OpenCL Gains Ground On CUDA

By Michael Feldman

February 28, 2012

As the two major programming frameworks for GPU computing, OpenCL and CUDA have been competing for mindshare in the developer community for the past few years. Until recently, CUDA has attracted most of the attention from developers, especially in the high performance computing realm. But OpenCL software has now matured to the point where HPC practitioners are taking a second look.

Both OpenCL and CUDA provide a general-purpose model for data parallelism as well as low-level access to hardware, but only OpenCL provides an open, industry-standard framework. As such, it has garnered support from nearly all processor manufacturers including AMD, Intel, and NVIDIA, as well as others that serve the mobile and embedded computing markets. As a result, applications developed in OpenCL are now portable across a variety of GPUs and CPUs.

Although OpenCL 1.0 was introduced in December 2008, just a year and a half after the NVIDIA launched its first version of CUDA, OpenCL still trails CUDA in popularity by a wide margin, especially with regard to HPC. That is mostly due to a concerted effort by NVIDIA to establish CUDA as the dominant programming framework for GPU application development in this realm..

AMD has been the most vocal booster of OpenCL technology for technical computing, but it’s lack of a competitive product set for high-end GPU computing has muted that message. Thus far, OpenCL usage has been mostly relegated to client-side computing, especially for mobile platforms, which have increasingly incorporated GPU silicon into their designs. Apple, who initially developed OpenCL before handing it off to the open-standard Khronos Group, was instrumental in getting the technology off the ground.

The knock on OpenCL for HPC users has been lack of maturity, which has resulted in low performance, compared to CUDA. There is also the perception that support from the principle HPC chipmakers (Intel, AMD and NVIDIA) would be less than enthusiastic, at least for their high-end processors. In many ways, that’s still true, given that NVIDIA is devoting most of its attention to its home-grown CUDA software, while Intel seems to have settled on its own parallel programming frameworks, mainly Cilk Plus and Threading Building Blocks.

AMD though, continues to champion OpenCL, and some of their more recent compiler and library releases have improved performance considerably. In fact, Kyle Spafford, from the Future Technology Group at Oak Ridge National Lab (ORNL), has been benchmarking the two technologies for some time and is now convinced that OpenCL performance is now on par with that of CUDA. He recently presented his findings at Georgia Tech’s Keeneland Workshop.

Spafford’s ran ORNL’s Scalable Heterogeneous Computing Benchmark Suite (SHOC) that has been optimized for both CUDA and OpenCL, and found that OpenCL can match CUDA performance on most of the basic math kernels. He also found that OpenCL’s performance on some kernels, like SGEMM, has increased 10-fold since 2009. The one code that CUDA still has a significant performance advantage is that of the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT). Spafford attributes CUDA’s better FFT performance on its use of a fast intrinsic, with OpenCL implementation (NVIDIA’s in this case*) employing a slower, more accurate version. If the implementations are matched, the performance difference goes away, says Spafford.

Others have found similar behavior on stand-alone science applications. A research group at Dartmouth running a numerical model of gravitation waves with OpenCL and CUDA found similar performance between OpenCL and CUDA, in this case on Tesla GPUs and IBM’s Cell BE processors. In the resulting paper, the researchers conclude that “an OpenCL-based implementation delivers comparable performance to that based on a native SDK on both types of accelerator hardware.”

GPU software maker AccelerEyes has seen CUDA and OpenCL performance equalize. The company, which recently released OpenCL-powered beta versions of their two flagship software products, ArrayFire and Jacket, has found that for most kernel codes, the two technologies now exhibit similar performance. Like ORNL, they found FFT speed is still better on CUDA due to NVIDIA’s faster implementation, but AMD’s OpenCL compiler and libraries have improved considerably, both in scope and performance.

According to AccelerEyes CEO John Melonakos, over half of their customers develop their GPU-accelerated code on their PCs before deploying to a workstation or cluster, so the ability to support non-NVIDIA hardware can be quite useful. For example, customers using MacBooks as development platforms couldn’t run CUDA there because Apple has no NVIDIA GPU option on its latest laptops. And since the AMD OpenCL libraries that AccelerEyes used in their beta offerings work just fine on Intel CPUs, AMD CPUs, and NVIDIA GPUs, there are no hardware incompatibility issues.

Then there are users who are just unwilling to adopt vendor-specific software stacks such as CUDA. “There are a class of people who absolutely want to do GPU computing but are resistant to anything that is vendor-locked,” Melonakos told HPCwire. He says this is group that has jumped onto their OpenCL-based offerings first.

To counter that kind of perception, NVIDIA has recently opened up the CUDA compiler source code for third-party developers. Significantly though, NVIDIA is not putting its all-important CUDA math libraries, like CUBLAS and CUFFT, into the open source pot. According to Melonakos, the large and mature library set is CUDA’s real strength in the technical computing arena. Open source or not, NVIDIA still retains control of the CUDA software technology, which is why it is still perceived as a vendor-specific solution.

