. High port-count 10GbE switches are available, which delivers HPC-class latency performance within 100’s of nanoseconds.

InfiniBand Overview and Value Proposition

InfiniBand is an I/O architecture designed to increase the communication speed between CPUs, devices within servers and subsystems located throughout a network. The original goal behind the release of the InfiniBand specification by the InfiniBand Trade Association was to address the mismatch between the speed of CPUs and the PCI I/O bus, as well as other deficiencies of the PCI bus, including bus sharing, scalability, and fault tolerance.

InfiniBand is a point-to-point, switched I/O fabric architecture. Both devices at each end of a link have full access to the communication path. To go beyond a point and traverse the network, switches come into play. By adding switches, multiple points can be interconnected to create a fabric. As more switches are added to a network, aggregated bandwidth of the fabric increases. By adding multiple paths between devices, switches also provide a greater level of redundancy.

A single InfiniBand link supports 2.5 Gbps in each direction per connection. InfiniBand supports double (DDR) and quad data rate (QDR) speeds, for 5 Gbps or 10 Gbps respectively, at the same data-clock rate. InfiniBand links use 8B/10B encoding — every 10 bits sent carry 8 bits of data, which meansthe net data transmission rate is four-fifths the raw rate. Thus single, double, and quad data rates carry 2, 4, or 8 Gbps respectively.

A quad-rate 12X link therefore carries 120 Gbps raw, or 96 Gbps of useful data. At present, most systems use 4X 10 Gbps (SDR), 20 Gbps (DDR) or 40 Gbps (QDR) connections. However, InfiniBand QDR performance is bounded by the 26 Gbps PCIe Gen2 throughput limitation.

Latency performance of InfiniBand SDR ad DDR switch chips is around 200 nanoseconds. InfiniBand Host Channel Adapters (HCAs) are rated 1-3 microseconds (although effective application-level performance is a different matter).

High-end clustering architectures have provided the main opportunity for InfiniBand deployment. Using the InfiniBand fabric versus Gigabit Ethernet as the cluster inter-process communications (IPC) interconnect typically boosts cluster performance and scalability while improving application response times. InfiniBand also provides exceptional scalability and failover in comparison to Gigabit Ethernet. In short, compared to Gigabit Ethernet, InfiniBand stands out in providing the mechanisms necessary to support the demanding requirements of high-end clustering.

iWARP and InfiniBand Comparative Review

As far as its compatibility with existing datacenter infrastructure, because it is layered on top of TCP, iWARP is fully compatible with existing Ethernet switching equipment that is able to process iWARP traffic out-of-the-box. In comparison, deploying InfiniBand requires environments where two separate network infrastructures are installed and managed as well as specialized InfiniBand to Ethernet gateways for bridging between the two infrastructures.

10GbE infrastructure is available from a range of incumbent and startup vendors. Intel, Broadcom, and Chelsio provide 10GbE iWARP adapters, while 10GbE switches are available from a broad range of vendors including Cisco, HP, IBM, BLADE Network Technologies, Extreme, Force10, Arista, and Voltaire. InfiniBand host channel adapter and switch silicon is only available from two vendors (Mellanox and QLogic), who in turn have signed up a number of OEMs to carry adapter and switching systems.

Both interconnects offer equivalent capabilities for supporting operating systems. The OpenFabrics software stack that is fully integrated into the flavors of Linux distributed by Novell and Red Hat fully supports both 10GbE iWARP and InfiniBand.

10GbE iWARP leverages its heritage to also support acceleration of emerging Ethernet-based storage protocols, including file storage (NFS-RDMA), which is fully supported by the Linux OFED stack. In addition, the Linux OFED stack also enables 10GbE iWARP to out-of-the-box support Lustre networking (LNET). In addition, 10GbE iWARP adapters can also provide concurrent, native support for standard Ethernet protocols such as NFS, CIFS, and iSCSI. In comparison, InfiniBand has had minimal deployments for server-to-storage communications, whether for file or block storage.

Regarding pricing, major server vendors are starting to add a 10 Gigabit Ethernet chip to the motherboard-known as LAN-on-Motherboard (LOM). NIC prices will continue to drop as LOM technology lets NIC vendors reach the high volumes they need to keep costs down, which in turn will drive switch port prices down as well. InfiniBand, on the other hand, has reached a mature market position and, consequently, reductions in the pricing of InfiniBand products will be relatively gradual.

Large-scale clusters built using 10GbE iWARP technology and high port-count 10Gbe switches are gaining ground, and cluster scalability is no longer viewed as inhibiting 10Gbe deployment. InfiniBand technology is an established interconnect for building large node-count clusters.

