Well NVIDIA waited exactly five days into the new year to announce a major new direction for its product roadmap. On Wednesday, the GPU-maker — and soon to be CPU-maker — revealed its plans to build heterogeneous processors, which will encompass high performance ARM CPU cores alongside GPU cores. The strategy parallel’s AMD’s Fusion architectural approach that marries x86 CPUs with ATI GPUs on-chip.
The upcoming NVIDIA processors, developed under the codename “Project Denver,” will span NVIDIA’s non-mobile product line, powering personal computers, workstations, servers and supercomputers. The announcement was made by company CEO Jen-Hsun Huang at the annual Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Las Vegas. Huang called the news “one of the most strategic announcements we have ever made at NVIDIA.” And that might be an understatement.
NVIDIA already uses ARM cores on its Tegra line of processors for mobile computing platforms. That SoC design integrates a 32-bit ARM CPU alongside its GPU cores to power handheld devices such as smartphones, personal digital assistants and tablets. (The company also announced its Tegra 2 generation of processors this week at CES.) With the upcoming Project Denver processors, this heterogeneous platform will be extended across the rest of NVIDIA’s product lines, up to and including the Tesla HPC offerings.
As part of this strategy, the company has obtained rights to develop its own NVIDIA-designed high performance CPU cores using ARM’s future processor architecture. Presumably this will be based on a future 64-bit implementation of the ARM ISA, given that 64-bit computing is the accepted standard outside of the mobile space.
According to the HPC luminary Jack Dongarra, NVIDIA’s decision to marry ARM with GPUs makes sense. “They couldn’t license the X86 architecture and needed a CPU platform for their move to more general computing, integrating both CPU- and GPU-based computing.” he said. “ARM is a logical choice, giving NVIDIA an opportunity to move in both the low power direction and up to high performance computing.”
The overarching rationale here is essentially the same as AMD’s: to glue CPU and GPU logic together on the same chip so as to take advantage of the sequential and parallel processing capabilities, respectively, of the two architectures. The proximity of both logic engines to main memory and on-chip resources makes for a much more efficient computing environment. Integration also affords major power efficiency advantages, something that is absolutely critical in both the handheld space and now the datacenter. In particular, as supercomputers move from petascale to exascale, power constraints will force system builders to abandon monolithic x86-based systems, a process that has already begun with the latest generation of GPGPU-equipped supercomputers.
Each of NVIDIA product lines (Tegra, Quadro, GeForce, and Tesla) have their own roadmaps on how the ARM CPU will be folded in. For the Tesla line, ARM integration will take place on the upcoming “Maxwell” generation, according to Andy Keane, general manager of NVIDIA’s Tesla business. The Maxwell architecture is scheduled to be introduced in 2013, following the “Kepler” GPUs that due to be unveiled later this year.
By moving their entire portfolio to a CPU-GPU architecture, NVIDIA is looking to leverage their R&D costs across all product segments, from handhelds to PCs to supercomputers — in the same way Intel and AMD do with their x86-based chips. In fact, it’s the same business model NVIDIA already employs with their own CUDA GPU architecture.
“The technologies for the future have to have some basis in the volume market,” Keane told HPCwire. “It has to have some reason to exist other than the relatively small volume of the HPC business. That’s why this makes sense.”
The wildcard here is ARM. For this to work, NVIDIA needs to create that volume market in Project Denver clients and servers. For decades, the x86 CPU has been the standard-bearer for non-mobile computing, and this new approach is a direct challenge to that status quo. In announcing the new architecture, Huang pointed out the ARM shipments already far outstrip x86 volume, and, thanks to the rise of mobile computing, that gap is expected to increase substantially over the next four years.
As a result, there are a wealth of existing compiler and other software development tools for ARM platforms. Conveniently, support for Linux (and now Windows) is also in place. “What we have to do for the Tesla business, like we have done currently with the GPU, is to make sure that the [ARM] ecosystem is adapted correctly for HPC,” said Keane.
ARM’s disadvantage is that the architecture’s footprint is currently non-existent in the PC and server arena. Attracting OEMs and system integrators to build non-x86 platforms will certainly be a hurtle for the GPU-maker. However, with the new emphasis on power, especially in the datacenter, the RISC-architected ARM has some real advantages. Combined with a mature software stack and backed by NVIDIA, ARMed GPUs have the potential to upset many segments of x86-dominated computing.
NVIDIA’s new path puts it in much more direct competition with Intel and AMD, who are now all vying for the same market segments, and who will soon have little if any reliance on each other’s chips. With Project Denver processors now gearing up to go head-to-head against Intel MIC/integrated graphics and AMD Fusion chips, this young decade just got a lot more interesting.