Robust Quantum Computers Still a Decade Away, Says Nat’l Academies Report

By John Russell

December 5, 2018

The National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine yesterday released a report – Quantum Computing: Progress and Prospects – whose optimism about quantum computing’s potential is matched by its cautionary tone on QC’s near-term prospects. After a webinar to introduce the report, one questioner asked the presenting panel if the report’s finding that practical, error-corrected quantum computers won’t be built for a decade or longer wasn’t too disappointing.

“I think we need to be careful to remember that there’s a range of quantum computers that the report was discussing. [It] is the case the fully error-corrected quantum computers that can crack modern cyphers are quite far off, over a decade off,” answered Mark Horowitz, chair of the NASEM committee that prepared the report and a Stanford University professor, “but there are a number of groups working to build these noisy intermediate scale quantum computers (NISQ). The committee thinks that those are likely to be deployed relatively quickly, in the early 2020s, and the capabilities of those machines is still a little bit uncertain so, yes there are many challenges to build the ultimate quantum computer but I think there are opportunities for quantum computers much sooner than when those larger machines are built.”

In many ways one could argue this latest report is a needed dose of realism in today’s hyperventilating quantum computing environment. Make no mistake, the report argues that quantum computing has formidable potential and the swelling investments in QC and its surging research activities are fully justified. Indeed more is required given the brewing global race, contends the report. Nevertheless, the caveat is a substantial one; many problems remain to be solved perhaps error correction preeminent among them.

Even the worry over quantum computing’s potential to crack current cryptographic algorithms – part of the reason the report was commissioned by director of National Intelligence – is premature says the report.

Quick excerpt: “The committee (Committee on Technical Assessment of the Feasibility and Implications of Quantum Computing) focused on understanding the current state of quantum computing hardware, software, and algorithms, and what advances would be needed to create a scalable, gate-based quantum computer capable of deploying Shor’s algorithm. Early in this process, it became clear that the current engineering approaches could not directly scale to the size needed to create this scalable, fully error corrected quantum computer.”

John Martinis, another member of the committee and prominent quantum computing researcher at Google said during the webinar Q&A, “Progress in the field has been quite good in the last few years, and people have been able not just to do basics physics experiments but [also] to start building quantum computing systems. I think there’s a lot more optimism that people can build things and get it to work properly. Of course there’s lot of work to be done to get them to work well and match them to problems but the pace [of progress] has picked up and there’s interesting things that have come out. I think that in the next year or two, [we] won’t get to solving actual problems yet but there will be a lot better machines out there.”

You get the picture. Quantum computing is important, perhaps vastly so for some classes of problems including security, but it’s not here yet and will only arrive with continued investment and patience according to this study. The study seems designed to temper near-term expectations while steeling interested parties for a longer-term effort.

The report is a broad and accessible compilation of the key aspects of quantum computing technology as they exist today. For those less familiar with QC, the summary section is a good overview. For long-time quantum watchers, while most of the material won’t be new, the core of the report is substantive if not tutorial. It’s divided into seven chapters:

  • Progress in Computing (chapter 1) provides background and context on the field of computing, introducing the computational advantage of a quantum computer. It takes a careful look at why and how classical computing technologies scaled in performance for over half a century.
  • Quantum Computing: A New Paradigm (chapter 2) introduces the principles of quantum mechanics that make quantum computing different, exciting, and challenging to implement, and compares them with operations of the computers deployed today, which process information according to classical laws of physics—known in the quantum computing community as “classical computers.” It introduces the three different types of quantum computing studied in this report: analog quantum, digital noisy intermediate-scale quantum (digital NISQ), and fully error corrected quantum computers.
  • Quantum Algorithms and Applications (chapter 3) looks at quantum algorithms in more depth. The chapter starts with known foundational algorithms for fully error corrected machines but then shows that the overhead for error correction is quite large—that is, it takes many physical qubits and physical gate operations to emulate an error-free, so-called logical qubit that can be used in complex algorithms. “Such machines are therefore unlikely to exist for a number of years.”
  • Quantum Computing’s Implications for Cryptography (chapter 4) discusses the classical cryptographic ciphers currently used to protect electronic data and communications, how a large quantum computer could defeat these systems, and what the cryptography community should do now (and has begun to do) to address these vulnerabilities.
  • Chapters 5 (hardware) and 6 (software) discuss general architectures and progress to date in building the necessary hardware and software components, respectively, required for quantum computing.
  • Feasibility and Time Frames of Quantum Computing (chapter 7) provides the committee’s assessment of the technical progress and other factors required to make significant progress in quantum computing, tools for assessing and reassessing the possible time frames and implications of such developments, and an outlook for the future of the field.