From a roadmap standpoint, the Ethernet market is moving forward aggressively to develop and implement 40G and 100G-based standards. It is expected that the standard for these versions of Ethernet will be ratified during 2010 and initial implementations based on these standards will be shipping from a range of vendors in the blade server and Ethernet networking switch markets within the next 2 to 3 years.

Converged Enhanced Ethernet

The IEEE has been developing standards collectively referred to as “Data Center Bridging” (DCB) or “Converged Enhanced Ethernet” (CEE) This refers to high speed Ethernet (currently 10 Gbps, with a clear path to 40 Gbps and 100 Gbps), plus a number of new features. The main new features are:

  • Priority-Based Flow Control (802.1Qbb), sometimes called “per-priority pause”
  • Enhanced Transmission Selection (802.1Qaz)
  • Congestion Notification (802.1Qau)

The first two features allow splitting an Ethernet link into multiple “virtual links” that operate independently — bandwidth can be reserved for a given virtual link, and by having per-virtual-link flow control, CEE can ensure that certain traffic classes do not overrun their buffers thus avoiding dropping packets. This congestion notification capability means that we can tell senders to slow down to avoid congestion spreading caused by that flow control.

CEE was developed primarily for use in Fibre Channel over Ethernet (FCoE). FC requires a very reliable network — it simply does not work if packets are dropped because of congestion — and, so, CEE provides the ability to segregate FCoE traffic on top of a “no drop” virtual link.

The roadmap initiatives in the InfiniBand space consist of QDR, EDR (2011), and RDMA over CEE. However, these roadmap initiatives suffer from the same limitations that have been a traditional challenge for InfiniBand, namely, limited vendor support.

RoCEE Overview and Value Proposition

Mellanox, the leader in the InfiniBand market, is behind the emerging RDMA over Converged Enhanced Ethernet (RoCEE) protocol proposal. RoCEE is designed to allow the deployment of RDMA semantics on Converged Enhanced Ethernet fabric by running the IB transport protocol using Ethernet frames.

Mellanox’s RoCEE proposal was motivated in order to create a protocol analogous to FCoE for Ethernet-based cluster networking. In other words, to take the InfiniBand transport layer and package it into Ethernet frames, instead of using the iWARP protocol for Ethernet-based high-performance cluster networking. But there are a number of challenges associated with this proposal:

First, one of the major motivations behind the RoCEE proposal is that it is the fastest path forward for an Ethernet-based alternative to InfiniBand. However, this ignores the fact that iWARP adapters are already shipping from multiple vendors, including Intel, Chelsio, and Broadcom. In addition, iWARP will automatically leverage the performance benefits of CEE as support for it will be ubiquitous in all 10GbE server adapter and LOM implementations, iWARP and non-iWARP alike.

Second, the idea that an InfiniBand over Ethernet (IBoE) specification will be quick or easy to develop flies in the face of the experience with FcoE. While FCoE sounded simple in concept, it turns out that the standards work took at least three years. In comparison, IBoE is more complicated to specify, and fewer resources are available for it, so a realistic view is that a true standard is very far away.

Last, RoCEE proponents point to the performance overhead challenges related to iWARP based on the TCP/IP protocol. However, this does not take into account the efficiency of silicon-based implementations of 10 Gbps TCP/IP. In addition, iWARP is also positioned to automatically take advantage of CEE as that protocol gains ubiquity in 10GbE server LOM and adapters.

In summary, RoCEE is unproven and its deployment faces significant hurdles including standardization and application and upper layer adoption. In addition, RoCEE is dependent on the deployment of 10GbE CEE infrastructure; currently only one vendor (Cisco) offers CEE switches, which are at relatively high price points.

About the Author

Saqib Jang is founder and principal at Margalla Communications, a Woodside, Calif.-based strategic and technical marketing consulting firm focused on storage and server networking.

This article is an excerpt from a Margalla Communications white paper entitled High-speed Remote Direct Memory Access (RDMA) Networking for HPC: Comparative Review of 10GbE iWARP and InfiniBand available at www.margallacomm.com.

