NVIDIA Debuts PCIe-based P100; Broadens Aim at CPU Dominance

By John Russell

June 19, 2016

NVIDIA seems to be mounting a vigorous effort to dethrone the CPU as the leader of the processor pack for HPC and demanding datacenter workloads. That’s a tall order. Introduction at ISC 2016 of a PCIe-based version of is new Tesla P100 card is one element in the strategy. It should ease the upgrade path for many. But really, NVIDIA’s mantra has been shifting since introduction of the Pascal chip and DGX-1 platform last April. NVIDIA argues that better performance scaling on GPUs (Intel would dispute this), the mainstreaming of AI/deep learning approaches in scientific computing, and the large base of CUDA developers and code are combining to lift GPUs from a supportive to preeminent role.

“If you look at real applications, they tend not to scale well as you add CPU only nodes,” argues Marc Hamilton, vice president, solutions architecture and engineering at NVIDIA, citing benchmark data for Amber (molecular dynamics) running on Comet at the San Diego Supercomputing Center. “After 30 or 40 CPUs, no matter how many CPUs you add the curve doesn’t scale. Both of these charts argue for having a having a faster GPU and a more powerful compute node.” (See slide below.)

GPUs (and acceleration generally) have been transforming HPC for some time. Now the paradigm is shifting in the datacenter as well, says Hamilton who notes pointedly, “The new P100 PCIe card is targeting general purpose high performance computing. Our second ISC theme is AI is next big thing for HPC. There’s no disputing that from the consumer web side for apps [and] they use GPUs for network training. [Moreover] every major supercomputing center of the past six months is really using AI to address scientific computing that just couldn’t be addressed before.”

NVIDIA.ISC16.CPU Inefficiencies

Specs for the new Tesla P100 GPU accelerator for PCIe include:

  • 4.7 teraflops double-precision performance, 9.3 teraflops single-precision performance and 18.7 teraflops half-precision performance with NVIDIA GPU Boost technology.
  • Support for PCIe Gen 3 interconnect (32GB/sec bi-directional bandwidth).
  • Enhanced programmability with Page Migration Engine and unified memory.
  • ECC protection for increased reliability.
  • Server-optimized for highest data center throughput and reliability.
  • Available in two configurations: 16GB of CoWoS HBM2 stacked memory, delivering 720GB/sec of memory bandwidth; 12GB of CoWoS HBM2 stacked memory, delivering 540GB/sec of memory bandwidth.

“P100 for PCIe-based servers is basically the same as the NVLink-based P100 card but packaged in a standard PCIe form with a standard PCIe power footprint (300w for NVLink version versus 250w for PCIe),” reports Hamilton. “It is the same chip, the same module. We still use the HBM2 memory, same size memory, 16G, full 720GBS bandwidth to the GPU, and it has support for the page migration engine.”

Hamilton says a single Tesla P100-powered server delivers higher performance than 50 CPU-only server nodes when running the AMBER molecular dynamics code, and is faster than 32 CPU-only nodes when running the VASP material science application. Later this year, Tesla P100 accelerators for PCIe will power an upgraded version of Europe’s fastest supercomputer, the Piz Daint system at the Swiss National Supercomputing Center in Lugano, Switzerland (see Europe’s Fastest Computer to Get Pascal GPU Upgrade).

NVIDIA.ISC16.DL

Just as interesting as the P100 cards is the DGX-1 system marketed as the world’s first GPU-based deep learning supercomputer. Hamilton says NVIDIA has customers buying multiple units and that bundled DGX-1 clusters would quickly crack the TOP500 list.

When first launched, “We weren’t shipping [but] did the math for the ISC list expectations and estimated with 10-to-12 DGX-1s in a single rack you could probably get on the TOP500 list. We always simulate out what our expectations are for the new lists and for November we think on the order of 15-16 DGX-1 boxes should get you on the TOP500 list and we certainly have customers that are looking at deployment of that size and larger,” Hamilton said.

Perhaps we’ll see the emergence of a new TOP500 ‘entrant profile’ that is GPU-only or GPU-mostly. Roughly 100 of the TOP500 are accelerator-assisted machines, most by NVIDIA GPUs.

Hamilton emphasizes NVIDIA sees a broad opportunity for more pervasive penetration by GPU-only/mostly systems throughout the enterprise, especially as deep learning computing techniques are applied to a wider swath of scientific and enterprise workloads. Big Internet service providers, of course, make heavy use of GPU uses for deep learning et al. “Deep learning is a new style of computing and requires boxes like the DGX-1. We’ve seen continued interest from not only the likes of HPE, Dell, IBM, and Cray on NVLink-based designs but also from smaller OEMs as well,” says Hamilton. The latter, presumably, would more be inclined to use new P100 PCIe card.

