OpenCL Gains Ground On CUDA

By Michael Feldman

February 28, 2012

As the two major programming frameworks for GPU computing, OpenCL and CUDA have been competing for mindshare in the developer community for the past few years. Until recently, CUDA has attracted most of the attention from developers, especially in the high performance computing realm. But OpenCL software has now matured to the point where HPC practitioners are taking a second look.

Both OpenCL and CUDA provide a general-purpose model for data parallelism as well as low-level access to hardware, but only OpenCL provides an open, industry-standard framework. As such, it has garnered support from nearly all processor manufacturers including AMD, Intel, and NVIDIA, as well as others that serve the mobile and embedded computing markets. As a result, applications developed in OpenCL are now portable across a variety of GPUs and CPUs.

Although OpenCL 1.0 was introduced in December 2008, just a year and a half after the NVIDIA launched its first version of CUDA, OpenCL still trails CUDA in popularity by a wide margin, especially with regard to HPC. That is mostly due to a concerted effort by NVIDIA to establish CUDA as the dominant programming framework for GPU application development in this realm..

AMD has been the most vocal booster of OpenCL technology for technical computing, but it’s lack of a competitive product set for high-end GPU computing has muted that message. Thus far, OpenCL usage has been mostly relegated to client-side computing, especially for mobile platforms, which have increasingly incorporated GPU silicon into their designs. Apple, who initially developed OpenCL before handing it off to the open-standard Khronos Group, was instrumental in getting the technology off the ground.

The knock on OpenCL for HPC users has been lack of maturity, which has resulted in low performance, compared to CUDA. There is also the perception that support from the principle HPC chipmakers (Intel, AMD and NVIDIA) would be less than enthusiastic, at least for their high-end processors. In many ways, that’s still true, given that NVIDIA is devoting most of its attention to its home-grown CUDA software, while Intel seems to have settled on its own parallel programming frameworks, mainly Cilk Plus and Threading Building Blocks.

AMD though, continues to champion OpenCL, and some of their more recent compiler and library releases have improved performance considerably. In fact, Kyle Spafford, from the Future Technology Group at Oak Ridge National Lab (ORNL), has been benchmarking the two technologies for some time and is now convinced that OpenCL performance is now on par with that of CUDA. He recently presented his findings at Georgia Tech’s Keeneland Workshop.

Spafford’s ran ORNL’s Scalable Heterogeneous Computing Benchmark Suite (SHOC) that has been optimized for both CUDA and OpenCL, and found that OpenCL can match CUDA performance on most of the basic math kernels. He also found that OpenCL’s performance on some kernels, like SGEMM, has increased 10-fold since 2009. The one code that CUDA still has a significant performance advantage is that of the Fast Fourier Transform (FFT). Spafford attributes CUDA’s better FFT performance on its use of a fast intrinsic, with OpenCL implementation (NVIDIA’s in this case*) employing a slower, more accurate version. If the implementations are matched, the performance difference goes away, says Spafford.

Others have found similar behavior on stand-alone science applications. A research group at Dartmouth running a numerical model of gravitation waves with OpenCL and CUDA found similar performance between OpenCL and CUDA, in this case on Tesla GPUs and IBM’s Cell BE processors. In the resulting paper, the researchers conclude that “an OpenCL-based implementation delivers comparable performance to that based on a native SDK on both types of accelerator hardware.”

GPU software maker AccelerEyes has seen CUDA and OpenCL performance equalize. The company, which recently released OpenCL-powered beta versions of their two flagship software products, ArrayFire and Jacket, has found that for most kernel codes, the two technologies now exhibit similar performance. Like ORNL, they found FFT speed is still better on CUDA due to NVIDIA’s faster implementation, but AMD’s OpenCL compiler and libraries have improved considerably, both in scope and performance.