The report hits all the right topics in an overview fashion. Quantum subsystems (which are quite challenging), software, quantum sensing and metrology, the necessity of blending classical computing with quantum processors to build functional quantum computers, etc. As an example, quantum storage has turned out to be tricky.

“Quantum storage is challenging because of a fundamental characteristic of quantum systems. It’s the no cloning theory, which says that you can’t have quantum information and then copy it some place and leave the original version the same. As a result if you talk about quantum storage you typically are talking about a thing that is referred to as QRAM which actually has some classical storage [that quickly encodes] that classical storage into quantum state. We talk a little bit about that in the report. That’s a technology which is much less developed than current qubit technology,” noted Bob Blakley, a committee member and the Global Head of Information Security Innovation at Citigroup.

Martinis said, “The idea of breaking the quantum computer into the different subsystems is of course important and you want to think about that. But because of this no cloning, no copying [rule], it means that the interfaces between all the different components are fundamentally different because you can’t just send the information in a box like you can for a classical computer. That means you have to have a much higher degree of system integration as you build complex quantum computers system. So it’s possible to do all of this. It just makes it more difficult.”

In tackling the problem, the report broadly classifies quantum computers into three general categories: “(1) Analog quantum computers” directly manipulate the interactions between qubits without breaking these actions into primitive gate operations. Examples of analog machines include quantum annealers, adiabatic quantum computers, and direct quantum simulators. (2) Digital NISQ computers operate by carrying out an algorithm of interest using primitive gate operations on physical qubits. Noise is present in both of these types of machine, which means that the quality (measured by error rates and qubit coherence times) will limit the complexity of the problems that these machines can solve. (3) Fully error-corrected quantum computers” are a version of gate-based QCs made more robust through deployment of quantum error correction (QEC), which enables noisy physical qubits to emulate stable logical qubits so that the computer behaves reliably for any computation.”

Most of the discussion is of systems built from superconducting qubits or trapped ions which seem to be the most advanced qubit technologies at present. Error correcting, not surprisingly, received a fair amount of discussion. “QEC incurs significant overheads in terms of both the number of physical qubits required to emulate a more robust and stable qubit, called a ‘logical qubit,’ and the number of primitive qubit operations that must be performed on physical qubits to emulate a quantum operation on this logical qubit,” notes the report. (See table below)

The notions of quantum supremacy and quantum advantage are also addressed: “Demonstration of ‘quantum supremacy’—that is, completing a task that is intractable on a classical computer, whether or not the task has practical utility—is one. While several teams have been focused on this goal, it has not yet been demonstrated (as of mid-2018). Another major milestone is creating a commercially useful quantum computer, which would require a QC that carries out at least one practical task more efficiently than any classical computer. While this milestone is in theory harder than achieving quantum supremacy—since the application in question must be better and more useful than available classical approaches—proving quantum supremacy could be difficult, especially for analog QC. Thus, it is possible that a useful application could arise before quantum supremacy is demonstrated.”

The new report echoes the notion that quantum computers will be special purpose devices.

“Quantum computing is not likely to take over for classical computing,” said Horowitz during Q&A. “It is rather more likely to be used as an accelerator attached to conventional computing to help in certain kinds of computations. In many kinds of computations quantum computers would not actually be better than a classical computer; the classical computer would be better and certainly cheaper.”

