TOP500: The Missing Puzzle Pieces

By Gary Johnson

February 27, 2013

[Editor’s Note: This article was modified to address a comment from Oak Ridge National Laboratory. It no longer says that the Titan supercomputer “failed” its acceptance test. The comment from ORNL is at the end of the article.]

 

According to recent news reports, Titan, the Cray XK7 located at the Department of Energy’s Oak Ridge National Laboratory and currently sitting at the top of the Top500 List, “isn’t working like it should”. This has puzzled many folks in the HPC community. How could Titan win the Top500 race last November, but be reported in February to have “bugs” that have “prevented users from getting access to the full Titan so far“? Some details are beginning to emerge, and the folks at Oak Ridge do expect Titan to pass its acceptance testing after Cray finishes repairing it. However, this situation does serve to raise some interesting questions about the Top500 List – and, in particular, about some pieces of the Top500 puzzle that are requested by the List keepers but are absent from the List. Let’s take a closer look.

Top500 Project

The Top500 Project is very clear about its objectives and the methodology it uses to accomplish them:

The main objective of the TOP500 list is to provide a ranked list of general purpose systems that are in common use for high end applications.

As a yardstick of performance we are using the `best’ performance as measured by the LINPACK Benchmark. LINPACK was chosen because it is widely used and performance numbers are available for almost all relevant systems.

The benchmark used in the LINPACK Benchmark is to solve a dense system of linear equations. For the TOP500, we used that version of the benchmark that allows the user to scale the size of the problem and to optimize the software in order to achieve the best performance for a given machine.

Since the problem is very regular, the performance achieved is quite high, and the performance numbers give a good correction of peak performance.

By measuring the actual performance for different problem sizes n, a user can get not only the maximal achieved performance Rmax for the problem size Nmax but also the problem size N1/2 where half of the performance Rmax is achieved. These numbers together with the theoretical peak performance Rpeak are the numbers given in the TOP500.

Next>>

They’ve been collecting data for more than 20 years and, through the Top500 Lists, they provide a valuable information resource to the HPC community.

Some relevant data for the top ten computers on the Fall 2012 Top500 List are presented in the Table 1 below.

Table 1 – Selected Data from the November 2012 Top500 List

Missing Puzzle Pieces

Acceptance Testing

The conditions for the Top500 competition are spelled out in its Call for Participation. Among them are these statements (the emphases are ours):

The authors of the Top500 reserve the right to independently verify submitted LINPACK results, and exclude systems from the list which are not valid or not general purpose in nature. By general purpose system we mean that the computer system must be able to be used to solve a range of scientific problems. Any system designed specifically to solve the LINPACK benchmark problem or have as its major purpose the goal of a high Top500 ranking will be disqualified.

The systems in the Top500 list are expected to be persistent and available for use for an extended period of time. Any system assembled to run a LINPACK benchmark only, and set up specifically to gain an entry in the Top500 will be excluded from the list. The TOP500 authors will reserve the right to deny inclusion in the list if it is suspected that the system violates these conditions.

If a general purpose computing system hasn’t successfully completed its acceptance testing, the rules of the Top500 competition could be interpreted as precluding it from the competition.  So, it’s probably worth waiting until after acceptance to compete.  Otherwise, the case that a computer system is “general purpose” and “persistent and available for use for an extended period of time” would appear to be weak.

Next>>

Unreported Data

Recall that, as cited above, the objectives of the Top500 Project include reporting not only Rmax but also Nmax, the problem size where Rmax is achieved, and Nhalf, where half of the performance Rmax is achieved. These numbers, together with the theoretical peak performance Rpeak, are to be reported in the TOP500 List.

From Table 1, we see that all top ten systems have reported their Rmax. Since without this datum there is no basis for being on the List, this is not a surprise. What is surprising however is that four of the top ten systems do not show an entry for Nmax and nine of the top ten have no entry for Nhalf. Note that among those reporting neither value is the number one system: Titan.

This begs a couple of obvious questions:

If the missing data were not reported, why were those systems included in the Top500 List?

If the missing data were reported, why are they not disclosed in the Top500 List?

