Dell, AMD, IBM, and Strangeworks Dig into Quantum’s Future

By John Russell

October 27, 2022

What’s the quantum computing fuss all about? Should you jump into the game or run as fast as you can away from it? A fascinating panel with committed quantum players, IBM and Strangeworks, and traditional computing powerhouses, Dell (systems) and AMD (chips), tackled this topic at the HPC + AI on Wall Street conference held earlier this fall.

Ostensibly about quantum computing’s potential in financial services, the panel quickly turned into a broader examination of quantum computing today, expectations for the future, along with a few suggestions for how to build a quantum initiative without breaking the bank. The moderator was Jay Boisseau, HPC & AI technology strategist, Dell. Panelists included: Robert Hormuth, corporate vice president, Architecture & Strategy of the Data Center Solutions Group, AMD; Aparna Prabhakar, IBM, vice president Quantum Partner & Alliances; and William Hurley, founder and CEO, Strangeworks.

The conversation was wide-ranging and covered: quantum computing’s place in the HPC landscape; early quantum successes (think machine learning) early architectures (think GPUs and QPUs); ongoing challenges (think data movement and memory); the reality that quantum computing will be a hybrid classical-quantum creature; and more. One of the more interesting ideas generally agreed upon was that quantum computing must do more than simply speed up tasks we already do – “Quantum should unlock net new workloads. If it doesn’t, then we shouldn’t be in this business. Simple as that,” said IBM’s Prabhakar.

There was even a light-hearted banter around what to call “classical” computing as quantum computing moves forward. (No surprise – quantum vanguarder Hurley likes the term “vintage”!)

What wasn’t in question is the burst of interest in quantum computing.

“At Dell, I’ve noticed that about three years ago, when I talked to our strategic customers maybe one in 10 asked me about quantum computing. About two years ago, it was one-in-five but now it’s certainly more than half; I’m not going to say it’s all yet, but almost all of our most strategic HPC customers,” said Boisseau.

Jay Boisseau, Dell

Big supercomputing centers are also catching quantum fever. “The National Energy Research Supercomputing Center (NERSC) did a quick evaluation of their workloads and estimated that half of their workloads could be accelerated greatly by quantum. I said, ‘Well, how did you do that?’ and my friend there said, “Well, frankly, very crudely, and simply, we use the Feynman approach. We said, if the problem is a quantum problem, then a quantum computer can, in theory, be made to solve that problem better. It turns out many of the interesting research problems we have are not at the atomic level anymore but at the quantum level.’” said Boisseau.

Expectations are indeed broadly soaring. JPMorgan Chase has taken the plunge in a big way (see HPCwire article, JPMorgan Chase Bets Big on Quantum Computing). Let’s be clear, no one is arguing quantum computing is ready for prime time today. It isn’t. But there’s a growing consensus it will be ready soon for at least a few narrow applications. Those companies already in the race argue that companies taking a go-slow approach will be left behind.

Hurley said, “If you’re going to take a wait-and-see attitude, you’re probably going to be crushed by some competitive force using quantum computing. I like to think 2023 is like 1963. By 1963, the integrated circuit had kind of come into play, you know, things were kind of taking off. I think 2023 with the number of qubits that companies like IBM have been able to grow over the time – we’ve worked together with them from 17 to 433 qubits – this is the time period where new, not billionaires, but trillionaires will be made.”

Ok then. Before digging into discussion highlights, here are three sets of stage-setting comments from IBM, Strangeworks, and AMD. Not surprisingly, IBM and Strangeworks are all-in on quantum. AMD’s Hormuth is more circumspect:

Is IBM’s Long View Starting to Pay Off?

Aparna Prabhakar, IBM

“In 2016, our CEO came to us and said, hey, when can I see revenue on Quantum? What should we do with this thing called Quantum which is sitting in our research? We sat down and had the conversation about this is going to be an investment…and it was a strategic decision made from a long-term perspective,” recalled Prabhakar.

“I’m betting my career on it, [but] that’s a different story. Today, we have 190 clients in our ecosystem of which a fair number are governments. I’m thinking national labs, but also international. We also have private institutes and around 20 enterprises in our ecosystem, and about 30 to 40 startups. We are very selective about who we let in this ecosystem because the issue is not who wants to work with us, the issue is we have limited resources. From a finance perspective, there’s so much IP, which still has to be created, there’s so many unknowns in that space, that you should be there right now and thinking about it in two senses – one is the business impact, and the other is the technology impact.”

