The Scalability Dilemma and the Case for Decoupling

By Justin Y. Shi, Temple University

March 30, 2016

The need for extreme scale computing is driven by the seemingly forever fledgling Internet. In abstract, the entire network is already an extreme scale computing engine. The technical difficulty, however, is to harness the dispersed computing powers for a single purpose. An analogy to this would be to build an engine capable of harnessing the combustive power of elements to move people or things. The presence of such an engine could drive transformative changes in technology, society and the economy.

The first requirement for such an extreme scale computing engine is the ability to gain incrementally better performance and reliability while concurrently expanding in size. We expect more from this engine than we do from a sports car. The “cost of doing business” should only include oil changes, tire and bearing replacements, but not re-building the car when a tire bursts or the engine upgrades. Unlike sports cars, technically, the extreme scale computing engine should run faster and more reliably when it expands for solving a bigger problem. While the top deliverable performance of the engine must be capped by the aggregate of available capabilities, there should be no loss in an application’s reliability when expanding in size.

Reliable distributed computing is hard. A 1993 paper entitled “The Impossibility of Implementing Reliable Communication in the Face of Crashes”[i] drew a “line in the sand.” It was proved that given a pair of sender and receiver, reliable communication between them is impossible if either one or the other could crash arbitrarily. It follows immediately that any distributed or parallel application that depends on fixed program-processor bindings must face the increased risk of crashes when the application expands, namely the “scalability dilemma.”

ImpossibilityProof 800xThe corollary of the impossibility proof is that reliable failure detection is also impossible. Thus, fault detection/repair/reschedule schemes are technically flawed for extreme scale computing. In this context, “reliability” means “100% application reliability while the system affords greater than the minimal survivable resource set.” For any computing or communication application, the “minimal survivable resource set” includes “at least one viable resource at every critical path at the time of need.”

Ironically, the possibility of such a highly reliable system using faulty networks was also proved by the same authors[ii]. Today’s Internet is a feasibility study of the correctness of this proof. These two complementary studies somehow seem contradictory to most people. This confusion may be rooted in a widespread faulty assumption in distributed computing communities: the “virtual circuit.” It is widely taught and believed that a virtual circuit is “a reliable, lossless data transmission channel between two communicating programs.” Historically, this term was first created by the network communities to signify a clean “hand-off point” for computing communities. The trouble was that the computing professionals took the liberty to expand the virtual circuit definition to include the reliability of the communicating programs.

This was an unfortunate mistake. It crossed the “line in the sand.” This problem was quickly identified as the first fallacy – “the network is reliable” — in the “Eight Fallacies of Distributed Computing”[iii]. However, in the last three decades, the industry and research communities have continued to ignore the warning signs despite increasing service downtimes and data losses in today’s large scale distributed systems (including all mission critical applications and HPC applications).

The Stateless Parallel Processing (“SPP”) concept [iv]was conceived in the mid-1980s based on a practical requirement of a mission critical project called “Zodiac.” The requirement was very basic: Keep a distributed application running regardless partial component failures. It was inconceivable for national security to rely on any mission critical application that could crash on a single component failure. Technically speaking, mission critical programs and data must be completely decoupled from processing, communication and storage devices. Otherwise, any device failure can halt the entire application and expanding the processing infrastructure will inevitably result in a higher probability of service interruptions, data losses, and runaway maintenance costs. HPC applications are the first non-lethal applications to demonstrate these potentially disastrous consequences. The growing instabilities in large scale simulations have also already played a role in the investigation of the scientific computing reproducibility problems[v].

Methods for building completely decoupled applications are fundamentally different from those for “bare metal” applications. The first difference is in the design of Application Programming Interface (“API”). Technically, Remote Procedure Call (“RPC”), Message Passing Interface (“MPI”), share memory (“OpenMP”), and Remote Method Invocation (“RMI”) are all “bare metal”-inspired APIs. Applications built using these APIs force the runtime systems to generate fixed program-processor dependencies. They have crossed the “line in the sand.” The computing application scalability dilemma is unavoidable.

The <key, value=””>-based APIs, such as Hadoop, Spark, and Scality, aimed to relax the program/data-device dependency by allowing the runtime system to conduct failure detection/repair “magic.” These efforts have already shown significant scalability gains against “bare metal” approaches. Unfortunately, due to the influence of the “virtual circuit” concept, their runtime implementations have also crossed the “line in the sand.” The natural next step is to completely decouple devices from programs and data.

As the “Internet of Things” takes afoot, the “smart big sensing” challenge is on the horizon. In this context, an extreme scale computing engine is merely a necessity for survival. The existing distributed and parallel computing technologies are woefully inadequate.

Fundamentally, all electronics will fail in unexpected ways. “Bare metal” computing was important decades ago but detrimental to large scale computing. It is simply flawed for extreme scale computing.

Albert Einstein defined “Insanity” as doing “the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result”. Without a paradigm shift, we can continue to call anything “extreme scale” while secretly keeping the true extreme scale engine in our dreams.