According to AccelerEyes CEO John Melonakos, over half of their customers develop their GPU-accelerated code on their PCs before deploying to a workstation or cluster, so the ability to support non-NVIDIA hardware can be quite useful. For example, customers using MacBooks as development platforms couldn’t run CUDA there because Apple has no NVIDIA GPU option on its latest laptops. And since the AMD OpenCL libraries that AccelerEyes used in their beta offerings work just fine on Intel CPUs, AMD CPUs, and NVIDIA GPUs, there are no hardware incompatibility issues.

Then there are users who are just unwilling to adopt vendor-specific software stacks such as CUDA. “There are a class of people who absolutely want to do GPU computing but are resistant to anything that is vendor-locked,” Melonakos told HPCwire. He says this is group that has jumped onto their OpenCL-based offerings first.

To counter that kind of perception, NVIDIA has recently opened up the CUDA compiler source code for third-party developers. Significantly though, NVIDIA is not putting its all-important CUDA math libraries, like CUBLAS and CUFFT, into the open source pot. According to Melonakos, the large and mature library set is CUDA’s real strength in the technical computing arena. Open source or not, NVIDIA still retains control of the CUDA software technology, which is why it is still perceived as a vendor-specific solution.

Even NVIDIA and Intel are hedging their bets with OpenCL though, with both vendors offering software hooks for their respective hardware. At this point, these companies are providing this support as a nod to their mobile computing developers (although Intel is reportedly working on a MIC processor port too). But since there is an increasing amount of cross-pollination between mobile and HPC these days, it’s not clear how developers will end up using these technologies.

In fact, if the mobile space latches onto OpenCL in a big way and it becomes the standard low-level solution for heterogenous computing, that could help speed its adoption at the high-end. Once OpenCL reaches a critical mass of acceptance in a volume market such as that, there will be a rapid increase in demand for robust compilers and libraries. As Melonakos put it: “I dont think OpenCL is going away.”

[Editor’s note: The original article erroneously stated that the SHOC benchmark work used AMD’s implementation of OpenCL, rather than NVIDIA’s. We regret the error.]

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

What’s New in HPC Research: Natural Gas, Precision Agriculture, Neural Networks and More

December 6, 2019

In this bimonthly feature, HPCwire highlights newly published research in the high-performance computing community and related domains. From parallel programming to exascale to quantum computing, the details are here. Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

On the Spack Track @SC19

December 5, 2019

At the annual supercomputing conference, SC19 in Denver, Colorado, there were Spack events each day of the conference. As a reflection of its grassroots heritage, nine sessions were planned by more than a dozen thought leaders from seven organizations, including three U.S. national Department of Energy (DOE) laboratories and Sylabs... Read more…

By Elizabeth Leake

Intel’s New Hyderabad Design Center Targets Exascale Era Technologies

December 3, 2019

Intel's Raja Koduri was in India this week to help launch a new 300,000 square foot design and engineering center in Hyderabad, which will focus on advanced computing technologies for the AI and exascale era. "Over th Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

AWS Debuts 7nm 2nd-Gen Graviton Arm Processor

December 3, 2019

The “x86 Big Bang,” in which market dominance of the venerable Intel CPU has exploded into fragments of processor options suited to varying workloads, has now encompassed CPUs offered by the leading public cloud serv Read more…

By Doug Black

Medical Imaging Gets an AI Boost

December 3, 2019

AI technologies incorporated into diagnostic imaging tools have proven useful in eliminating confirmation bias, often outperforming human clinicians who may bring their own prejudices. Another issue slowing progress is t Read more…

By George Leopold

AWS Solution Channel

Making High Performance Computing Affordable and Accessible for Small and Medium Businesses with HPC on AWS

High performance computing (HPC) brings a powerful set of tools to a broad range of industries, helping to drive innovation and boost revenue in finance, genomics, oil and gas extraction, and other fields. Read more…

IBM Accelerated Insights

AI Needs Intelligent HPC infrastructure

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has revolutionized entire industries and enables humanity to solve some of the most daunting challenges. To accomplish this, it requires massive amounts of data from heterogeneous sources that is processed it new ways that differs significantly from HPC applications. Read more…