Martinis agreed and suggested an internet or cloud-based access model is what is likely to emerge in terms of gaining access and indeed IBM, Rigetti Computing, and D-Wave all offer quantum clouds now.

Asked if there might ever be a quantum laptop, he said “I think you want to imagine a quantum computer being like a supercomputer which are traditionally very big machines and that’s what people are building right now. The various implementations are 3m x 3m x 3m kinds of machines looking at all the hardware. And of course in the beginning [they are] perhaps a little bit large because you kind of brute force it and don’t have all the technologies scaled down to do everything. But as you want to scale up the number of qubits, it’s probably going to stay large.

“So I think it’s going to be a large, a special purpose machine for next few years and who knows what’s going to happen in the future. I think one of the interesting things that’s happened is these machines are now available on cloud access so you’re remotely accessing that. So although it is nice to think about having a quantum computer in your own lab or space, it works just fine for the quantum computer to be remotely somewhere and use the internet and cloud computing to access that. [If] you think about your cell phone right now, that’s basically what you are doing. Your cellphone is an interface device and all the big computing is done in a datacenters. We think that’s probably the right model in going forward in the future.”

The report is best read directly and is available as a free PDF. It will be interesting to monitor how closely this report hits or misses the mark.

Member of the Academies’ Committee on Technical Assessment of the Feasibility and Implications of Quantum Computing, which prepared the report: Mark A. Horowitz, NAE, Stanford University, chair; Alán Aspuru-Guzik, University of Toronto;
David D. Awschalom, NAS/NAE, University of Chicago; Bob Blakley, Citigroup; Dan Boneh, NAE, Stanford University;
Susan N. Coppersmith, NAS, University of Wisconsin, Madison; Jungsang Kim, Duke University;
John M. Martinis, Google; Margaret Martonosi, Princeton University;
Michele Mosca, University of Waterloo;
William D. Oliver, Massachusetts Institute of Technology; Krysta Svore, Microsoft Research; Umesh V. Vazirani, NAS, University of California, Berkeley

Images/Figures Source: Quantum Computing: Progress and Prospects report from the National Academies of Science, Engineering, and Medicine, 12/3/18

Link to report: https://www.nap.edu/catalog/25196/quantum-computing-progress-and-prospects

Link to press release: http://www8.nationalacademies.org/onpinews/newsitem.aspx?RecordID=25196&_ga=2.224720602.191491450.1544026218-508219378.1544026218

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

NIST/Xanadu Researchers Report Photonic Quantum Computing Advance

March 3, 2021

Researchers from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and Xanadu, a young Canada-based quantum computing company, have reported developing a full-stack, photonic quantum computer able to carry out th Read more…

By John Russell

Can Deep Learning Replace Numerical Weather Prediction?

March 3, 2021

Numerical weather prediction (NWP) is a mainstay of supercomputing. Some of the first applications of the first supercomputers dealt with climate modeling, and even to this day, the largest climate models are heavily con Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

HPE Names Justin Hotard New HPC Chief as Pete Ungaro Departs

March 2, 2021

HPE CEO Antonio Neri announced today (March 2, 2020) the appointment of Justin Hotard as general manager of HPC, mission critical solutions and labs, effective immediately. Hotard replaces long-time Cray exec Pete Ungaro Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

ORNL’s Jeffrey Vetter on How IRIS Runtime will Help Deal with Extreme Heterogeneity

March 2, 2021

Jeffery Vetter is a familiar figure in HPC. Last year he became one of the new section heads in a reorganization at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. He had been founding director of ORNL's Future Technologies Group which i Read more…

By John Russell

HPC Career Notes: March 2021 Edition

March 1, 2021

In this monthly feature, we’ll keep you up-to-date on the latest career developments for individuals in the high-performance computing community. Whether it’s a promotion, new company hire, or even an accolade, we’ Read more…