Even NVIDIA and Intel are hedging their bets with OpenCL though, with both vendors offering software hooks for their respective hardware. At this point, these companies are providing this support as a nod to their mobile computing developers (although Intel is reportedly working on a MIC processor port too). But since there is an increasing amount of cross-pollination between mobile and HPC these days, it’s not clear how developers will end up using these technologies.

In fact, if the mobile space latches onto OpenCL in a big way and it becomes the standard low-level solution for heterogenous computing, that could help speed its adoption at the high-end. Once OpenCL reaches a critical mass of acceptance in a volume market such as that, there will be a rapid increase in demand for robust compilers and libraries. As Melonakos put it: “I dont think OpenCL is going away.”

[Editor’s note: The original article erroneously stated that the SHOC benchmark work used AMD’s implementation of OpenCL, rather than NVIDIA’s. We regret the error.]

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

Pfizer HPC Engineer Aims to Automate Software Stack Testing

January 17, 2019

Seeking to reign in the tediousness of manual software testing, Pfizer HPC Engineer Shahzeb Siddiqui is developing an open source software tool called buildtest, aimed at automating software stack testing by providing the community with a central repository of tests for common HPC apps and the ability to automate execution of testing. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Senegal Prepares to Take Delivery of Atos Supercomputer

January 16, 2019

In just a few months time, Senegal will be operating the second largest HPC system in sub-Saharan Africa. The Minister of Higher Education, Research and Innovation Mary Teuw Niane made the announcement on Monday (Jan. 14 Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Google Cloud Platform Extends GPU Instance Options

January 16, 2019

If it's Nvidia GPUs you're after to power your AI/HPC/visualization workload, Google Cloud has them, now claiming "broadest GPU availability." Each of the three big public cloud vendors has by turn touted the latest and Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

HPE Extreme Performance Solutions

HPE Systems With Intel Omni-Path: Architected for Value and Accessible High-Performance Computing

Today’s high-performance computing (HPC) and artificial intelligence (AI) users value high performing clusters. And the higher the performance that their system can deliver, the better. Read more…

IBM Accelerated Insights

Resource Management in the Age of Artificial Intelligence

New challenges demand fresh approaches

Fueled by GPUs, big data, and rapid advances in software, the AI revolution is upon us. Read more…

STAC Floats ML Benchmark for Financial Services Workloads

January 16, 2019

STAC (Securities Technology Analysis Center) recently released an ‘exploratory’ benchmark for machine learning which it hopes will evolve into a firm benchmark or suite of benchmarking tools to compare the performanc Read more…

By John Russell

Google Cloud Platform Extends GPU Instance Options

January 16, 2019

If it's Nvidia GPUs you're after to power your AI/HPC/visualization workload, Google Cloud has them, now claiming "broadest GPU availability." Each of the three Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

STAC Floats ML Benchmark for Financial Services Workloads

January 16, 2019

STAC (Securities Technology Analysis Center) recently released an ‘exploratory’ benchmark for machine learning which it hopes will evolve into a firm benchm Read more…

By John Russell

A Big Data Journey While Seeking to Catalog our Universe

January 16, 2019

It turns out, astronomers have lots of photos of the sky but seek knowledge about what the photos mean. Sound familiar? Big data problems are often characterize Read more…

By James Reinders

Intel Bets Big on 2-Track Quantum Strategy

January 15, 2019

Quantum computing has lived so long in the future it’s taken on a futuristic life of its own, with a Gartner-style hype cycle that includes triggers of innovation, inflated expectations and – though a useful quantum system is still years away – anticipatory troughs of disillusionment. Read more…

By Doug Black

IBM Quantum Update: Q System One Launch, New Collaborators, and QC Center Plans

January 10, 2019

IBM made three significant quantum computing announcements at CES this week. One was introduction of IBM Q System One; it’s really the integration of IBM’s Read more…

By John Russell

IBM’s New Global Weather Forecasting System Runs on GPUs

January 9, 2019

Anyone who has checked a forecast to decide whether or not to pack an umbrella knows that weather prediction can be a mercurial endeavor. It is a Herculean task: the constant modeling of incredibly complex systems to a high degree of accuracy at a local level within very short spans of time. Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

The Case Against ‘The Case Against Quantum Computing’

January 9, 2019

It’s not easy to be a physicist. Richard Feynman (basically the Jimi Hendrix of physicists) once said: “The first principle is that you must not fool yourse Read more…

By Ben Criger

The Deep500 – Researchers Tackle an HPC Benchmark for Deep Learning

January 7, 2019

How do you know if an HPC system, particularly a larger-scale system, is well-suited for deep learning workloads? Today, that’s not an easy question to answer Read more…

By John Russell

Quantum Computing Will Never Work

November 27, 2018

Amid the gush of money and enthusiastic predictions being thrown at quantum computing comes a proposed cold shower in the form of an essay by physicist Mikhail Read more…