If the answers have something to do with “confidentiality”, we note that all of the top ten systems appear to have been acquired with public money – and complete reporting and disclosure are clearly in the public interest.

Furthermore, incomplete reporting and/or disclosure serve to limit the utility of the Top500 List and erode public confidence in it. Given the sustained value that the List has provided over the past couple of decades, this would be a shame.

Time to Completion

Computers are for solving problems – not just running fast. Even in automobile racing it’s not just about maximum speed – it’s about crossing the finish line first. So, wouldn’t it be a good idea to add a couple of data points to the Top500 List:

Tmax – the time required to complete the Linpack Rmax run

Thalf – the time required to complete the Linpack Rhalf run

In fact, we suspect that some folks in the HPC community would be more interested in these numbers than in the maximum speed ones.

We strongly suspect that Tmax and Thalf data are available for the machines on the current Top500 List. Some number of people in our HPC community have these numbers (you know who you are  ). So, how about providing them – and also filling in the blanks in the Rmax and Rhalf columns?

To seed the process of supplementing the List, we’ve provided Table 2 below. In it we’ve included some anecdotal and unverified – but presumed roughly accurate – data for a few of the top ten systems. The times listed are given in hours. If you can improve on these rough estimates or fill in any of the other blanks, please send us the data.

Next>>

Table 2 – Supplementary Data for the November 2012 Top500 List

Going Forward

The next Top500 List is scheduled to be released in June at the International Supercomputing Conference in Leipzig, Germany. The submission deadline is May 18th. By ensuring that: all competing systems have passed their acceptance tests; all data traditionally disclosed are complete; and perhaps adding the Tmax and Thalf data, the next release of Top500 List could be made even more valuable to the HPC community.

 

Postscript

As noted in comments below, the times to completion, while not explicitly included in the published lists, may be calculated from Rmax and Nmax as follows:

Tmax = 2.0/3.0 * Nmax^3 / (Rmax * 10^9)

This yields Tmax in seconds. Table 3 below shows the results of this calculation, with Tmax converted to hours. Note that, since some of the Nmax data is approximate, so are the corresponding Tmax calculations. As mentioned above, you are invited to fill in the blanks and correct any errors you may find in this Table.

Table 3 – Supplementary Data Calculated for the November 2012 Top500 List

 

Comment from ORNL:

We are writing to address a factual error in Gary Johnson’s February 27th article in HPCwire “Top500: The Missing Puzzle Pieces.”  In his article, Mr. Johnson states that “Titan, the Cray XK7 sitting at the top of the current TOP500 List, recently failed its acceptance test…”  This statement  is incorrect.  Titan has not yet completed the full suite of acceptance tests but has successfully passed both the functionality and performance phases of acceptance testing.  Moreover, Titan is within 1% of passing its stability test, the last component of the acceptance test suite. The original project schedule called for fully completing acceptance testing by June of 2013, a schedule we expect to meet. And, as we proceed through this complex testing procedure, users are making productive use of the system.

Thank you for the opportunity to correct the record.

James J. Hack

National Center for Computational Sciences, Director

Arthur S. Bland

Oak Ridge Leadership Computing Facility, Project Director

 

Related Articles

World’s Fastest Supercomputer Hits Speed Bump

Waiting for Exascale

Titan Knocks Off Sequoia as Top Supercomputer

DOE Labs Set Records with IBM Blue Gene/Q

Podcast: Accelerator Triple Play; TOP500 Results

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

Q&A with Google’s Bill Magro, an HPCwire Person to Watch in 2021

June 11, 2021

Last Fall Bill Magro joined Google as CTO of HPC, a newly created position, after two decades at Intel, where he was responsible for the company's HPC strategy. This interview was conducted by email at the beginning of A Read more…

A Carbon Crisis Looms Over Supercomputing. How Do We Stop It?

June 11, 2021

Supercomputing is extraordinarily power-hungry, with many of the top systems measuring their peak demand in the megawatts due to powerful processors and their correspondingly powerful cooling systems. As a result, these Read more…

Honeywell Quantum and Cambridge Quantum Plan to Merge; More to Follow?