By Mariana Iriarte

AWS Solution Channel

Moderna Accelerates COVID-19 Vaccine Development on AWS

Marcello Damiani, Chief Digital and Operational Excellence Officer at Moderna, joins Todd Weatherby, Vice President of AWS Professional Services Worldwide, for a discussion on developing Moderna’s COVID-19 vaccine, scaling systems to enable global distribution, and leveraging cloud technologies to accelerate processes. Read more…

Supercomputers Enable First Holistic Model of SARS-CoV-2, Showing Spike Proteins Move in Tandem

February 28, 2021

Most models of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, hone in on key features of the virus: for instance, the spike protein. Some of this is attributable to the relative importance of those features, but most Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Can Deep Learning Replace Numerical Weather Prediction?

March 3, 2021

Numerical weather prediction (NWP) is a mainstay of supercomputing. Some of the first applications of the first supercomputers dealt with climate modeling, and Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

HPE Names Justin Hotard New HPC Chief as Pete Ungaro Departs

March 2, 2021

HPE CEO Antonio Neri announced today (March 2, 2020) the appointment of Justin Hotard as general manager of HPC, mission critical solutions and labs, effective Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

ORNL’s Jeffrey Vetter on How IRIS Runtime will Help Deal with Extreme Heterogeneity

March 2, 2021

Jeffery Vetter is a familiar figure in HPC. Last year he became one of the new section heads in a reorganization at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. He had been f Read more…

By John Russell

HPC Career Notes: March 2021 Edition

March 1, 2021

In this monthly feature, we’ll keep you up-to-date on the latest career developments for individuals in the high-performance computing community. Whether it Read more…

By Mariana Iriarte

African Supercomputing Center Inaugurates ‘Toubkal,’ Most Powerful Supercomputer on the Continent

February 25, 2021

Historically, Africa hasn’t exactly been synonymous with supercomputing. There are only a handful of supercomputers on the continent, with few ranking on the Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Japan to Debut Integrated Fujitsu HPC/AI Supercomputer This Spring

February 25, 2021

The integrated Fujitsu HPC/AI Supercomputer, Wisteria, is coming to Japan this spring. The University of Tokyo is preparing to deploy a heterogeneous computing Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Xilinx Launches Alveo SN1000 SmartNIC

February 24, 2021

FPGA vendor Xilinx has debuted its latest SmartNIC model, the Alveo SN1000, with integrated “composability” features that allow enterprise users to add their own custom networking functions to supplement its built-in networking. By providing deep flexibility... Read more…

By Todd R. Weiss

ASF Keynotes Showcase How HPC and Big Data Have Pervaded the Pandemic

February 24, 2021

Last Thursday, a range of experts joined the Advanced Scale Forum (ASF) in a rapid-fire roundtable to discuss how advanced technologies have transformed the way humanity responded to the COVID-19 pandemic in indelible ways. The roundtable, held near the one-year mark of the first... Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Julia Update: Adoption Keeps Climbing; Is It a Python Challenger?

January 13, 2021

The rapid adoption of Julia, the open source, high level programing language with roots at MIT, shows no sign of slowing according to data from Julialang.org. I Read more…

By John Russell

Esperanto Unveils ML Chip with Nearly 1,100 RISC-V Cores

December 8, 2020

At the RISC-V Summit today, Art Swift, CEO of Esperanto Technologies, announced a new, RISC-V based chip aimed at machine learning and containing nearly 1,100 low-power cores based on the open-source RISC-V architecture. Esperanto Technologies, headquartered in... Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Azure Scaled to Record 86,400 Cores for Molecular Dynamics

November 20, 2020

A new record for HPC scaling on the public cloud has been achieved on Microsoft Azure. Led by Dr. Jer-Ming Chia, the cloud provider partnered with the Beckman I Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Programming the Soon-to-Be World’s Fastest Supercomputer, Frontier