Ride on the Wild Side – Squyres SC19 Mars Rovers Keynote

December 2, 2019

Reminding us of the deep and enabling connection between HPC and modern science is an important part of the SC Conference mission. And yes, HPC is a science itself. At SC19, Steve Squyres’ opening keynote recounting th Read more…

By John Russell

On the Spack Track @SC19

December 5, 2019

At the annual supercomputing conference, SC19 in Denver, Colorado, there were Spack events each day of the conference. As a reflection of its grassroots heritage, nine sessions were planned by more than a dozen thought leaders from seven organizations, including three U.S. national Department of Energy (DOE) laboratories and Sylabs... Read more…

By Elizabeth Leake

Intel’s New Hyderabad Design Center Targets Exascale Era Technologies

December 3, 2019

Intel's Raja Koduri was in India this week to help launch a new 300,000 square foot design and engineering center in Hyderabad, which will focus on advanced com Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

AWS Debuts 7nm 2nd-Gen Graviton Arm Processor

December 3, 2019

The “x86 Big Bang,” in which market dominance of the venerable Intel CPU has exploded into fragments of processor options suited to varying workloads, has n Read more…

By Doug Black

Ride on the Wild Side – Squyres SC19 Mars Rovers Keynote

December 2, 2019

Reminding us of the deep and enabling connection between HPC and modern science is an important part of the SC Conference mission. And yes, HPC is a science its Read more…

By John Russell

NSCI Update – Adapting to a Changing Landscape

December 2, 2019

It was November of 2017 when we last visited the topic of the National Strategic Computing Initiative (NSCI). As you will recall, the NSCI was started with an Executive Order (E.O. No. 13702), that was issued by President Obama in July of 2015 and was followed by a Strategic Plan that was released in July of 2016. The question for November of 2017... Read more…

By Alex R. Larzelere

Tsinghua University Racks Up Its Ninth Student Cluster Championship Win at SC19

November 27, 2019

Tsinghua University has done it again. At SC19 last week, the eight-time gold medal-winner team took home the top prize in the 2019 Student Cluster Competition Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

SC19: IBM Changes Its HPC-AI Game Plan

November 25, 2019

It’s probably fair to say IBM is known for big bets. Summit supercomputer – a big win. Red Hat acquisition – looking like a big win. OpenPOWER and Power processors – jury’s out? At SC19, long-time IBMer Dave Turek sketched out a different kind of bet for Big Blue – a small ball strategy, if you’ll forgive the baseball analogy... Read more…

By John Russell

How the Gordon Bell Prize Winners Used Summit to Illuminate Transistors

November 22, 2019

At SC19, the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) awarded the prestigious Gordon Bell Prize to the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH) Zurich. The Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Using AI to Solve One of the Most Prevailing Problems in CFD

October 17, 2019

How can artificial intelligence (AI) and high-performance computing (HPC) solve mesh generation, one of the most commonly referenced problems in computational engineering? A new study has set out to answer this question and create an industry-first AI-mesh application... Read more…

By James Sharpe

Cray Wins NNSA-Livermore ‘El Capitan’ Exascale Contract

August 13, 2019

Cray has won the bid to build the first exascale supercomputer for the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) and Lawrence Livermore National Laborator Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

DARPA Looks to Propel Parallelism

September 4, 2019

As Moore’s law runs out of steam, new programming approaches are being pursued with the goal of greater hardware performance with less coding. The Defense Advanced Projects Research Agency is launching a new programming effort aimed at leveraging the benefits of massive distributed parallelism with less sweat. Read more…

By George Leopold

D-Wave’s Path to 5000 Qubits; Google’s Quantum Supremacy Claim

September 24, 2019

On the heels of IBM’s quantum news last week come two more quantum items. D-Wave Systems today announced the name of its forthcoming 5000-qubit system, Advantage (yes the name choice isn’t serendipity), at its user conference being held this week in Newport, RI. Read more…