June 10, 2021

Earlier this week, Honeywell announced plans to merge its quantum computing business, Honeywell Quantum Solutions (HQS), which focuses on trapped ion hardware, with the U.K.-based Cambridge Quantum Computing (CQC), which Read more…

ISC21 Keynoter Xiaoxiang Zhu to Deliver a Bird’s-Eye View of a Changing World

June 10, 2021

ISC High Performance 2021 – once again virtual due to the ongoing pandemic – is swiftly approaching. In contrast to last year’s conference, which canceled its in-person component with a couple months’ notice, ISC Read more…

Xilinx Expands Versal Chip Family With 7 New Versal AI Edge Chips

June 10, 2021

FPGA chip vendor Xilinx has been busy over the last several years cranking out its Versal AI Core, Versal Premium and Versal Prime chip families to fill customer compute needs in the cloud, datacenters, networks and more. Now Xilinx is expanding its reach to the booming edge... Read more…

AWS Solution Channel

Building highly-available HPC infrastructure on AWS

Reminder: You can learn a lot from AWS HPC engineers by subscribing to the HPC Tech Short YouTube channel, and following the AWS HPC Blog channel. Read more…

Space Weather Prediction Gets a Supercomputing Boost

June 9, 2021

Solar winds are a hot topic in the HPC world right now, with supercomputer-powered research spanning from the Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory (which used Oak Ridge’s Titan system) to University College London (which used resources from the DiRAC HPC facility). One of the larger... Read more…

A Carbon Crisis Looms Over Supercomputing. How Do We Stop It?

June 11, 2021

Supercomputing is extraordinarily power-hungry, with many of the top systems measuring their peak demand in the megawatts due to powerful processors and their c Read more…

Honeywell Quantum and Cambridge Quantum Plan to Merge; More to Follow?

June 10, 2021

Earlier this week, Honeywell announced plans to merge its quantum computing business, Honeywell Quantum Solutions (HQS), which focuses on trapped ion hardware, Read more…

ISC21 Keynoter Xiaoxiang Zhu to Deliver a Bird’s-Eye View of a Changing World

June 10, 2021

ISC High Performance 2021 – once again virtual due to the ongoing pandemic – is swiftly approaching. In contrast to last year’s conference, which canceled Read more…

Xilinx Expands Versal Chip Family With 7 New Versal AI Edge Chips

June 10, 2021

FPGA chip vendor Xilinx has been busy over the last several years cranking out its Versal AI Core, Versal Premium and Versal Prime chip families to fill customer compute needs in the cloud, datacenters, networks and more. Now Xilinx is expanding its reach to the booming edge... Read more…

What is Thermodynamic Computing and Could It Become Important?

June 3, 2021

What, exactly, is thermodynamic computing? (Yes, we know everything obeys thermodynamic laws.) A trio of researchers from Microsoft, UC San Diego, and Georgia Tech have written an interesting viewpoint in the June issue... Read more…

AMD Introduces 3D Chiplets, Demos Vertical Cache on Zen 3 CPUs

June 2, 2021

At Computex 2021, held virtually this week, AMD showcased a new 3D chiplet architecture that will be used for future high-performance computing products set to Read more…

Nvidia Expands Its Certified Server Models, Unveils DGX SuperPod Subscriptions

June 2, 2021

Nvidia is busy this week at the virtual Computex 2021 Taipei technology show, announcing an expansion of its nascent Nvidia-certified server program, a range of Read more…

Using HPC Cloud, Researchers Investigate the COVID-19 Lab Leak Hypothesis

May 27, 2021

At the end of 2019, strange pneumonia cases started cropping up in Wuhan, China. As Wuhan (then China, then the world) scrambled to contain what would, of cours Read more…

AMD Chipmaker TSMC to Use AMD Chips for Chipmaking

May 8, 2021

TSMC has tapped AMD to support its major manufacturing and R&D workloads. AMD will provide its Epyc Rome 7702P CPUs – with 64 cores operating at a base cl Read more…

Intel Launches 10nm ‘Ice Lake’ Datacenter CPU with Up to 40 Cores

April 6, 2021

The wait is over. Today Intel officially launched its 10nm datacenter CPU, the third-generation Intel Xeon Scalable processor, codenamed Ice Lake. With up to 40 Read more…