By John Russell

Cray Unveils Shasta, Lands NERSC-9 Contract

October 30, 2018

Cray revealed today the details of its next-gen supercomputing architecture, Shasta, selected to be the next flagship system at NERSC. We've known of the code-name "Shasta" since the Argonne slice of the CORAL project was announced in 2015 and although the details of that plan have changed considerably, Cray didn't slow down its timeline for Shasta. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

AMD Sets Up for Epyc Epoch

November 16, 2018

It’s been a good two weeks, AMD’s Gary Silcott and Andy Parma told me on the last day of SC18 in Dallas at the restaurant where we met to discuss their show news and recent successes. Heck, it’s been a good year. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

The Case Against ‘The Case Against Quantum Computing’

January 9, 2019

It’s not easy to be a physicist. Richard Feynman (basically the Jimi Hendrix of physicists) once said: “The first principle is that you must not fool yourse Read more…

By Ben Criger

US Leads Supercomputing with #1, #2 Systems & Petascale Arm

November 12, 2018

The 31st Supercomputing Conference (SC) - commemorating 30 years since the first Supercomputing in 1988 - kicked off in Dallas yesterday, taking over the Kay Ba Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Contract Signed for New Finnish Supercomputer

December 13, 2018

After the official contract signing yesterday, configuration details were made public for the new BullSequana system that the Finnish IT Center for Science (CSC Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Summit Supercomputer is Already Making its Mark on Science

September 20, 2018

Summit, now the fastest supercomputer in the world, is quickly making its mark in science – five of the six finalists just announced for the prestigious 2018 Read more…

By John Russell

Nvidia’s Jensen Huang Delivers Vision for the New HPC

November 14, 2018

For nearly two hours on Monday at SC18, Jensen Huang, CEO of Nvidia, presented his expansive view of the future of HPC (and computing in general) as only he can do. Animated. Backstopped by a stream of data charts, product photos, and even a beautiful image of supernovae... Read more…

By John Russell

Leading Solution Providers

SC 18 Virtual Booth Video Tour

Advania @ SC18 AMD @ SC18
ASRock Rack @ SC18
DDN Storage @ SC18
HPE @ SC18
IBM @ SC18
Lenovo @ SC18 Mellanox Technologies @ SC18
NVIDIA @ SC18
One Stop Systems @ SC18
Oracle @ SC18 Panasas @ SC18
Supermicro @ SC18 SUSE @ SC18 TYAN @ SC18
Verne Global @ SC18

HPE No. 1, IBM Surges, in ‘Bucking Bronco’ High Performance Server Market

September 27, 2018

Riding healthy U.S. and global economies, strong demand for AI-capable hardware and other tailwind trends, the high performance computing server market jumped 28 percent in the second quarter 2018 to $3.7 billion, up from $2.9 billion for the same period last year, according to industry analyst firm Hyperion Research. Read more…

By Doug Black

HPC Reflections and (Mostly Hopeful) Predictions

December 19, 2018

So much ‘spaghetti’ gets tossed on walls by the technology community (vendors and researchers) to see what sticks that it is often difficult to peer through Read more…

By John Russell

Intel Confirms 48-Core Cascade Lake-AP for 2019

November 4, 2018

As part of the run-up to SC18, taking place in Dallas next week (Nov. 11-16), Intel is doling out info on its next-gen Cascade Lake family of Xeon processors, specifically the “Advanced Processor” version (Cascade Lake-AP), architected for high-performance computing, artificial intelligence and infrastructure-as-a-service workloads. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Germany Celebrates Launch of Two Fastest Supercomputers

September 26, 2018

The new high-performance computer SuperMUC-NG at the Leibniz Supercomputing Center (LRZ) in Garching is the fastest computer in Germany and one of the fastest i Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

House Passes $1.275B National Quantum Initiative

September 17, 2018

Last Thursday the U.S. House of Representatives passed the National Quantum Initiative Act (NQIA) intended to accelerate quantum computing research and developm Read more…

By John Russell

Houston to Field Massive, ‘Geophysically Configured’ Cloud Supercomputer

October 11, 2018

Based on some news stories out today, one might get the impression that the next system to crack number one on the Top500 would be an industrial oil and gas mon Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Microsoft to Buy Mellanox?

December 20, 2018

Networking equipment powerhouse Mellanox could be an acquisition target by Microsoft, according to a published report in an Israeli financial publication. Microsoft has reportedly gone so far as to engage Goldman Sachs to handle negotiations with Mellanox. Read more…

By Doug Black

The Deep500 – Researchers Tackle an HPC Benchmark for Deep Learning

January 7, 2019

How do you know if an HPC system, particularly a larger-scale system, is well-suited for deep learning workloads? Today, that’s not an easy question to answer Read more…

By John Russell

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
Share This