Overall, “We have around 430,000 users, [have run] 1.3 trillion executions, have a fleet of 22 systems, and a whole team focused around making quantum a reality and advancing the quantum computer.”

Strangeworks Says the Quantum Glass is Overflowing

William Hurley, Strangeworks

“From 2000 to around 2013 or 2014, there was only about $700 million invested in quantum computing. Then in 2014, and 2015, 15 different companies did 40 equity rounds for a total of a little over a billion bucks. Okay. And that was seen as kind of one of the big inflection points. Last year, $3.2 billion was invested in quantum computing, a billion of it in the last quarter. This year, almost a billion in the first quarter already. We’ll probably surpass that number by an order of magnitude. When we first started Strangeworks in 2018, there was $20 billion in government and everyone invested worldwide. Since then, in less than five years, an additional $10 billion has been pumped into it,” said Hurley.

“So, is [quantum computing] getting the air it needs to grow and the water and all that stuff? It definitely is. The thing I would say to think about is not just the finance going into pushing the technology, and how you can use it as a financial technology, but think about completely new uses. This is unexplored territory. You know, pessimists thought it’s 20 years out when I started; now pessimists think it’s five to 10 years out. Optimists thought it was five years out, now think it’s a year or two. We have customers paying us to use quantum computers to do real world work, right now, today. They are very conservative customers in pharmaceutical and in government, and they’re not people who willy-nilly are throwing money around,” said Hurley.

AMD – Classical Computing is Hardly Done.

Robert Hormuth, AMD

“I’m going to add a little bit of a counter view. Moore’s law is not dead. We’re finding ways to push transistor density. We’re finding ways to be more energy efficient. We’re tackling more advanced packaging, wafer level packaging. So, traditional computers have a way to go. I do agree that quantum will coexist in HPC; it’s just another accelerator,” said Hormuth.

On investment, Hormuth said, “You know, big investment does not always mean success. There are plenty of examples in the industry where there was another non x86 64-bit architecture that invested billions and billions and billions, and ended up not being able to succeed. You know the industry has probably poured in, I don’t know, $20 billion into different kinds of persistent memory, phase change memory, things of that nature. That looked pretty good on paper, and some of it worked pretty well, and the last guy standing in that field kind of just shut that down recently.

“I would caution us that a billion dollars here and there does not mean success when there are big commercial companies that invested $20-$30 billion into product lines that couldn’t make them commercial. When we mean commercially viable, it’s got to be at a scale. Building one or two or 100 or 1,000 machines is great. But we’ve got to think bigger if it’s going to be commercially viable and successful, it’s got to be at a scale to the masses. If it’s just in a couple of ivory towers, and academia or governments, and all the government’s care about is cracking RSA. Is that a commercial viable success? I don’t know.”

Strangeworks, founded in 2018, may be the least well-known of the panel companies, at least outside the quantum industry where it is well-known. The company develops software tools for quantum resources, has built a quantum community for education and idea exchange, and works with a host of quantum hardware companies providing access to their resources. Among the panelists, Hurley was perhaps the most unambiguous advocate.

“When we started, I used to joke with our investors, ‘What does Strangeworks do? We write software for computers that don’t exist.’ Then a couple years later it was, ‘We write software for you know, they’re not really computers but are kind of good lab equipment for exploring the quantum landscape.’ Now, almost five years in I can’t say that anymore. Are they the most amazing general purpose quantum computers in the world? Absolutely not. Are they light years over where they were last year and the year before that? Absolutely,” said Hurley.

The full conversation is best watched directly. Here’s a link to the session video. Presented below are a few topics highlighted by the panel.

What Does Early FS Success Look Like?

Besides simply getting quantum computers to work, there are many questions about what financial applications will be able to actually do better on quantum systems than classical resources. Optimization is often touted, but perhaps wrongly so, said IBM’s Prabhakar.

“There are basically three areas which are interesting: there’s simulating nature, there is optimization, and then there is machine learning,” said Prabhakar. “Initially, when we started working with banks, right – JPMC is a client of ours as is Goldman Sachs and others – they started looking at optimization. But it was very clear that there are classical methods which are actually advancing as quickly in optimization. So, if you’d asked me three years ago, my answer would have been optimization. Now we are realizing it’s not optimization, it’s probably machine learning-based analysis, which are going to have first early use cases.