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

European HPC Summit Week and PRACEdays 2018: Slaying Dragons and SHAPEing Futures One SME at a Time

June 20, 2018

The University of Ljubljana in Slovenia hosted the third annual EHPCSW18 and fifth annual PRACEdays18 events which opened May 29, 2018. The conference was chaired by PRACE Council Vice-Chair Sergi Girona (Barcelona Super Read more…

By Elizabeth Leake (STEM-Trek for HPCwire)

An Overview of ‘OpenACC for Programmers’ from the Book’s Editors

June 20, 2018

In an era of multicore processors coupled with manycore accelerators in all kinds of devices from smartphones all the way to supercomputers, it is important to train current and future computational scientists of all dom Read more…

By Sunita Chandrasekaran and Guido Juckeland

Cray Introduces All Flash Lustre Storage Solution Targeting HPC

June 19, 2018

Citing the rise of IOPS-intensive workflows and more affordable flash technology, Cray today introduced the L300F, a scalable all-flash storage solution whose primary use case is to support high IOPS rates to/from a scra Read more…

By John Russell

HPE Extreme Performance Solutions

HPC and AI Convergence is Accelerating New Levels of Intelligence

Data analytics is the most valuable tool in the digital marketplace – so much so that organizations are employing high performance computing (HPC) capabilities to rapidly collect, share, and analyze endless streams of data. Read more…

IBM Accelerated Insights

Preview the World’s Smartest Supercomputer at ISC 2018

Introducing an accelerated IT infrastructure for HPC & AI workloads Read more…

Lenovo to Debut ‘Neptune’ Cooling Technologies at ISC

June 19, 2018

Lenovo today announced a set of cooling technologies, dubbed Neptune, that include direct to node (DTN) warm water cooling, rear door heat exchanger (RDHX), and hybrid solutions that combine air and liquid cooling. Lenov Read more…

By John Russell

European HPC Summit Week and PRACEdays 2018: Slaying Dragons and SHAPEing Futures One SME at a Time

June 20, 2018

The University of Ljubljana in Slovenia hosted the third annual EHPCSW18 and fifth annual PRACEdays18 events which opened May 29, 2018. The conference was chair Read more…

By Elizabeth Leake (STEM-Trek for HPCwire)

Cray Introduces All Flash Lustre Storage Solution Targeting HPC

June 19, 2018

Citing the rise of IOPS-intensive workflows and more affordable flash technology, Cray today introduced the L300F, a scalable all-flash storage solution whose p Read more…

By John Russell

Sandia to Take Delivery of World’s Largest Arm System

June 18, 2018

While the enterprise remains circumspect on prospects for Arm servers in the datacenter, the leadership HPC community is taking a bolder, brighter view of the x86 server CPU alternative. Amongst current and planned Arm HPC installations – i.e., the innovative Mont-Blanc project, led by Bull/Atos, the 'Isambard’ Cray XC50 going into the University of Bristol, and commitments from both Japan and France among others -- HPE is announcing that it will be supply the United States National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) with a 2.3 petaflops peak Arm-based system, named Astra. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

The Machine Learning Hype Cycle and HPC

June 14, 2018

Like many other HPC professionals I’m following the hype cycle around machine learning/deep learning with interest. I subscribe to the view that we’re probably approaching the ‘peak of inflated expectation’ but not quite yet starting the descent into the ‘trough of disillusionment. This still raises the probability that... Read more…

By Dairsie Latimer

Xiaoxiang Zhu Receives the 2018 PRACE Ada Lovelace Award for HPC

June 13, 2018

Xiaoxiang Zhu, who works for the German Aerospace Center (DLR) and Technical University of Munich (TUM), was awarded the 2018 PRACE Ada Lovelace Award for HPC for her outstanding contributions in the field of high performance computing (HPC) in Europe. Read more…

By Elizabeth Leake

U.S Considering Launch of National Quantum Initiative

June 11, 2018

Sometime this month the U.S. House Science Committee will introduce legislation to launch a 10-year National Quantum Initiative, according to a recent report by Read more…

By John Russell

ORNL Summit Supercomputer Is Officially Here

June 8, 2018

Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) together with IBM and Nvidia celebrated the official unveiling of the Department of Energy (DOE) Summit supercomputer toda Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Exascale USA – Continuing to Move Forward

June 6, 2018

The end of May 2018, saw several important events that continue to advance the Department of Energy’s (DOE) Exascale Computing Initiative (ECI) for the United Read more…

By Alex R. Larzelere

MLPerf – Will New Machine Learning Benchmark Help Propel AI Forward?