Critics say GPU systems are more expensive. Hamilton agrees, if the metric is simply server hardware cost. “I think there’s some misconceptions about GPU systems. Of course a CPU server is more expensive because you start with a regular server and add a GPU. However the GPU-enabled datacenter running the same workload is going to be lower cost because not only do you have fewer nodes, but also you reduce all the other infrastructure at a typical supercomputer center. Turns out only 39 percent of the compute budget is used for servers; the rest of it is racking, cabling, networking, power and cooling, etc. One of the goals we’re trying to do is address that 61 percent of the budget,” he says.

The market will eventually decide, as always, but NVIDIA seems to be carefully lining up multiple arguments for its case – not least the need. NVIDIA notes that NSF was oversubscribed by 200 billion core hours, meaning rejected cycles, because its capacity was full and that capacity is heavily CPU-based.

“Accelerated computing is the only path forward to keep up with researchers’ insatiable demand for HPC and AI supercomputing,” said Ian Buck, vice president of accelerated computing at NVIDIA in the company’s official release announcement. “Deploying CPU-only systems to meet this demand would require large numbers of commodity compute nodes, leading to substantially increased costs without proportional performance gains. Dramatically scaling performance with fewer, more powerful Tesla P100-powered nodes puts more dollars into computing instead of vast infrastructure overhead.”

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industry updates delivered to you every week!

Bill Gropp on ‘Different Approaches to AI’

November 6, 2024

Around this same time last year, I expounded on what the “Future of AI” may entail. A lot has happened in the 12 months since then, including new approaches, new trends and, yes, new complications. A lot of the ne Read more…

Google Cloud Sporting a New Look in HPC and AI Hardware

November 5, 2024

It's raining hardware at Google Cloud, with the company making major upgrades in advance of bringing Nvidia's Blackwell GPUs into its fold next year. The upgrades announced in late October include a preview of its new Read more…

Go (Mountain) West, Quantum Workers! CU, CUbit, and Elevate Quantum Issue Workforce Roadmap

November 5, 2024

Last week the University of Colorado (Boulder), the CUbit Quantum Initiative, and the Elevate Quantum consortium released workforce roadmap for educating and building a quantum workforce. “This roadmap provides a foun Read more…

Collaboration Speeds Complex Chemical Modeling

November 4, 2024

A recent collaboration among researchers from HUN-REN Wigner Research Centre for Physics in Hungary and the Department of Energy's Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), along with industry collaborators SandboxAQ Read more…

High-Performance Storage for AI and Analytics Panel

October 31, 2024

When storage is mentioned in an AI or Big Data analytics context, it is assumed to be a high-performance system. In practice, it may not be, and the user eventually learns about scaleable storage as the amounts of data g Read more…

Microsoft Azure & AMD Solution Channel

Join Microsoft Azure and AMD at SC24

Atlanta, Georgia is the place to be this fall as the high-performance computing (HPC) community convenes for Supercomputing 2024. SC24 will bring together an unparalleled mix of scientists, engineers, researchers, educators, programmers, and developers for a week of learning and sharing. Read more…

White House Mulls Expanding AI Chip Export Bans Beyond China

October 31, 2024

The Biden administration is reportedly considering capping sales of advanced artificial intelligence (AI) chips from US-based manufacturers like AMD and Nvidia to certain countries, including those in the Middle East. � Read more…

Bill Gropp on ‘Different Approaches to AI’

November 6, 2024

Around this same time last year, I expounded on what the “Future of AI” may entail. A lot has happened in the 12 months since then, including new approaches Read more…

Shutterstock 1179408610

Google Cloud Sporting a New Look in HPC and AI Hardware

November 5, 2024

It's raining hardware at Google Cloud, with the company making major upgrades in advance of bringing Nvidia's Blackwell GPUs into its fold next year. The upg Read more…

Go (Mountain) West, Quantum Workers! CU, CUbit, and Elevate Quantum Issue Workforce Roadmap

November 5, 2024

Last week the University of Colorado (Boulder), the CUbit Quantum Initiative, and the Elevate Quantum consortium released workforce roadmap for educating and bu Read more…

Collaboration Speeds Complex Chemical Modeling

November 4, 2024

A recent collaboration among researchers from HUN-REN Wigner Research Centre for Physics in Hungary and the Department of Energy's Pacific Northwest National La Read more…

High-Performance Storage for AI and Analytics Panel

October 31, 2024

When storage is mentioned in an AI or Big Data analytics context, it is assumed to be a high-performance system. In practice, it may not be, and the user eventu Read more…

Shutterstock_556401859

Role Reversal: Google Teases Nvidia’s Blackwell as It Softens TPU Rivalry

October 30, 2024

Customers now have access to Google's homegrown hardware -- its Axion CPU and latest Trillium TPU -- in its Cloud service.  At the same time, Google gave custo Read more…