“If you look at the work our clients are doing, you will see that a lot of them are actually not making the decision right now on which of these three areas they want to work on. They’re doing proof of concepts, but they’ve made the most advances in credit analysis, risk analysis, using machine learning, and quantum machine learning specifically. They have small teams which are looking still at optimization and figuring out how do they take their workflows, break it into classical and quantum parts, and stitch them together? There’s a lot of work how do you integrate these,” she said.

Hurley tended to agree, “In December, John Preskill (Caltech) and his team released a paper showing that you could do exponential speedups on machine learning, right. So, they used 40 superconducting qubits. They ran about 1,300 experiments, and they definitively proved there is a quantum advantage to be gained with machine learning. Clearly, machine learning is very important. That would be the first one that would be the most impactful [in FS], because I have not talked to a finance company that is not applying machine learning to all manner of things from risk management, to portfolio optimization, etc. There’s a speedup that is demonstrable right there.”

Courtesy of Marco Pistoia (JPMorgan Chase), a keynote speaker at HPC + AI Wall Street

Quantum’s Place in the HPC Landscape

In one sense, all quantum computing is hybrid – classical computers are required to process the input to and results from quantum computers. But beyond that, most observers think most quantum computing will be hybrid and involve partitioning programs into pieces that are solved on the appropriate quantum or classical resource before being incorporated into a final result. In today’s NISQ (near-term intermediate scale noisy quantum) computer era, the hybrid architecture typically centers on GPUs and QPUs. Quantum simply becomes part of the HPC world.

This shouldn’t seem strange, noted Boisseau, “HPC means just that: literally high performance computing. So, quantum will be a branch of high performance computing. Many people equate HPC with clusters. But you know, Bob Sorenson (Hyperion Research analyst) got up here [at the conference] and talked about using HPC in 1981. I was [doing the same] shortly thereafter, and those were parallel vector machines and then there were MPPs, like the Connection Machine and IBM Blue Gene. Then we saw cluster computing starting in 1994, with Thomas Sterling and Don Becker. To me, as an HPC person, I see this as a natural extension, an evolution of technologies in HPC. I consider this just a new branch of HPC.”

True enough, but given quantum computing’s early stage, it is easy to be confused about what hybrid means.

IBM Eagle Quantum QPU

“You have to be careful with the word hybrid because some of the hardware manufacturers are taking classical and quantum processors and bump-bonding them into hybrids so it’s all one thing. Others are using classical infrastructure, working with GPUs from companies like AMD and Nvidia next to the quantum machine. You have to be very cautious because there’s latency issues with each one of those,” said Hurley.

What does it look like now? “We have several customers who use GPUs, and even analog compute in a chain with quantum computing. They have something they’re doing only the quantum processor can do, and they’re taking those results and sending them back out to other resources. Usually what that looks like is classical GPUs and quantum QPUs,” said Hurley.

“I think defining ‘hybrid’ is a really important part of the conversation,” he added. “Are you talking about hybrid at the actual chip level, are you talking about hybrid in the infrastructure level, are you talking about hybrid being a quantum-inspired algorithm [and] there’s no quantum computer in the chain at all, it’s just running on classical system, but you couldn’t have come to that algorithm without a quantum [predecessor]?”

Prabhakar noted, “First, quantum can’t store your data. Let’s be very clear about that. In some ways, what you’re really doing is sending a query and getting back an answer. It’s like – I don’t know how many of you are Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy fans – what is the answer to the universe? It’s 42. Right. You get one answer back. Our enterprise clients are actually using their GPU clusters on-prem [with IBM-hosted QPUs on its network]. Latency is today not an issue, because this is the discovery phase and they’re building proof of concepts. The second thing to draw clarity to is that quantum is not production-ready right now. What people are really doing is building the first use cases, actually experimenting and doing things.”

“What we are doing however, with these enterprises and clients, is actually looking at something that we’re calling the orchestration layer. It’s very similar to what you do with HPC. But you’re orchestrating your workloads with your HPC workloads and figuring out how all of them work together. That’s an active area of work, which we are doing, and that’s what I think of as hybrid environments. Right now, we’re not as much thinking about latency because those problems don’t exist honestly. If you can get your compute done, instead of days, in five seconds, do you really care about latency at that point? Not as yet,” said Prabhakar.