Berkeley Lab Debuts Perlmutter, World’s Fastest AI Supercomputer

May 27, 2021

A ribbon-cutting ceremony held virtually at Berkeley Lab's National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center (NERSC) today marked the official launch of Perlmutter – aka NERSC-9 – the GPU-accelerated supercomputer built by HPE in partnership with Nvidia and AMD. Read more…

CERN Is Betting Big on Exascale

April 1, 2021

The European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) involves 23 countries, 15,000 researchers, billions of dollars a year, and the biggest machine in the worl Read more…

Google Launches TPU v4 AI Chips

May 20, 2021

Google CEO Sundar Pichai spoke for only one minute and 42 seconds about the company’s latest TPU v4 Tensor Processing Units during his keynote at the Google I Read more…

Iran Gains HPC Capabilities with Launch of ‘Simorgh’ Supercomputer

May 18, 2021

Iran is said to be developing domestic supercomputing technology to advance the processing of scientific, economic, political and military data, and to strengthen the nation’s position in the age of AI and big data. On Sunday, Iran unveiled the Simorgh supercomputer, which will deliver.... Read more…

HPE Launches Storage Line Loaded with IBM’s Spectrum Scale File System

April 6, 2021

HPE today launched a new family of storage solutions bundled with IBM’s Spectrum Scale Erasure Code Edition parallel file system (description below) and featu Read more…

Quantum Computer Start-up IonQ Plans IPO via SPAC

March 8, 2021

IonQ, a Maryland-based quantum computing start-up working with ion trap technology, plans to go public via a Special Purpose Acquisition Company (SPAC) merger a Read more…

Leading Solution Providers

Contributors

10nm, 7nm, 5nm…. Should the Chip Nanometer Metric Be Replaced?

June 1, 2020

The biggest cool factor in server chips is the nanometer. AMD beating Intel to a CPU built on a 7nm process node* – with 5nm and 3nm on the way – has been i Read more…

Julia Update: Adoption Keeps Climbing; Is It a Python Challenger?

January 13, 2021

The rapid adoption of Julia, the open source, high level programing language with roots at MIT, shows no sign of slowing according to data from Julialang.org. I Read more…

AMD Launches Epyc ‘Milan’ with 19 SKUs for HPC, Enterprise and Hyperscale

March 15, 2021

At a virtual launch event held today (Monday), AMD revealed its third-generation Epyc “Milan” CPU lineup: a set of 19 SKUs -- including the flagship 64-core, 280-watt 7763 part --  aimed at HPC, enterprise and cloud workloads. Notably, the third-gen Epyc Milan chips achieve 19 percent... Read more…

Can Deep Learning Replace Numerical Weather Prediction?

March 3, 2021

Numerical weather prediction (NWP) is a mainstay of supercomputing. Some of the first applications of the first supercomputers dealt with climate modeling, and Read more…

Livermore’s El Capitan Supercomputer to Debut HPE ‘Rabbit’ Near Node Local Storage

February 18, 2021

A near node local storage innovation called Rabbit factored heavily into Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory’s decision to select Cray’s proposal for its CORAL-2 machine, the lab’s first exascale-class supercomputer, El Capitan. Details of this new storage technology were revealed... Read more…

GTC21: Nvidia Launches cuQuantum; Dips a Toe in Quantum Computing

April 13, 2021

Yesterday Nvidia officially dipped a toe into quantum computing with the launch of cuQuantum SDK, a development platform for simulating quantum circuits on GPU-accelerated systems. As Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang emphasized in his keynote, Nvidia doesn’t plan to build... Read more…

Microsoft to Provide World’s Most Powerful Weather & Climate Supercomputer for UK’s Met Office

April 22, 2021

More than 14 months ago, the UK government announced plans to invest £1.2 billion ($1.56 billion) into weather and climate supercomputing, including procuremen Read more…

African Supercomputing Center Inaugurates ‘Toubkal,’ Most Powerful Supercomputer on the Continent

February 25, 2021

Historically, Africa hasn’t exactly been synonymous with supercomputing. There are only a handful of supercomputers on the continent, with few ranking on the Read more…

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
HPCwire