May 2, 2018

Let the AI benchmarking wars begin. Today, a diverse group from academia and industry – Google, Baidu, Intel, AMD, Harvard, and Stanford among them – releas Read more…

By John Russell

How the Cloud Is Falling Short for HPC

March 15, 2018

The last couple of years have seen cloud computing gradually build some legitimacy within the HPC world, but still the HPC industry lies far behind enterprise I Read more…

By Chris Downing

US Plans $1.8 Billion Spend on DOE Exascale Supercomputing

April 11, 2018

On Monday, the United States Department of Energy announced its intention to procure up to three exascale supercomputers at a cost of up to $1.8 billion with th Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Deep Learning at 15 PFlops Enables Training for Extreme Weather Identification at Scale

March 19, 2018

Petaflop per second deep learning training performance on the NERSC (National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center) Cori supercomputer has given climate Read more…

By Rob Farber

Lenovo Unveils Warm Water Cooled ThinkSystem SD650 in Rampup to LRZ Install

February 22, 2018

This week Lenovo took the wraps off the ThinkSystem SD650 high-density server with third-generation direct water cooling technology developed in tandem with par Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

ORNL Summit Supercomputer Is Officially Here

June 8, 2018

Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) together with IBM and Nvidia celebrated the official unveiling of the Department of Energy (DOE) Summit supercomputer toda Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Nvidia Responds to Google TPU Benchmarking

April 10, 2017

Nvidia highlights strengths of its newest GPU silicon in response to Google's report on the performance and energy advantages of its custom tensor processor. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Hennessy & Patterson: A New Golden Age for Computer Architecture

April 17, 2018

On Monday June 4, 2018, 2017 A.M. Turing Award Winners John L. Hennessy and David A. Patterson will deliver the Turing Lecture at the 45th International Sympo Read more…

By Staff

Leading Solution Providers

SC17 Booth Video Tours Playlist

Altair @ SC17

Altair

AMD @ SC17

AMD

ASRock Rack @ SC17

ASRock Rack

CEJN @ SC17

CEJN

DDN Storage @ SC17

DDN Storage

Huawei @ SC17

Huawei

IBM @ SC17

IBM

IBM Power Systems @ SC17

IBM Power Systems

Intel @ SC17

Intel

Lenovo @ SC17

Lenovo

Mellanox Technologies @ SC17

Mellanox Technologies

Microsoft @ SC17

Microsoft

Penguin Computing @ SC17

Penguin Computing

Pure Storage @ SC17

Pure Storage

Supericro @ SC17

Supericro

Tyan @ SC17

Tyan

Univa @ SC17

Univa

Google Chases Quantum Supremacy with 72-Qubit Processor

March 7, 2018

Google pulled ahead of the pack this week in the race toward "quantum supremacy," with the introduction of a new 72-qubit quantum processor called Bristlecone. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Google I/O 2018: AI Everywhere; TPU 3.0 Delivers 100+ Petaflops but Requires Liquid Cooling

May 9, 2018

All things AI dominated discussion at yesterday’s opening of Google’s I/O 2018 developers meeting covering much of Google's near-term product roadmap. The e Read more…

By John Russell

Nvidia Ups Hardware Game with 16-GPU DGX-2 Server and 18-Port NVSwitch

March 27, 2018

Nvidia unveiled a raft of new products from its annual technology conference in San Jose today, and despite not offering up a new chip architecture, there were still a few surprises in store for HPC hardware aficionados. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Pattern Computer – Startup Claims Breakthrough in ‘Pattern Discovery’ Technology

May 23, 2018

If it weren’t for the heavy-hitter technology team behind start-up Pattern Computer, which emerged from stealth today in a live-streamed event from San Franci Read more…

By John Russell

Part One: Deep Dive into 2018 Trends in Life Sciences HPC

March 1, 2018

Life sciences is an interesting lens through which to see HPC. It is perhaps not an obvious choice, given life sciences’ relative newness as a heavy user of H Read more…

By John Russell

Intel Pledges First Commercial Nervana Product ‘Spring Crest’ in 2019

May 24, 2018

At its AI developer conference in San Francisco yesterday, Intel embraced a holistic approach to AI and showed off a broad AI portfolio that includes Xeon processors, Movidius technologies, FPGAs and Intel’s Nervana Neural Network Processors (NNPs), based on the technology it acquired in 2016. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Google Charts Two-Dimensional Quantum Course

April 26, 2018

Quantum error correction, essential for achieving universal fault-tolerant quantum computation, is one of the main challenges of the quantum computing field and it’s top of mind for Google’s John Martinis. At a presentation last week at the HPC User Forum in Tucson, Martinis, one of the world's foremost experts in quantum computing, emphasized... Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Cray Rolls Out AMD-Based CS500; More to Follow?

April 18, 2018

Cray was the latest OEM to bring AMD back into the fold with introduction today of a CS500 option based on AMD’s Epyc processor line. The move follows Cray’ Read more…

By John Russell

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
Share This