References

[i] Alan Fekete, Nancy A. Lynch, Yishay Mansour, John Spinelli, “The Impossibility of Implementing Reliable Communication in the Face of Crashes,” Journal of the ACM, 1993.

[ii] John Spinelli, “Reliable Data Communication in Faulty Computer Networks.” Ph.D. dissertation. Dept. Elect. Eng. Comput. Sci., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Mass., and MIT Laboratory for Information and Decision Systems report LIDS-TH-1882, June 1984.

[iii] Peter Deutsch, “Eight Fallacies of Distributed Computing,” http://www.ibiblio.org/xml/slides/acgnj/syndication/cache/Fallacies.html

[iv] Justin Shi, “Stateless Parallel Processing Prototype: Synergy”. https://github.com/jys673/Synergy30

[v] XSEDE 2014 Reproducibility Workshop Report, “Standing Together for Reproducibility in Large-Scale Computing”. https://www.xsede.org/documents/659353/d90df1cb-62b5-47c7-9936-2de11113a40f

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

What’s New in HPC Research: September (Part 1)

September 18, 2018

In this new bimonthly feature, HPCwire will highlight newly published research in the high-performance computing community and related domains. From exascale to quantum computing, the details are here. Check back every Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

House Passes $1.275B National Quantum Initiative

September 17, 2018

Last Thursday the U.S. House of Representatives passed the National Quantum Initiative Act (NQIA) intended to accelerate quantum computing research and development. Among other things it would establish a National Quantu Read more…

By John Russell

Nvidia Accelerates AI Inference in the Datacenter with T4 GPU

September 14, 2018

Nvidia is upping its game for AI inference in the datacenter with a new platform consisting of an inference accelerator chip--the new Turing-based Tesla T4 GPU--and a refresh of its inference server software packaged as Read more…

By George Leopold

HPE Extreme Performance Solutions

Introducing the First Integrated System Management Software for HPC Clusters from HPE

How do you manage your complex, growing cluster environments? Answer that big challenge with the new HPC cluster management solution: HPE Performance Cluster Manager. Read more…

IBM Accelerated Insights

A Crystal Ball for HPC

People are notoriously bad at predicting the future.  This very much includes experts. In the Forbes article “Why Most Predictions Are So Bad” Philip Tetlock discusses the largest and best-known test of the accuracy of expert predictions which show that any experts would do better if they make random guesses. Read more…

NSF Highlights Expanded Efforts for Broadening Participation in Computing

September 13, 2018

Today, the Directorate of Computer and Information Science and Engineering (CISE) of the NSF released a letter highlighting the expansion of its broadening participation in computing efforts. The letter was penned by Jam Read more…

By Staff

House Passes $1.275B National Quantum Initiative

September 17, 2018

Last Thursday the U.S. House of Representatives passed the National Quantum Initiative Act (NQIA) intended to accelerate quantum computing research and developm Read more…

By John Russell

Nvidia Accelerates AI Inference in the Datacenter with T4 GPU

September 14, 2018

Nvidia is upping its game for AI inference in the datacenter with a new platform consisting of an inference accelerator chip--the new Turing-based Tesla T4 GPU- Read more…

By George Leopold

DeepSense Combines HPC and AI to Bolster Canada’s Ocean Economy

September 13, 2018

We often hear scientists say that we know less than 10 percent of the life of the oceans. This week, IBM and a group of Canadian industry and government partner Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Rigetti (and Others) Pursuit of Quantum Advantage

September 11, 2018

Remember ‘quantum supremacy’, the much-touted but little-loved idea that the age of quantum computing would be signaled when quantum computers could tackle Read more…

By John Russell

How FPGAs Accelerate Financial Services Workloads

September 11, 2018

While FSI companies are unlikely, for competitive reasons, to disclose their FPGA strategies, James Reinders offers insights into the case for FPGAs as accelerators for FSI by discussing performance, power, size, latency, jitter and inline processing. Read more…

By James Reinders

Update from Gregory Kurtzer on Singularity’s Push into FS and the Enterprise

September 11, 2018

Container technology is hardly new but it has undergone rapid evolution in the HPC space in recent years to accommodate traditional science workloads and HPC systems requirements. While Docker containers continue to dominate in the enterprise, other variants are becoming important and one alternative with distinctly HPC roots – Singularity – is making an enterprise push targeting advanced scale workload inclusive of HPC. Read more…

By John Russell

At HPC on Wall Street: AI-as-a-Service Accelerates AI Journeys

September 10, 2018

AIaaS – artificial intelligence-as-a-service – is the technology discipline that eases enterprise entry into the mysteries of the AI journey while lowering Read more…

By Doug Black

No Go for GloFo at 7nm; and the Fujitsu A64FX post-K CPU

September 5, 2018

It’s been a news worthy couple of weeks in the semiconductor and HPC industry. There were several HPC relevant disclosures at Hot Chips 2018 to whet appetites Read more…

By Dairsie Latimer

TACC Wins Next NSF-funded Major Supercomputer

July 30, 2018

The Texas Advanced Computing Center (TACC) has won the next NSF-funded big supercomputer beating out rivals including the National Center for Supercomputing Ap Read more…