She noted further, “We are bringing forward the concept of quantum serverless. Now that HPC is thinking about serverless concepts and how to introduce that [broadly] I think quantum intersects really nicely with that. We are looking at how do you do that and working with our HPC counterparts in national labs to think about what does quantum serverless actually mean? When you think about CPU, you think about GPU? How do you think about QPU, your quantum processing unit in that paradigm?”

AMD, said Hormuth, is a quantum fan to the extent it “generally has a lot of HPC compute.” They go hand-in-hand and AMD could be a component supplier. “From an AMD perspective, we’ve been a leader in chiplet-based technology, and if there is a quantum chiplet that comes along that makes sense to integrate into a traditional classical computer, we’re, we’re well along that journey.”

Boisseau said, “Even Dell, a company that is a traditional classical computing company has absolutely embraced the need for moving into quantum. The Dell research guys have worked with IBM, they’ve worked with IonQ. We recognize that we’re not the ones that make native quantum computing hardware, just as we don’t make the processors that Robert’s company (AMD) makes. But we make solutions for customers and we recognize that those future solutions are going to involve quantum in some way.”

To Get Started, Find a Champion

 A key question for would-be quantum users is how to get started. Both Prabhakar and Hurley had advice.

“From our experience with our quantum network, and usually at enterprise, the way it starts, is you actually have a champion,” Prabhakar. “Next, there’s a lot of resources out there, which are free and accessible, where you can get started with your teams right now. The number one thing to do is to have the champion – most of these enterprises who are working with us started with a champion who started with free resources and started engaging with other providers, be it IBM or anybody else.

“Figure out what is hype, because there’s a lot of hype around quantum and you can get on the wrong track very quickly. So, understand how you net that out. And there are short term benefits to quantum let’s be clear. There’s patents to be had. There’s IP to be made. There’s discovery. We (IBM) are in the optimistic group and [think] in the next one or two years, you should see the first use-cases emerge.”

Hurley’s advice was similar. Leverage free resources to start. “On that note, we recently released with the World Bank and Linux Foundation a free quantum training course that you can get from the Linux Foundation. If you want to start with those educational materials, it’s a free course and you can learn about how it [quantum computing] works, the physics level, the programming, the computers, and different architectures.”

He pointed out many quantum tech suppliers have tools they offer. IBM, for example, has Qiskit (quantum SDK), which is open source, free, and has simulators. The point, said Hurley, is “you don’t need to go find a million-dollar budget to get started, even with a company as big as IBM.”

Link to conference session video, https://www.hpcaiwallstreet.com/conference/quantum-is-coming/ 

Subscribe to HPCwire's Weekly Update!

Be the most informed person in the room! Stay ahead of the tech trends with industy updates delivered to you every week!

Quantum Riches and Hardware Diversity Are Discouraging Collaboration

November 28, 2022

Quantum computing is viewed as a technology for generations, and the spoils for the winners are huge, but the diversity of technology is discouraging collaboration, an Intel executive said last week. There are close t Read more…

2022 Road Trip: NASA Ames Takes Off

November 25, 2022

I left Dallas very early Friday morning after the conclusion of SC22. I had a race with the devil to get from Dallas to Mountain View, Calif., by Sunday. According to Google Maps, this 1,957 mile jaunt would be the longe Read more…

2022 Road Trip: Sandia Brain Trust Sounds Off

November 24, 2022

As the 2022 Great American Supercomputing Road Trip carries on, it’s Sandia’s turn. It was a bright sunny day when I rolled into Albuquerque after a high-speed run from Los Alamos National Laboratory. My interview su Read more…

2022 HPC Road Trip: Los Alamos

November 23, 2022

With SC22 in the rearview mirror, it’s time to get back to the 2022 Great American Supercomputing Road Trip. To refresh everyone’s memory, I jumped in the car on November 3rd and headed towards SC22 in Dallas, stoppi Read more…

Chipmakers Looking at New Architecture to Drive Computing Ahead

November 23, 2022

The ability to scale current computing designs is reaching a breaking point, and chipmakers such as Intel, Qualcomm and AMD are putting their brains together on an alternate architecture to push computing forward. The chipmakers are coalescing around the new concept of sparse computing, which involves bringing computing to data... Read more…