AI Has a Data Problem, Appen Report Says

October 30, 2024

AI may be a priority at American companies, but the difficulty in managing data and obtaining high quality data to train AI models is becoming a bigger hurdle t Read more…

Report from HALO Details Issues Facing HPC-AI Industry

October 28, 2024

Intersect360 Research has released a comprehensive new report concerning the challenges facing the combined fields of high-performance computing (HPC) and artif Read more…

Shutterstock_2176157037

Intel’s Falcon Shores Future Looks Bleak as It Concedes AI Training to GPU Rivals

September 17, 2024

Intel's Falcon Shores future looks bleak as it concedes AI training to GPU rivals On Monday, Intel sent a letter to employees detailing its comeback plan after Read more…

Granite Rapids HPC Benchmarks: I’m Thinking Intel Is Back (Updated)

September 25, 2024

Waiting is the hardest part. In the fall of 2023, HPCwire wrote about the new diverging Xeon processor strategy from Intel. Instead of a on-size-fits all approa Read more…

Ansys Fluent® Adds AMD Instinct™ MI200 and MI300 Acceleration to Power CFD Simulations

September 23, 2024

Ansys Fluent® is well-known in the commercial computational fluid dynamics (CFD) space and is praised for its versatility as a general-purpose solver. Its impr Read more…

xAI Colossus: The Elon Project

September 5, 2024

Elon Musk's xAI cluster, named Colossus (possibly after the 1970 movie about a massive computer that does not end well), has been brought online. Musk recently Read more…

Shutterstock 1024337068

Researchers Benchmark Nvidia’s GH200 Supercomputing Chips

September 4, 2024

Nvidia is putting its GH200 chips in European supercomputers, and researchers are getting their hands on those systems and releasing research papers with perfor Read more…

AMD Clears Up Messy GPU Roadmap, Upgrades Chips Annually

June 3, 2024

In the world of AI, there's a desperate search for an alternative to Nvidia's GPUs, and AMD is stepping up to the plate. AMD detailed its updated GPU roadmap, w Read more…

Comparing NVIDIA A100 and NVIDIA L40S: Which GPU is Ideal for AI and Graphics-Intensive Workloads?

October 30, 2023

With long lead times for the NVIDIA H100 and A100 GPUs, many organizations are looking at the new NVIDIA L40S GPU, which it’s a new GPU optimized for AI and g Read more…

Nvidia Shipped 3.76 Million Data-center GPUs in 2023, According to Study

June 10, 2024

Nvidia had an explosive 2023 in data-center GPU shipments, which totaled roughly 3.76 million units, according to a study conducted by semiconductor analyst fir Read more…

Leading Solution Providers

Contributors

IBM Develops New Quantum Benchmarking Tool — Benchpress

September 26, 2024

Benchmarking is an important topic in quantum computing. There’s consensus it’s needed but opinions vary widely on how to go about it. Last week, IBM introd Read more…

Intel Customizing Granite Rapids Server Chips for Nvidia GPUs

September 25, 2024

Intel is now customizing its latest Xeon 6 server chips for use with Nvidia's GPUs that dominate the AI landscape. The chipmaker's new Xeon 6 chips, also called Read more…

Zapata Computing, Early Quantum-AI Software Specialist, Ceases Operations

October 14, 2024

Zapata Computing, which was founded in 2017 as a Harvard spinout specializing in quantum software and later pivoted to an AI focus, is ceasing operations, accor Read more…

Quantum and AI: Navigating the Resource Challenge

September 18, 2024

Rapid advancements in quantum computing are bringing a new era of technological possibilities. However, as quantum technology progresses, there are growing conc Read more…

US Implements Controls on Quantum Computing and other Technologies

September 27, 2024

Yesterday the Commerce Department announced export controls on quantum computing technologies as well as new controls for advanced semiconductors and additive Read more…

Google’s DataGemma Tackles AI Hallucination

September 18, 2024

The rapid evolution of large language models (LLMs) has fueled significant advancement in AI, enabling these systems to analyze text, generate summaries, sugges Read more…

Microsoft, Quantinuum Use Hybrid Workflow to Simulate Catalyst

September 13, 2024

Microsoft and Quantinuum reported the ability to create 12 logical qubits on Quantinuum's H2 trapped ion system this week and also reported using two logical qu Read more…

On Paper, AMD’s New MI355X Makes MI325X Look Pedestrian

October 15, 2024

Advanced Micro Devices has detailed two new GPUs that unambiguously reinforce it as the only legitimate GPU alternative to Nvidia. AMD shared new facts on its n Read more…

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
HPCwire