By John Russell

IBM at Hot Chips: What’s Next for Power

August 23, 2018

With processor, memory and networking technologies all racing to fill in for an ailing Moore’s law, the era of the heterogeneous datacenter is well underway, Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Requiem for a Phi: Knights Landing Discontinued

July 25, 2018

On Monday, Intel made public its end of life strategy for the Knights Landing "KNL" Phi product set. The announcement makes official what has already been wide Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

CERN Project Sees Orders-of-Magnitude Speedup with AI Approach

August 14, 2018

An award-winning effort at CERN has demonstrated potential to significantly change how the physics based modeling and simulation communities view machine learni Read more…

By Rob Farber

ORNL Summit Supercomputer Is Officially Here

June 8, 2018

Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) together with IBM and Nvidia celebrated the official unveiling of the Department of Energy (DOE) Summit supercomputer toda Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

New Deep Learning Algorithm Solves Rubik’s Cube

July 25, 2018

Solving (and attempting to solve) Rubik’s Cube has delighted millions of puzzle lovers since 1974 when the cube was invented by Hungarian sculptor and archite Read more…

By John Russell

AMD’s EPYC Road to Redemption in Six Slides

June 21, 2018

A year ago AMD returned to the server market with its EPYC processor line. The earth didn’t tremble but folks took notice. People remember the Opteron fondly Read more…

By John Russell

MLPerf – Will New Machine Learning Benchmark Help Propel AI Forward?

May 2, 2018

Let the AI benchmarking wars begin. Today, a diverse group from academia and industry – Google, Baidu, Intel, AMD, Harvard, and Stanford among them – releas Read more…

By John Russell

Leading Solution Providers

SC17 Booth Video Tours Playlist

Altair @ SC17

Altair

AMD @ SC17

AMD

ASRock Rack @ SC17

ASRock Rack

CEJN @ SC17

CEJN

DDN Storage @ SC17

DDN Storage

Huawei @ SC17

Huawei

IBM @ SC17

IBM

IBM Power Systems @ SC17

IBM Power Systems

Intel @ SC17

Intel

Lenovo @ SC17

Lenovo

Mellanox Technologies @ SC17

Mellanox Technologies

Microsoft @ SC17

Microsoft

Penguin Computing @ SC17

Penguin Computing

Pure Storage @ SC17

Pure Storage

Supericro @ SC17

Supericro

Tyan @ SC17

Tyan

Univa @ SC17

Univa

Pattern Computer – Startup Claims Breakthrough in ‘Pattern Discovery’ Technology

May 23, 2018

If it weren’t for the heavy-hitter technology team behind start-up Pattern Computer, which emerged from stealth today in a live-streamed event from San Franci Read more…

By John Russell

Sandia to Take Delivery of World’s Largest Arm System

June 18, 2018

While the enterprise remains circumspect on prospects for Arm servers in the datacenter, the leadership HPC community is taking a bolder, brighter view of the x86 server CPU alternative. Amongst current and planned Arm HPC installations – i.e., the innovative Mont-Blanc project, led by Bull/Atos, the 'Isambard’ Cray XC50 going into the University of Bristol, and commitments from both Japan and France among others -- HPE is announcing that it will be supply the United States National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) with a 2.3 petaflops peak Arm-based system, named Astra. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

D-Wave Breaks New Ground in Quantum Simulation

July 16, 2018

Last Friday D-Wave scientists and colleagues published work in Science which they say represents the first fulfillment of Richard Feynman’s 1982 notion that Read more…

By John Russell

Intel Pledges First Commercial Nervana Product ‘Spring Crest’ in 2019

May 24, 2018

At its AI developer conference in San Francisco yesterday, Intel embraced a holistic approach to AI and showed off a broad AI portfolio that includes Xeon processors, Movidius technologies, FPGAs and Intel’s Nervana Neural Network Processors (NNPs), based on the technology it acquired in 2016. Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Intel Announces Cooper Lake, Advances AI Strategy

August 9, 2018

Intel's chief datacenter exec Navin Shenoy kicked off the company's Data-Centric Innovation Summit Wednesday, the day-long program devoted to Intel's datacenter Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

TACC’s ‘Frontera’ Supercomputer Expands Horizon for Extreme-Scale Science

August 29, 2018

The National Science Foundation and the Texas Advanced Computing Center announced today that a new system, called Frontera, will overtake Stampede 2 as the fast Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

GPUs Power Five of World’s Top Seven Supercomputers

June 25, 2018

The top 10 echelon of the newly minted Top500 list boasts three powerful new systems with one common engine: the Nvidia Volta V100 general-purpose graphics proc Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

The Machine Learning Hype Cycle and HPC

June 14, 2018

Like many other HPC professionals I’m following the hype cycle around machine learning/deep learning with interest. I subscribe to the view that we’re probably approaching the ‘peak of inflated expectation’ but not quite yet starting the descent into the ‘trough of disillusionment. This still raises the probability that... Read more…

By Dairsie Latimer

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
Share This