By John Russell

Ayar Labs to Demo Photonics Chiplet in FPGA Package at Hot Chips

August 19, 2019

Silicon startup Ayar Labs continues to gain momentum with its DARPA-backed optical chiplet technology that puts advanced electronics and optics on the same chip Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

SC19: IBM Changes Its HPC-AI Game Plan

November 25, 2019

It’s probably fair to say IBM is known for big bets. Summit supercomputer – a big win. Red Hat acquisition – looking like a big win. OpenPOWER and Power processors – jury’s out? At SC19, long-time IBMer Dave Turek sketched out a different kind of bet for Big Blue – a small ball strategy, if you’ll forgive the baseball analogy... Read more…

By John Russell

Cray, Fujitsu Both Bringing Fujitsu A64FX-based Supercomputers to Market in 2020

November 12, 2019

The number of top-tier HPC systems makers has shrunk due to a steady march of M&A activity, but there is increased diversity and choice of processing compon Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Crystal Ball Gazing: IBM’s Vision for the Future of Computing

October 14, 2019

Dario Gil, IBM’s relatively new director of research, painted a intriguing portrait of the future of computing along with a rough idea of how IBM thinks we’ Read more…

By John Russell

Leading Solution Providers

ISC 2019 Virtual Booth Video Tour

CRAY
CRAY
DDN
DDN
DELL EMC
DELL EMC
GOOGLE
GOOGLE
ONE STOP SYSTEMS
ONE STOP SYSTEMS
PANASAS
PANASAS
VERNE GLOBAL
VERNE GLOBAL

Intel Debuts New GPU – Ponte Vecchio – and Outlines Aspirations for oneAPI

November 17, 2019

Intel today revealed a few more details about its forthcoming Xe line of GPUs – the top SKU is named Ponte Vecchio and will be used in Aurora, the first plann Read more…

By John Russell

Kubernetes, Containers and HPC

September 19, 2019

Software containers and Kubernetes are important tools for building, deploying, running and managing modern enterprise applications at scale and delivering enterprise software faster and more reliably to the end user — while using resources more efficiently and reducing costs. Read more…

By Daniel Gruber, Burak Yenier and Wolfgang Gentzsch, UberCloud

Dell Ramps Up HPC Testing of AMD Rome Processors

October 21, 2019

Dell Technologies is wading deeper into the AMD-based systems market with a growing evaluation program for the latest Epyc (Rome) microprocessors from AMD. In a Read more…

By John Russell

AMD Launches Epyc Rome, First 7nm CPU

August 8, 2019

From a gala event at the Palace of Fine Arts in San Francisco yesterday (Aug. 7), AMD launched its second-generation Epyc Rome x86 chips, based on its 7nm proce Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

SC19: Welcome to Denver

November 17, 2019

A significant swath of the HPC community has come to Denver for SC19, which began today (Sunday) with a rich technical program. As is customary, the ribbon cutt Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

When Dense Matrix Representations Beat Sparse

September 9, 2019

In our world filled with unintended consequences, it turns out that saving memory space to help deal with GPU limitations, knowing it introduces performance pen Read more…

By James Reinders

With the Help of HPC, Astronomers Prepare to Deflect a Real Asteroid

September 26, 2019

For years, NASA has been running simulations of asteroid impacts to understand the risks (and likelihoods) of asteroids colliding with Earth. Now, NASA and the European Space Agency (ESA) are preparing for the next, crucial step in planetary defense against asteroid impacts: physically deflecting a real asteroid. Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Cerebras to Supply DOE with Wafer-Scale AI Supercomputing Technology

September 17, 2019

Cerebras Systems, which debuted its wafer-scale AI silicon at Hot Chips last month, has entered into a multi-year partnership with Argonne National Laboratory and Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory as part of a larger collaboration with the U.S. Department of Energy... Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
Share This