July 20, 2011

Intel Takes Aim at Switch Chip Business with Fulcrum Deal

Michael Feldman

Intel has signed a definitive agreement to acquire switch silicon maker Fulcrum Microsystems. The deal adds Ethernet switch chips to Intel’s growing portfolio of networking products. The agreement, whose terms remain under wraps, was announced on Tuesday.

Founded in 2000, Fulcrum is a privately-owned company that has been singularly focused on creating merchant silicon for high performance, lossless Ethernet networks. The company’s two main product lines are its FocalPoint Ethernet chip family for network processing on switches and routers and its PivotPoint interconnect chip for packet processing on the line card. The foundational technology was developed at Caltech in the 1990s.

The emphasis on performance, and especially low latency, attracted performance-minded Ethernet switch vendors like Arista Networks and BLADE Network Technologies (now under IBM ownership). And until Mellanox scooped up Voltaire, the latter’s Ethernet switches employed Fulcrum silicon as well. HPC storage maker Panasas also found a use for Fulcrum hardware in its ActiveStor product line. All told, Fulcrum claims its switch chips are used across 250 customer designs.

With cut-through latencies in the 200-300ns range and per-port power draw under one watt, Fulcrum’s FocalPoint chip is just slightly less impressive than the latest InfiniBand hardware and on par with any competing Ethernet solution. For example, Mellanox claims its ambidextrous SwitchX silicon will deliver 160ns latency and about 2 watts per port for FDR (56 Gbps) InfiniBand, while providing 230ns latency and 0.6 watts when it switches to 10GbE.

The Fulcrum designs dovetail nicely with vendors who want to deliver cutting-edge 10GbE and 40GbE switching for high performance computing, cloud infrastructure, and other latency-sensitive datacenter applications. But the larger trend, and the one that Intel is likely to be most interested in long-term, is the commoditization of network switching.

Up until fairly recently, the accepted way to build switches was with custom silicon, often produced in-house by the switch manufacturers. With the appearance of merchant silicon vendors like Broadcom, Marvell and Fulcrum, that model is changing, threatening vendors like Cisco, which has long relied on its own chipsets. Just this week, it was reported that Lazard Capital analyst Daniel Amir sees Cisco beginning to transition to merchant silicon solutions.

That suggests that network switching is undergoing the same sort of transition that occurred in the server arena over the last 20 years, as most of the market moved from custom-build CPUs like Sparc and Power to x86. Over the last couple of years, Intel has seen its Xeon CPUs start to dominate in storage boxes and expects the same to happen in switches, replacing MIPS, Power CPUs and custom-built processors.

All of this reflects a larger strategy at Intel to establish a wider footprint in the datacenter. Since the chipmaker morphed its server division into the Data Center Group a couple years ago, the company has broadened its focus to encompass network and storage gear. The move parallels the shift of some of Intel’s biggest enterprise customers, like IBM, HP, and Cisco, to package up “converged infrastructure” solutions, rather than just sell servers, storage and networking in a piecemeal fashion.

And although Intel has been selling Ethernet adapter chips and NICs on the host side for awhile, the Fulcrum addition will further their expansion on switch side, says Steve Schultz, director of marketing in Intel’s LAN Access Division. “More and more we’re seeing a lot of the switching and routing gear transitioning to Intel-based processors,” he told HPCwire. “This is very complementary to that.”

For Fulcrum customers, this is bound to be good news. Even though the company has been racking up impressive revenue numbers of late, expanding from $1.1 million in sales in 2006 to $6.4 million in 2009, it remains a small business with about a $100 million worth of VC money to answer to. Its five principal investors, New Enterprise Associates, Infinity Capital, Granite Ventures, Palomar Ventures and Worldview Technology Partners, will presumably all get their just desserts once the Intel deal closes.

In addition, being able to draw on Intel’s considerable resources would put Fulcrum’s product set on a much more stable foundation. And although Intel has not talked about moving the network chips into its own fabs — the switch chips are currently manufactured by TSMC — the chipmaker will undoubtedly want to leverage its world-class manufacturing technology.

Schultz says the existing Fulcrum team will remain intact and the business will be folded into the LAN Access Division, which itself is run out of the Data Center Group. The acquisition is subject to shareholder and regulatory approval, but according to Schultz no glitches are foreseen. The deal is expected to close in 30 to 35 days.

Share This