AWS Solution Channel

Shutterstock 110419589

Thank you for visiting AWS at SC22

Accelerate high performance computing (HPC) solutions with AWS. We make extreme-scale compute possible so that you can solve some of the world’s toughest environmental, social, health, and scientific challenges. Read more…

 

shutterstock_1431394361

AI and the need for purpose-built cloud infrastructure

Modern AI solutions augment human understanding, preferences, intent, and even spoken language. AI improves our knowledge and understanding by delivering faster, more informed insights that fuel transformation beyond anything previously imagined. Read more…

QuEra’s Quest: Build a Flexible Neutral Atom-based Quantum Computer

November 23, 2022

Last month, QuEra Computing began providing access to its 256-qubit, neutral atom-based quantum system, Aquila, from Amazon Braket. Founded in 2018, and built on technology developed at Harvard and MIT, QuEra, is one of Read more…

Quantum Riches and Hardware Diversity Are Discouraging Collaboration

November 28, 2022

Quantum computing is viewed as a technology for generations, and the spoils for the winners are huge, but the diversity of technology is discouraging collaborat Read more…

2022 HPC Road Trip: Los Alamos

November 23, 2022

With SC22 in the rearview mirror, it’s time to get back to the 2022 Great American Supercomputing Road Trip. To refresh everyone’s memory, I jumped in the c Read more…

QuEra’s Quest: Build a Flexible Neutral Atom-based Quantum Computer

November 23, 2022

Last month, QuEra Computing began providing access to its 256-qubit, neutral atom-based quantum system, Aquila, from Amazon Braket. Founded in 2018, and built o Read more…

SC22’s ‘HPC Accelerates’ Plenary Stresses Need for Collaboration

November 21, 2022

Every year, SC has a theme. For SC22 – held last week in Dallas – it was “HPC Accelerates”: a theme that conference chair Candace Culhane said reflected Read more…

Quantum – Are We There (or Close) Yet? No, Says the Panel

November 19, 2022

For all of its politeness, a fascinating panel on the last day of SC22 – Quantum Computing: A Future for HPC Acceleration? – mostly served to illustrate the Read more…

RISC-V Is Far from Being an Alternative to x86 and Arm in HPC

November 18, 2022

One of the original RISC-V designers this week boldly predicted that the open architecture will surpass rival chip architectures in performance. "The prediction is two or three years we'll be surpassing your architectures and available performance with... Read more…

Gordon Bell Special Prize Goes to LLM-Based Covid Variant Prediction

November 17, 2022

For three years running, ACM has awarded not only its long-standing Gordon Bell Prize (read more about this year’s winner here!) but also its Gordon Bell Spec Read more…

2022 Gordon Bell Prize Goes to Plasma Accelerator Research

November 17, 2022

At the awards ceremony at SC22 in Dallas today, ACM awarded the 2022 ACM Gordon Bell Prize to a team of researchers who used four major supercomputers – inclu Read more…

Nvidia Shuts Out RISC-V Software Support for GPUs 

September 23, 2022

Nvidia is not interested in bringing software support to its GPUs for the RISC-V architecture despite being an early adopter of the open-source technology in its GPU controllers. Nvidia has no plans to add RISC-V support for CUDA, which is the proprietary GPU software platform, a company representative... Read more…

RISC-V Is Far from Being an Alternative to x86 and Arm in HPC

November 18, 2022

One of the original RISC-V designers this week boldly predicted that the open architecture will surpass rival chip architectures in performance. "The prediction is two or three years we'll be surpassing your architectures and available performance with... Read more…

AWS Takes the Short and Long View of Quantum Computing

August 30, 2022

It is perhaps not surprising that the big cloud providers – a poor term really – have jumped into quantum computing. Amazon, Microsoft Azure, Google, and th Read more…

Chinese Startup Biren Details BR100 GPU

August 22, 2022

Amid the high-performance GPU turf tussle between AMD and Nvidia (and soon, Intel), a new, China-based player is emerging: Biren Technology, founded in 2019 and headquartered in Shanghai. At Hot Chips 34, Biren co-founder and president Lingjie Xu and Biren CTO Mike Hong took the (virtual) stage to detail the company’s inaugural product: the Biren BR100 general-purpose GPU (GPGPU). “It is my honor to present... Read more…

Tesla Bulks Up Its GPU-Powered AI Super – Is Dojo Next?