January 5, 2021

What’s it like designing an app for the world’s fastest supercomputer, set to come online in the United States in 2021? The University of Delaware’s Sunita Chandrasekaran is leading an elite international team in just that task. Chandrasekaran, assistant professor of computer and information sciences, recently was named... Read more…

By Tracey Bryant

NICS Unleashes ‘Kraken’ Supercomputer

April 4, 2008

A Cray XT4 supercomputer, dubbed Kraken, is scheduled to come online in mid-summer at the National Institute for Computational Sciences (NICS). The soon-to-be petascale system, and the resulting NICS organization, are the result of an NSF Track II award of $65 million to the University of Tennessee and its partners to provide next-generation supercomputing for the nation's science community. Read more…

10nm, 7nm, 5nm…. Should the Chip Nanometer Metric Be Replaced?

June 1, 2020

The biggest cool factor in server chips is the nanometer. AMD beating Intel to a CPU built on a 7nm process node* – with 5nm and 3nm on the way – has been i Read more…

By Doug Black

Top500: Fugaku Keeps Crown, Nvidia’s Selene Climbs to #5

November 16, 2020

With the publication of the 56th Top500 list today from SC20's virtual proceedings, Japan's Fugaku supercomputer – now fully deployed – notches another win, Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Gordon Bell Special Prize Goes to Massive SARS-CoV-2 Simulations

November 19, 2020

2020 has proven a harrowing year – but it has produced remarkable heroes. To that end, this year, the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) introduced the Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Leading Solution Providers

Contributors

Texas A&M Announces Flagship ‘Grace’ Supercomputer

November 9, 2020

Texas A&M University has announced its next flagship system: Grace. The new supercomputer, named for legendary programming pioneer Grace Hopper, is replacing the Ada system (itself named for mathematician Ada Lovelace) as the primary workhorse for Texas A&M’s High Performance Research Computing (HPRC). Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Saudi Aramco Unveils Dammam 7, Its New Top Ten Supercomputer

January 21, 2021

By revenue, oil and gas giant Saudi Aramco is one of the largest companies in the world, and it has historically employed commensurate amounts of supercomputing Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

Intel Xe-HP GPU Deployed for Aurora Exascale Development

November 17, 2020

At SC20, Intel announced that it is making its Xe-HP high performance discrete GPUs available to early access developers. Notably, the new chips have been deplo Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

Intel Teases Ice Lake-SP, Shows Competitive Benchmarking

November 17, 2020

At SC20 this week, Intel teased its forthcoming third-generation Xeon "Ice Lake-SP" server processor, claiming competitive benchmarking results against AMD's second-generation Epyc "Rome" processor. Ice Lake-SP, Intel's first server processor with 10nm technology... Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

New Deep Learning Algorithm Solves Rubik’s Cube

July 25, 2018

Solving (and attempting to solve) Rubik’s Cube has delighted millions of puzzle lovers since 1974 when the cube was invented by Hungarian sculptor and archite Read more…

By John Russell

Livermore’s El Capitan Supercomputer to Debut HPE ‘Rabbit’ Near Node Local Storage

February 18, 2021

A near node local storage innovation called Rabbit factored heavily into Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory’s decision to select Cray’s proposal for its CORAL-2 machine, the lab’s first exascale-class supercomputer, El Capitan. Details of this new storage technology were revealed... Read more…

By Tiffany Trader

It’s Fugaku vs. COVID-19: How the World’s Top Supercomputer Is Shaping Our New Normal

November 9, 2020

Fugaku is currently the most powerful publicly ranked supercomputer in the world – but we weren’t supposed to have it yet. The supercomputer, situated at Japan’s Riken scientific research institute, was scheduled to come online in 2021. When the pandemic struck... Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

African Supercomputing Center Inaugurates ‘Toubkal,’ Most Powerful Supercomputer on the Continent

February 25, 2021

Historically, Africa hasn’t exactly been synonymous with supercomputing. There are only a handful of supercomputers on the continent, with few ranking on the Read more…

By Oliver Peckham

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
HPCwire