August 16, 2022

Tesla has revealed that its biggest in-house AI supercomputer – which we wrote about last year – now has a total of 7,360 A100 GPUs, a nearly 28 percent uplift from its previous total of 5,760 GPUs. That’s enough GPU oomph for a top seven spot on the Top500, although the tech company best known for its electric vehicles has not publicly benchmarked the system. If it had, it would... Read more…

AMD Thrives in Servers amid Intel Restructuring, Layoffs

November 12, 2022

Chipmakers regularly indulge in a game of brinkmanship, with an example being Intel and AMD trying to upstage one another with server chip launches this week. But each of those companies are in different positions, with AMD playing its traditional role of a scrappy underdog trying to unseat the behemoth Intel... Read more…

JPMorgan Chase Bets Big on Quantum Computing

October 12, 2022

Most talk about quantum computing today, at least in HPC circles, focuses on advancing technology and the hurdles that remain. There are plenty of the latter. F Read more…

Using Exascale Supercomputers to Make Clean Fusion Energy Possible

September 2, 2022

Fusion, the nuclear reaction that powers the Sun and the stars, has incredible potential as a source of safe, carbon-free and essentially limitless energy. But Read more…

Leading Solution Providers

Contributors

UCIe Consortium Incorporates, Nvidia and Alibaba Round Out Board

August 2, 2022

The Universal Chiplet Interconnect Express (UCIe) consortium is moving ahead with its effort to standardize a universal interconnect at the package level. The c Read more…

Nvidia, Qualcomm Shine in MLPerf Inference; Intel’s Sapphire Rapids Makes an Appearance.

September 8, 2022

The steady maturation of MLCommons/MLPerf as an AI benchmarking tool was apparent in today’s release of MLPerf v2.1 Inference results. Twenty-one organization Read more…

Not Just Cash for Chips – The New Chips and Science Act Boosts NSF, DOE, NIST

August 3, 2022

After two-plus years of contentious debate, several different names, and final passage by the House (243-187) and Senate (64-33) last week, the Chips and Science Act will soon become law. Besides the $54.2 billion provided to boost US-based chip manufacturing, the act reshapes US science policy in meaningful ways. NSF’s proposed budget... Read more…

SC22 Unveils ACM Gordon Bell Prize Finalists

August 12, 2022

Courtesy of the schedule for the SC22 conference, we now have our first glimpse at the finalists for this year’s coveted Gordon Bell Prize. The Gordon Bell Pr Read more…

Intel Is Opening up Its Chip Factories to Academia

October 6, 2022

Intel is opening up its fabs for academic institutions so researchers can get their hands on physical versions of its chips, with the end goal of boosting semic Read more…

AMD Previews 400 Gig Adaptive SmartNIC SOC at Hot Chips

August 24, 2022

Fresh from finalizing its acquisitions of FPGA provider Xilinx (Feb. 2022) and DPU provider Pensando (May 2022) ), AMD previewed what it calls a 400 Gig Adaptive smartNIC SOC yesterday at Hot Chips. It is another contender in the increasingly crowded and blurry smartNIC/DPU space where distinguishing between the two isn’t always easy. The motivation for these device types... Read more…

AMD’s Genoa CPUs Offer Up to 96 5nm Cores Across 12 Chiplets

November 10, 2022

AMD’s fourth-generation Epyc processor line has arrived, starting with the “general-purpose” architecture, called “Genoa,” the successor to third-gen Eypc Milan, which debuted in March of last year. At a launch event held today in San Francisco, AMD announced the general availability of the latest Epyc CPUs with up to 96 TSMC 5nm Zen 4 cores... Read more…

Google Program to Free Chips Boosts University Semiconductor Design

August 11, 2022

A Google-led program to design and manufacture chips for free is becoming popular among researchers and computer enthusiasts. The search giant's open silicon program is providing the tools for anyone to design chips, which then get manufactured. Google foots the entire bill, from a chip's conception to delivery of the final product in a user's hand. Google's... Read more…

  • arrow
  • Click Here for More Headlines
  • arrow
HPCwire